Contribution
My Lords, I do not wish to sound curmudgeonly or to cause any offence. I am speaking entirely personally, of course, and as a Roman Catholic. While I do not actively oppose the Bill to the point of wishing to table amendments to it in Committee, I am not entirely supportive of it either. The noble Baroness the Lord Privy Seal said that it was a narrow Bill and I propose to treat it narrowly and look at what it says, unlike some other noble Lords who have helpfully and illuminatingly spread their speeches across a broader canvas.
My first concern is to do with rushing constitutional legislation through Parliament. There is no need for this rush. We have had too much constitutional change over the last 30 years—too much of it ill considered and some of it rushed and not properly connected. A great deal of it should be reversed. Here we have another pattern of rushing ahead with a piece of constitutional change. I will come back to this question, but what is the reason for the rush? The Explanatory Notes say that it is because the Prime Minister is a Catholic. He is on the verge of exercising his constitutional duty and, if we do not pass this legislation, he will be precluded from exercising it.
So what change is the Bill going to make? We have already had it explained to us that, in effect, the Prime Minister acts as a postbox between a careful and cautious selection process carried out by the Church of England on the one hand and the monarch on the other. Is all that is going to happen that the postbox moves from one desk to another? If so, I ask myself, what is the import of the religious denomination of a postbox? It seems to me of no significance whatever. On the other hand, it is possible that there will be change. We have not explored this question because the arrangement reached with no public consultation—this is part of a pattern—by Gordon Brown that changed our constitutional arrangements on this matter is something that could be reversed. If it were to be reversed, I can see that the Prime Minister would be doing something where the denomination of the person doing it could have some significance. We have not quite been told: is there any intention to change current practice? If there is no intention, given that the function is essentially no more than a postbox, what is the rush?
No Catholic, as far as I am aware, has called for this change. This would be nowhere in the list of priorities that Catholics would like to see Parliament engage with, ideally on an urgent basis. Off the top of my head, there are about half a dozen things that I could think of, but one instance would be a greater level of support for our Catholic schools and their expansion. That would be highly appreciated by Catholics, since they suffer to some extent from a rather suspicious eye cast on them by a secular bureaucracy. That would be a priority for the Catholic Church, but this would be nowhere. No sensible Catholic would ever want to be involved in appointing Anglican bishops. I am not sure who would.
I say no Catholic would want to, but there is the possibility that there is one Catholic who has been asking for this to happen. The Prime Minister has said that he professes the Catholic faith. We do not entirely know how much he is personally the driver behind this Bill because, as the noble Baroness said, the process could easily be said to have been set in hand back in March 2025—it is part of a process. But then again, where is the urgency coming from in all of this?
I turn to what I think were the original intentions of those who made the legislation in the 19th century when they admitted Catholics to Parliament for the first time in a couple of hundred years—I will come to Jews later, if I may. Essentially, the Test Act that excluded Catholics was the post-Titus Oates one in the 1670s. Catholics could sit in Parliament until then. Then it was reversed in 1829, as has been recounted. I think the original intention was to try to ensure that, from that point, the monarch would still be advised by someone who was of the Anglican faith, or at least a Protestant Christian. Nobody at that time—it was a failure of the imagination, if you like—could conceive that there might ever be a Hindu or a Muslim Prime Minister. In 1829, Jews were still excluded from sitting in Parliament. In fact, atheists were also excluded until well into the 19th century and the Bradlaugh case. They were excluded by the oath because they could not take it, and the Charles Bradlaugh case changed that. In 1829, there was no prospect of an atheist Prime Minister any more than there was, in practice, of a Hindu or a Muslim Prime Minister. So the idea that you preserve the role of advising the monarch on Anglican appointments to an Anglican Prime Minister and adviser, or at the very least, a Protestant Christian, seems to me to be a sensible one.
The Bill, rather tendentiously, includes “Discriminatory” in the Short Title, but is it discriminatory? We discriminate all the time. It is bad and reprehensible discrimination if we exclude someone on grounds that are irrelevant, such as saying they cannot vote because of the colour of their skin, but is it really discriminatory to say that somebody advising on Anglican matters should be an Anglican? That seems pertinent to me.
None of my remarks relate, of course, to people of the Jewish faith, and I look forward to hearing my noble friend Lord Wolfson on that. However, I have some concerns, and I hope that some of my questions might be answered.