L

Lord Tunnicliffe (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 12 November 2026

Debate

Autumn Budget 2026

Contribution

My Lords, I worked for John Healey for perhaps 10 years. He was a team leader with a difference; he was the best leader I have ever worked for because he listens. So, it is not surprising that I support all 98 features of his Budget. I will not go through all 98, but I will touch on, as did the noble Baroness, Lady Warwick, the issue of housing. Housing is so central to people’s lives. Housing divides society in terms of economic performance and success, as well as dividing society even more sharply. I am a boomer. Most people in this House are boomers or sub-boomers; we lived through history’s most famous generation. We saw our standards of living, on balance, improving every year, even in housing. I was brought up in a council house, and there were no problems. We had stability of tenure and sensible rent increases. You did not think that you were a second-class citizen; you felt that this is how people live and it was a good way of living. Bad housing and sleeping rough are an absolute disgrace. Everybody should be concerned with avoiding it. One of the advantages of spending on council housing, so-called affordable housing and so on, is that it will create growth. Growth is the issue I wish to finish on. Lack of growth poisons society because it creates economic divisions, divisions in education and divisions in skills. Too much of society lives in a second-class standard, particularly younger people. When I was young—an awfully long time ago now—jobs were plentiful and progress was possible. Meritocracies were, to a surprising extent, there. We must try to return to that situation. To do it, the only solution is successful and sustained growth. There are four things that can impact on the economy. I am sure a proper economist could find 40, but there are four. There is the external environment—trade treaties and that sort of stuff. There is expenditure, and taxation. Fourthly, there is borrowing. I argue that we should have a different way of thinking about borrowing. If there is a need for cash, the Government should borrow it and inject it. It is all about trends. Once you get trends going, the rest of society will generate its cash. More cash for research and more cash for that transition from small business to large business is necessary. What does this come up against? It comes up against fiscal rules. Fiscal rules are supposed to be saving us. Well, may the Almighty be on our side. Fiscal rules meant something in Gordon Brown’s day, when they did not change for 12 years. Since that time, counting from the useful work done by the committee, they seemed to have changed 23 times. There is nothing firm about 23 times in that relatively modest period. Fiscal rules seem to be lines in the sand for us to manage the markets, but what do we know about the markets? A number of people in this Chamber perhaps know them intimately, but I do not. I do know that the other three variabilities are understood and debated, so I want the Government to pause after this Budget is put through, but before we firm up on the 10-year plan, and to give to borrowing money the same amount of attention we give to expenditure and taxation. I went through the period of PFIs. PFIs were the biggest fiddle known to mankind, but they work. They were not as good as the Government giving me the money and then me spending it—I would have done a better job than the PFI—but there was no alternative. We had PFIs all over the place. The PFI took money screaming into the Underground’s 10 years of renewal and expenditure. Let us put the best minds in the country—I include the noble Lord, Lord O’Neill, in that—to inventing another system of charades that makes government borrowing respectable and effective again, recognising that the only way you get change is through having really good ideas developed by good people, and then backing them with sufficient funds for them to become productive.

More from Lord Tunnicliffe (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.