Contribution
My Lords, I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Hoey, for her regret amendment. I join the Minister and the noble Baroness, Lady Suttie, in expressing the condolences of these Benches to the people of Spain and to those affected by today’s tragic accident in Spain.
I start by acknowledging that the EU has a legitimate interest in railways that springs from the need for interoperability between national systems if its single market is to be perfected. It explains, for example, why the EU has been requiring adoption of a single signalling system throughout its realms. But that goal of interoperability is and will remain a complete chimera as far as Ireland is concerned. As the noble Lord has already explained, the Railway Regulation (Gauge) Act 1846 settled on a standard gauge of four foot, eight and a half inches for Great Britain and an Irish gauge of five foot, three inches for the railways of Ireland. For reasons too lengthy to explore now, the standard gauge was adopted in time throughout most of western Europe, while the Irish gauge established itself only in parts of Australia and Brazil—presumably there were Irish engineers there.
It follows that no European train, indeed no British train, could run in Ireland because it would not fit the tracks, even if the considerable difficulties of transporting it across the substantial body of water that separates Ireland from her nearest neighbour in the European Union could be overcome. The argument of interoperability for EU involvement in Ireland’s railways, north and south, therefore fails dismally.
These regulations replace for Northern Ireland alone the Railways (Interoperability) Regulations 2011, which have, until now, governed rail interoperability across the whole United Kingdom. It is worth stating that cross-border arrangements in Ireland—arrangements which include practical co-operation between railway authorities on both sides of the UK-Irish border—have never been criticised for a lack of effectiveness in the operation of Irish trains. I am sure there has very occasionally been cause for complaint, but generally the system works well. In the place of those regulations, Northern Ireland is to implement the 2016 EU directive, together with the technical specifications adopted under it.
Regulation 2 defines both the directive and those specifications as they are
“amended from time to time”.
Therefore, this is dynamic alignment in perpetuity. This means that the rules governing Northern Ireland’s railways will change not just today but in the future, whenever the European Commission chooses to change them, without any further Act of this Parliament and without any vote in the Northern Ireland Assembly. The mechanisms of democratic consent and the Stormont brake, whatever their merits, offer scant means of effective objection.
The Minister wants a single directing mind in charge of Great British Railways. He seems to be happy that it should be a single directing foreign mind based in Valenciennes, of all places, in charge of railways in the rest of the UK. I do not criticise my right honourable friend Rishi Sunak for not having the Railway Regulation (Gauge) Act 1846 at the front of his mind when he negotiated the Windsor Framework. None the less, it is not right that people in one part of the United Kingdom should be governed by rules in whose making they have no say. I would have expected the European Union, with its long-standing commitment to democratic norms, to be the first to understand that.
The regulations have some intriguing implications. They require the whole of Ireland to adopt the European rail traffic management system—the single European Union signalling system that will allow interoperability with trains that cannot get to Ireland and will not fit the tracks if they do. Why is the British taxpayer paying for this in respect of Northern Ireland? Is this what the people of Northern Ireland want? We will never know. There has been no public consultation; manufacturers, suppliers, those who work on the railway and, above all, passengers get no say. Can the Minister explain why? He has been asked this by a number of noble Lords.
We have never taken the view that the Windsor Framework was the final word or beyond improvement in what is an evolving situation. We will always look at constructive proposals for change and reform. One such proposal would have been persuading the European Union not to proceed with these frankly daft regulations. It would be good to hear from the Minister whether His Majesty’s Government ever approached Brussels with such a proposal. We need to ensure that legislation works for all parts of the United Kingdom; this does not. For that reason, if the noble Baroness divides the House, we will support her.