L

Lord Bridges of Headley (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 12 November 2026

Debate

Autumn Budget 2026

Contribution

My Lords, I start by congratulating those noble Lords who have given their maiden speeches today and welcome them to this House. It is invidious to pick out one of those noble Lords, but let me welcome the noble Baroness, Lady Ussher, to her place. Our paths have crossed in a professional capacity and it is a great pleasure to see her here—and I congratulate her on an extremely good speech. It would be churlish not to start by acknowledging today’s GDP figures, as the Minister did when he spoke. They are indeed welcome. My issue is what the Chancellor reads into them and, to a certain extent, what the Minister did. The Chancellor said this morning that the UK has “standout resilience”. I gently question that. Resilience rests on many things: strong defence—that is pretty obvious—but also a sustainable national debt, debt interest costs that are under control and a buffer to cushion the economy against shocks. Looking at the Budget and ahead into next year, on all the metrics that show whether our economy is indeed becoming more resilient, we are heading in the wrong direction. Everything we want to go down is going up, and everything we want to go up is going down. The forecast for growth next year: down. Living standards: down. Inflation: up. Unemployment: up. Debt: up. Debt interest: up. I completely concede that these forecasts may be overly pessimistic. The noble Lord, Lord O’Neill, is not in his place but, as he said, tough decisions are undoubtedly needed, no matter what happens, as regards spending. Here, as I have said before, I believe that this Government are taking the wrong decisions, or taking no decisions at all. That is weakening, not strengthening, our nation’s resilience. My noble friends Lord Lamont and Lord Howell both spoke about the rising costs of debt interest. I want to focus on another D: defence. I welcome the commitment by the Government, mentioned by the Minister, to increase defence spending to 3% of GDP by 2030-31. My question is whether we are doing enough and doing it speedily enough. Surely, if we were building a resilient nation, we would be accelerating the increase in defence spending while reducing welfare spending. But we are not. The OBR forecasts that defence spending will rise from 2.6% of GDP to 3% by 2030-31, with most of that increase—reportedly £11 billion—deferred until the final year. Meanwhile, annual spending on health and disability benefits will rise by £22.4 billion between 2026-27 and 2030-31. Whatever Mr Milburn might say about this in his review, the welfare bill will not come down in this Parliament. That is what the Chancellor said a couple of weeks ago; I would be grateful if the Minister could confirm today that that is still so. Secondly, what will this increase in defence spending be spent on? Our nuclear deterrent and programmes reportedly account for around one-fifth of the defence budget, with that share expected to rise. Pay, pensions and other costs add further pressures. How much of the additional defence spending will reach the conventional front line? Will spending on equipment, ammunition, training and operational readiness rise in real terms over the next four years? Thirdly, how is this increase in defence spending being paid for? Some £1.7 billion from the Treasury’s capital reserve is being used to fund the defence investment plan—note the phrase “capital reserve”. Can the Minister explain why investment in a planned defence programme, which the Government have known about for many months, is being funded from money set aside for unforeseen emergencies? Under what provision of the Treasury’s rules has this been authorised? How much genuinely uncommitted contingency remains to meet the next unforeseen shock? That brings us to the Chancellor’s wider fiscal strategy. There are many figures in the OBR’s report which show just how weak it is. If nominal GDP growth were just 0.1 percentage points lower each year, £5 billion of the £15 billion fiscal headroom would disappear. Overall, our fiscal buffer of £15 billion compares with an average of approximately £33 billion before November 2022, less than half the historical level. This illustrates a simple, worrying point: our finances are not resilient but fragile, with the Government putting off difficult decisions on spending, hoping something will turn up. More of the same is not good enough, the Prime Minister told his party conference. But that is precisely what this Budget gives us—more spending, more debt and more denial that we are spending beyond our means. Resilience is built before a crisis, not during one, and it is built by taking difficult decisions today, not leaving them for tomorrow.

More from Lord Bridges of Headley (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.