T

The Lord Bishop of Manchester

Speaking in the House of Lords on 10 November 2026

Debate

Church Appointments (Repeal of Discriminatory Provision) Bill

Contribution

My Lords, whether or not my robes add to or, as the noble Baroness, Lady Bottomley, asserts, detract from my contribution to the debate, I am pleased to speak in support of the Bill. I hope that my words will not be deemed left wing or “woke rubbish”, whatever may have been said of bishops in another place, or archaic, as the noble Lord, Lord Birt, just averred. I can, however, assure the noble Lord that I am no ayatollah. As he would not give way a few moments ago, I also need to assure your Lordships’ House that the Church of Scotland is not part of the Anglican Communion. Indeed, it does not have bishops. This is a modest but important Bill that brings our constitution to closer alignment with the values of modern Britain. The restriction preventing those who profess the Catholic or Jewish faiths from advising the crown on church appointments has its origins in a very different period. I and other Christians believe that God created humans equally and in his own image, each of us with inherent value and purpose. In a democracy, this is reflected in equal opportunity for participation in public and civic life—a right that must be defended regardless of faith or creed. The strength of our UK democracy is derived from the unique diversity of its participants. As a Member of this House, it is my proud vocation to support the interests of thriving and vibrant communities right across the diocese of Manchester. Manchester is a place where people of all faiths and none come together to participate in community life. If our democracy and communities are to continue to thrive, there can be no justification for retaining the discriminatory provision that the Bill seeks to repeal. That is why I am so pleased to support it. Indeed, it is precisely these principles that it is the duty of the established Church to uphold—a duty that is facilitated all the more by the unique relationship with the state that it has had since Reformation days. In practice, the appointments process for bishops will be unaffected by this Bill. The process is, as the noble Baroness, Lady Bottomley, assured us, led by the Church. Although the Prime Minister’s role in advising the sovereign is a constitutional duty, it does not, and has not now for quite some time, involve the exercise of personal choice between different candidates. However, that does not mean that the Prime Minister and his office are out of the picture. Their interests, on behalf of the nation, are represented on the Crown Nominations Commission through the Prime Minister’s appointments secretary. This person, though a non-voting member, is fully involved in the wide-ranging consultations that take place ahead of a nomination, and is present and able to participate fully in the conversations that take place during the commission’s meetings. I have every confidence that Manchester will be much blessed over the coming months, as I head towards my retirement, by the involvement of the Prime Minister’s appointments secretary in helping the city of Manchester and its surrounds to identify the right person to be the next bishop for that diocese. Considerable Downing Street involvement at that stage in the process is the proper route to ensuring that candidates can serve wider society at both diocesan and national level, while also serving the structures of the Church. I have been through these processes myself, 13 years ago. No process is perfect, but I think they are at least as robust as those by which Lords temporal arrive in your Lordships’ House. Once a name has emerged, with that Downing Street involvement, the secretary will convey it, together with a detailed rationale for the nomination, to the Prime Minister. The PM then seeks the assent of the nominee, before concluding it by forwarding the nomination on to the Crown. Those final processes may be formal, but they remain important because they are an expression of the constitutional relationship between Church and state. They do not require the Prime Minister personally to espouse any faith. Indeed, they are neither strengthened nor weakened by the religious affiliations of the person who happens to hold that office on any particular day. This establishment relationship is not designed for the Church of England to secure special privileges for itself. The established Church exists to serve people of all faiths and none; to create space for freedom and coexistence; to build bridges across diverse communities; and to encourage a mutual sense of responsibility to our neighbours, our communities and the wider world around us. I am not sure that that is what the ayatollahs in Iran do. In my diocese, I have chaired the Greater Manchester police ethics committee, a large housing association, the Manchester Homelessness Partnership, the GM faith and community leaders group and numerous other non-Church bodies. I will not even go into the things I have done at national Church level. My local church has worked to inspire social action, to foster belonging and to protect the free practice of all faiths in the UK. Beyond the appointment of bishops, as we have heard, there are certain other ecclesiastical appointments, such as to Crown livings, that may belong, primarily by patronage, to the First Lord of the Treasury, the Lord Chancellor or some other government or parliamentary officeholder. In practice, Downing Street officers exercise those functions on a day-to-day basis and take an active part in the proceedings. I or any of my colleagues—my right reverend friend the Bishop of Norwich is here with me—would be glad to bore noble Lords in the bar on some other occasion if they have interest in that amount of detail, but I would argue that it does not present your Lordships with any matters of concern. It is through its relationship with the state that our established Church is uniquely empowered to fulfil this vocational service. The repeal of this discriminatory provision will strengthen not only the important relationship between Church and state but the constitution itself, by better reflecting the principles of religious freedom and equal citizenship. I welcome the opportunity to support this Bill tonight.

More from The Lord Bishop of Manchester

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.