L

Lord Moylan (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 22 October 2026

Debate

Sitting Times of the House

Contribution

For a proposition that was advocated for so much by the Labour Party, on that occasion there was consultation with management about whether the changes could be put into effect but no consultation with staff trade unions and staff associations about what the changes ought to be. Somebody—I am not sure who it was—shouted out just now from a sedentary position that there has been such consultation at the moment and trade unions and staff associations have been consulted. None of those responses have been vouchsafed to noble Lords. If that has taken place this time, as it should have done, perhaps we can see it. We should have seen it before we were invited to feed into the consultation. I am concerned about the change in the character of the House. There are those who wish to see membership of the House become a full-time, daytime job, like a nine-to-five job, in fact very much as the House of Commons has become. It is a perfectly respectable position to hold that view—if that is one’s view, that is absolutely fine—but the change in character of the House of Lords would be much more profound than the change that has occurred in the character of the House of Commons as a result of that. I am particularly concerned about the consequences for the age profile. We are an elderly House. I think it is to our discredit in the public mind that we are such an elderly House, because people look at us and think we are a bunch of old fogies. How do you persuade younger people to come into the House who might have careers—the people of experience and ability whom we wish to attract to this House—if doing so will preclude their external activities? Not everything everyone does is done to make a lot of money. Chairing a public body can be very time-consuming; two days a week is the normal sort of commitment made if someone is going to chair a major public body. We just had an appointment to the chairmanship of Great British Railways in the last few days—that is a two-day-a-week commitment. Sir John Kingman would not be able to accept an invitation to join this House if we became a full-time House, because he has to commit two days a week elsewhere to chairing Great British Railways. That is the sort of thing that becomes very difficult for people to do, especially if they are younger. It would mean great change and consequences for the age profile of the House, which worries me already. As I have said, any change such as this—which I oppose—is going to have little personal effect on me because of my own circumstances, so I think I can speak about it from a disinterested position. Other noble Lords have the opportunity to say for themselves through the consultation how it is going to affect them. What I took away from the speech of my noble friend Lord Redwood was that this change would not only affect other noble Lords. There are 10,000 people working on the Parliamentary Estate—of course, not all of them are at this end; the majority of them are working in relation to the other place. This change will affect a huge number of people who have happily tailored their lives to the existing working hours of your Lordships’ House. They will have their lives changed significantly, but we seem to be giving so little consideration to their interests, which seems to me a very great shame. Finally, I conclude with a question to the noble Lord, Lord Ponsonby, which he may want to pick up at the end, as to whether speeches made in the course of this debate are being fed formally into the consultation process. It would be a great pity if we all had this debate and gave our views, but then it was, so to speak, as nothing from the point of view of the consultation response.

More from Lord Moylan (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.