L

Lord Blencathra (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 22 October 2026

Debate

Sitting Times of the House

Contribution

My Lords, I too congratulate the noble Lord, Lord Ponsonby of Shulbrede, on initiating this important debate. I exempt him from any criticism I may make of this consultation and the process. I have in my hand here the entirety of the consultation process for changing the sitting hours of the second Chamber of the Parliament of the United Kingdom: two sides of a bit of paper. Neville Chamberlain returned from Munich waving a bit of paper and saying, “Peace for our time”. I wave this flimsy document and say, “Chaos for our time”, because, on the basis of this document, that is what we might get. This is not a consultation in any meaningful sense of the word. It is, in essence, a multiple-choice tick-box questionnaire: “Do we want Tuesday? Do we want Wednesday? Do we want both? Just tick the box, my Lords”. There is no requirement to consider the effect on legislative scrutiny; no requirement to consider the effect on committees or on staff; no requirement to consider the effect on Members who live outside London and cannot get home at night; no requirement to consider the effect on the culture of the House. We are simply asked which option we would prefer. Even more remarkably, the accompanying papers tell us that much of the analysis on service implications is still being processed, so only after we have ignorantly ticked the box will the Procedure Committee then figure out what changes will be made to committee sitting hours. Only afterwards will the Services Committee decide on what dining services to withdraw, because they will no longer be viable for the fewer Peers attending after 8.30 pm. What other serious changes to our practical operating procedures will have to be made and have not been mentioned in this rather scrappy document? We are being asked for our conclusions before the evidence has been assembled. That is not evidence-based policy making; it is policy-making backwards. I oppose these proposals, as noble Lords may have gathered, but I also oppose the process by which they are being advanced. I have a particular advantage and perhaps a particular burden in this debate. I served in the House of Commons both before and after the introduction of the so-called family-friendly hours. There are only two other Peers participating in this debate who have that experience, my noble friends Lady Laing of Elderslie and Lord Redwood; the vast majority of noble Lords in the House do not have that experience, but the three of us do. We witnessed the consequences at first hand. Supporters of those changes promised a more modern Parliament. What they did not foresee was the effect on parliamentary culture. The greatest losses were not measured in hours; they were measured in relationships. Before those changes, Members from all parties met informally throughout the day. We talked over breakfast, lunch and coffee. We talked while waiting for committees. Political opponents knew each other. After the introduction of the new hours, much of that slowly disappeared. The Commons dining rooms have become largely deserted on Tuesday and Wednesday evenings. Members rush from home to go straight on to a committee, first thing in the morning, and then on to the Chamber or one commitment after another, with no thinking time and no chance to talk to colleagues informally, even those on their own side. Cross-party contact diminished. Politics became more tribal. I think we would all agree that the Commons has become a harsher place in the past 25 years. The lesson I learned from that is simple: changing the clock changes the culture. Those advocating this proposal speak as though they are moving a hand on a watch. In reality, they are changing the character of an institution. Every Member of the House is equal, and every Member’s opinion deserves respect in this consultation. However, not every Member of the House of Lords possesses the same depth of experience of parliamentary procedure. For decisions of this magnitude, institutional memory matters. Those who served in Parliament before and after the Commons reforms possess direct evidence about what happens in practice. We witnessed the consequences. Likewise, Members who have spent many years in this House serving on committees, scrutinising legislation and participating in House business necessarily possess a deeper understanding of how procedural changes affect parliamentary effectiveness. There is one Member in this Committee who has 36 years’ experience of serving in the House of Lords. It is fortunate that that is the noble Lord, Lord Ponsonby of Shulbrede, the Senior Deputy Speaker—and, of course, the Government Chief Whip has 25 years’ experience.

More from Lord Blencathra (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.