Lord Bridges of Headley (Con)

We hear some answers here from our Front Bench, and my noble friend Lord Howell discussed that point. Then there are the further pressures we will face: the noble Lord, Lord Browne, spoke about defence and welfare, and the noble Baronesses, Lady Cash and Lady Grey-Thompson, tackled the intergenerational issues. Each of those points merits debate in itself and deserves to be heard. What we did not hear today was assurances that taxes will not need to rise further; instead, we heard that the Government are sticking to their course, that they believe that debt is on a sustainable path and that we are able to weather the storm we are in. I dearly hope that I am proven wrong, for I fear that we lack a credible strategy for the problems we face. That brings me on to the bigger, more fundamental problem of philosophy and belief. If we truly want to tackle these challenges, we need to have a debate about the role of the state versus that of the individual. It boils down to a simple question: do we trust the state to do more to tackle these challenges? In which case, taxes may inexorably have to rise. If so, what will be the impact on our economy, competitiveness and growth? Alternatively, do we take a different course, and do we trust the people? If so, what does that mean for the social contract? Where does the boundary lie between the responsibilities of the state and the individual? These are enormous questions, which this debate on our report begins to open up. My deep concern is that we will continue to kick the can down the road and not have that debate, because all these challenges—all those Ds—come head-to-head with the other, massively bigger D: the D of democracy. Having this debate—and confronting these challenges—raises the enormous and, at times, tough and unpopular decisions and difficult trade-offs that have to be faced. However, if we do not have this debate, and we continue to try to tackle these problems piecemeal in an incoherent way, I fear that not only will the solutions fail but we will lack the legitimacy to take the action required. As the noble Lord, Lord King, said, we owe it to our children and grandchildren to muster the courage and have the honesty to confront these challenges now, so as to put our debt on a sustainable path before it becomes too late.