Contribution
My Lords, I thank the Senior Deputy Speaker for initiating this debate. I am a little disappointed that there are not more people from the Government Benches here. I am speaking in a personal capacity as a former group Chief Whip. Apart from the Government Chief Whip here today, I have probably spent more time in the House in the last nine years at late hours than anybody else in this Room. I have some experience that I should like to share as to why I support the proposed new sitting times for Tuesdays and Wednesdays as a long overdue reform of the House.
The key question should be: will the revised hours improve the effectiveness and quality of our scrutiny work of the Government? In my view, of course it will because sitting late helps absolutely nobody. Few like it and most people vote with their feet anyway, and they are not here. That is the reality and 10 pm on a regular basis is too late, in my book. There is a slightly ridiculous system. Unless there is an agreement between the Whips, the Government have to keep 100 people here so that they are not ambushed and, if there is an agreement with the Opposition, 30 people here, to make sure that the House is not adjourned because it is not quorate.
The reality is that on most evenings, particularly after dinner, the number in the Chamber is down to about 20 on average. That is my experience and the number gets even lower as the evening goes on. You can end up some evenings—I have been there—as one of two on our Benches, two on the Government Benches and two on the Conservative Benches. That is the reality. Votes are hopeless after dinner. The Opposition should know that. We can rarely win a vote after dinner because everybody disappears. What is the effect of that?
Oppositions like to keep up the morale of their troops by wearing the Government down. I have done it. We feel good from wearing Ministers down by keeping them here late at night. But is this good for government? Is it good in practice? No, it is not. Does it improve government? No, it does not. One day, Oppositions will be in government and will realise that. Finishing at 8.30 pm will mean that more people will stay to see the day through. Votes will be more meaningful up to that time, whereas they are not after dinner on the current arrangements. We will not miss the scrutiny that we currently have after dinner. That is the reality.
There is one major concern against the change. I am surprised that the noble Lord, Lord Redwood, did not mention this but I will address it because that is what people say to me. They say, “We will meet earlier and still sit late”. That is what worries people, regardless of the change. We will have longer hours. That will be the reality. That is what people say. But this underestimates the power of convention in this self-regulating House and, indeed, the responsiveness of the usual channels. The Companion says that it is a firm convention for the House to finish at about 10 pm on a Monday through to a Wednesday, and 7 pm on Thursdays. This convention will change on Tuesdays and Wednesdays to 8.30 pm. The reality of that is that the usual channels will then be under pressure to keep to that, except for exceptional circumstances. Those normally happen when you are trying to finish a Bill and it just makes for convenience and to meet deadlines before a Prorogation. That is the reality.
Agreement is important in the usual channels, so people should understand. I know that the usual channels are often criticised and are a bit of a mystery. But one thing that is absolutely right in this House is that when relationships in the usual channels collapse, the House gets into a real mess. It is therefore important that in the usual channels—I was there and know what it is like—we always try to keep relationships together because it is a nightmare when those relationships break down. Eventually, it becomes so intolerable for people in the House that they call for the usual channels to meet and sort it out. When I was a Whip that is what we did.
Relationships in the usual channels are important and if the convention is 8.30 pm for the finish, the Government Chief Whip will be under pressure from the Opposition Whips to keep to that unless there are special circumstances, as they do now for 10 pm. I do not buy this argument that if we agree to an 8.30 pm finish and an earlier starting time we will actually lengthen the hours of the House. It will be up to the House, as a self-regulating House, to make sure that that does not happen. But I think, with the relationships of the usual channels as they are, that that argument will not wash.
That is the main argument I have heard against this change, but we have heard a few more from the noble Lord, Lord Redwood, so let me address some of them. We had them the last time we had this debate, and I remember debating with the now Lord Speaker, the noble Lord, Lord Forsyth, in quite difficult circumstances. Let us deal with each of the arguments put up by the noble Lord, Lord Redwood.
We were told that school visits would reduce by 4,000 or 5,000 pupils a year. We have an education centre. We have to adapt if it works for the working of the House to meet earlier. I think that by meeting earlier we will give more of an opportunity for pupils to stay for 1 pm, to see the proceedings happening, before they have to go back to school, whereas now they do not wait until 2.30 pm. They have the trip round the Chamber, but they probably do not stay for the proceedings. I do not buy the argument that school visits will be inconvenienced. We have to change, and they can be accommodated.
Catering budgets will suffer, we are told. We do not run the Lords to run a catering service. The needs of the House come first, I am afraid, and the catering service can adapt. In fact, if more people stay till 8.30 pm it will benefit, and more people may come in for lunch at a slightly earlier time. It will probably be easier to recruit staff. So I do not buy the catering argument.
Then we are told that having a slightly earlier time will hit people working outside the House. Well, 1 pm is a marginal change. People here mix and match what they do; they are on Select Committees, they go to other meetings in the House, they do outside work, and they deal with legislation. We mix and match the whole time. I think it is perfectly compatible with people working outside the House to have a 1 pm start. Anyway, not everybody is here when the House starts at 2.30 pm. People mix and match.
Then another argument we get is that camaraderie over the dining table is important. I thought the noble Baroness, Lady Morgan, was terrific in the debate we had back in 2022:
“Camaraderie comes because we work together … it does not come because we dine together”.—[Official Report, 5/7/22; col. 977.]
I agree with that.
Last time, the vote was quite close. It was ruined—I remember it well—because a couple of years before we had a vote that included Mondays for an early start, with the consequence that all our friends from Scotland and from distant places voted against that change to having an early start on Monday, Tuesday and Wednesday. We are not considering it this time. When we had the second vote in 2022, it was still slightly confused by that original debate. Indeed, the number of people who voted last time was really poor: 284. I am delighted that we have a consultation of more than 350 so far. I am looking forward to seeing what the consultation results show. I suspect that there is growing support for improved hours in the House.
Better hours will improve the working of the House and the effectiveness of scrutiny of the Government. That should be our major consideration. We should put more emphasis on improving scrutiny than simply wearing Governments or people down. If we have these earlier hours, we will stop the ridiculous situation where Peers are going home as public transport declines in the evening; indeed, some evenings, when we go very late, there is no public transport at all. We will make life better for people working in the House, and that will make it more attractive. We should make this change.