Contribution
My Lords, my Amendment 47 seeks safeguards that would require the verification of nationality and immigration status before an individual is automatically added to the electoral register.
I fully recognise and uphold the importance of ensuring that every person who is legally entitled to vote should have the uninterrupted opportunity to register and to participate fully in our democratic process. That is a fundamental right and has long distinguished us internationally. There is an equally important principle, however, which I fear risks being overlooked in this Bill—that only those who are legally entitled to vote should be entered on to the electoral register in the first place.
I fear that, left unamended, this part of the Bill will weaken the integrity of elections. Clause 17 introduces a significant change to our electoral arrangements. It would place a duty on electoral registration officers to register individuals automatically where certain conditions are met without those individuals having to make an application to register themselves. I recognise that there could be a potential administrative benefit in this, but it is for your Lordships to ask whether the safeguards accompanying this fundamental change are robust enough, especially on establishing nationality and immigration status.
In presenting Clause 17, the Government are attempting to allow for the modernisation of the system. I welcome that, but I caution that modernisation must never come at the expense of electoral integrity and that operational convenience must never take precedence over establishing voter eligibility. Therefore, through this amendment, I am seeking to introduce an additional safeguard that will require an electoral registration officer to positively verify that the person satisfies the relevant nationality requirements and, where applicable, the necessary immigration status before being registered.
The parliamentary franchise rightly extends to Irish citizens and qualifying Commonwealth citizens. Different nationality and residency requirements apply to other elections. An individual’s immigration status may determine whether they qualify for that registration. For example, a person may be lawfully resident in the United Kingdom in employment, paying taxes and accessing public services, without necessarily being entitled to vote in a particular election. That is not a criticism of the individual but simply a recognition that lawful residence and electoral entitlement are not the same thing. It is precisely why we must make sure that this Bill distinguishes between verifying someone’s identity and their electoral eligibility. A government database may confirm somebody’s name, address and date of birth. A national insurance number may assist in establishing identity. However, neither by itself necessarily establishes nationality or entitlement.
I have tabled this amendment as I am concerned that, as the Government move towards an automated system, we risk treating the existence of an administrative record as sufficient evidence of electoral eligibility. The Electoral Commission has emphasised that the success of registration will depend entirely on the accuracy and reliability of the underlying data, so that only eligible individuals are registered. Having been around the upper echelons of government and local government through much of my adult life, I must confess that an unquestioning faith in the accuracy of government-held data is something that I have not been able to acquire. This is not a question of the dedication of the many officials who maintain the system, but my experience over the years has taught me that our systems are far from infallible.
I also appreciate the responsibilities already placed upon the electoral registration officers. They have a mammoth task in maintaining the accuracy and completeness of the registers, often against a background of considerable administrative and financial pressure caused by a lack of local government funding. My amendment does not intend to place further obstacles in their path—quite the opposite. It would establish a statutory requirement, supported by prescribed evidence or information lawfully obtained from public authorities.
I would therefore be grateful if the Minister could address three questions. First, what arrangements would exist to distinguish between a person’s identity and their legal entitlement to vote when records are obtained from government departments and other public bodies? Secondly, will electoral registration officers have timely access to the information necessary to verify immigration status where it is relevant, and who will bear the administrative cost? Thirdly, what safeguards will prevent an individual being entered on to a register for an election in which they are not legally entitled to participate?