L

Lord Caine (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 14 October 2026

Debate

Drumcree

Contribution

My Lords, I am grateful for the opportunity to discuss the events at Drumcree in Portadown over recent days and the decision of the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland to prohibit an Orange Order parade from Drumcree church along the Garvaghy Road. At the outset, I would like to concur with what the government Statement says about not returning to the stand-offs that took place from the mid-1990s that resulted in widespread and large-scale disorder, awful violence and, most sadly of all, the loss of 21 lives. It was a particularly painful chapter in Northern Ireland’s troubled history, one that left terrible scars on society and which, I believe, fostered the heightened community tensions that led to the death of Robert Hamill, which we discussed on Monday. Any question of going back to those times is simply unimaginable. I was special adviser to the then Secretary of State, the late Lord Mayhew of Twysden, for some of that period. I was also at the Northern Ireland Office when disputes around the return parade through Ardoyne, in north Belfast, also led to serious disorder from 2012 until a resolution was found in 2016. So I speak with some small degree of experience of the issues with which the current Secretary of State, the noble Baroness the Minister and other colleagues and officials have grappled in recent days, and the predicaments they have faced. Ministers often face a choice between the least worst options, or, as I believe Alec Douglas-Home once put it, between the unpalatable and the utterly catastrophic. The police are also placed in a near-impossible position. We completely accept, therefore, the sincerity of the Secretary of State when he says that the decision on Friday to ban the parade was not one that was taken lightly. I believe, however, that the decision taken raises serious issues. The parade was permitted, with severe restrictions—35 people to walk the 10-minute route, with no bands or supporters—by the Parades Commission, which is the lawfully constituted body under the Public Processions (Northern Ireland) Act 1998. As its determinations carry the full weight of law, the parade was legal. The lawfulness of the Parades Commission determination was upheld by the Court of Appeal, chaired by the Lady Chief Justice, on Monday. The parade was prevented from taking place, however, by an unlawful protest, as a result of which a number of people, including senior politicians, are being investigated over possible breaches of the law. It cannot be excusable for any, but least of all lawmakers, to decide that they will obey the law only when it suits them. Yet does the Minister agree that that is what appears to have happened on this occasion? In his own statement, the chief constable said that for the march to proceed would have, “required a substantial public order intervention that was not assessed to be proportionate, and which would have carried an unacceptable risk of serious injury, disorder and a wider contagion effect across Northern Ireland”. Nobody doubts that these are serious matters that require full consideration. We are clear that nothing can be gained by any actions that will further heighten tensions, just as nothing will be gained by heeding those voices that wish to pull down the institutions in Northern Ireland. Is not the consequence of banning the march, though, that those who have broken the law and those whose actions have threatened “serious injury, disorder and a wider contagion” have in fact triumphed? I accept totally that this is not remotely the intention of Ministers and the Government, but will not the perception in Northern Ireland be that those who bring sufficient numbers on to the streets and threaten violence and disorder will prevail? Throughout the duration of the stand-off at Ardoyne, I attended countless meetings with nationalist politicians and residents who were adamant that Parades Commission determinations must always be upheld. At the same time, unionist politicians and the Orange Order exhorted us to use the same process and Section 9 powers employed by the Secretary of State on Friday to enable their parade at the time to take place. In 2013, we gave this serious consideration but drew back due to the implications for the authority of the Parades Commission, confidence in policing and, above all, upholding the rule of law. Again, I know this is not the intention, but I am deeply concerned that the Secretary of State may have crossed a line from which, in future, it will be difficult ever to retreat. Finally, the pledge of office in Schedule 4 to the Northern Ireland Act 1998 contains a commitment for Ministers, including the First Minister, “to support the rule of law unequivocally in word and deed and to support all efforts to uphold it”. Does the Minister believe that there should be consequences for any Minister, of whatever political party, who fails to abide by that pledge? In this respect, are there any plans to look at the powers of the Secretary of State under Section 30A of the Northern Ireland Act 1998? In his statement, the chief constable said that among the considerations in recommending that the Secretary of State ban the parade were the implications “for the Northern Ireland Executive and the peace process”. Can the noble Baroness tell the House what the chief constable meant by that? As I have said, I fully accept that there are no easy answers, but I fear on this occasion that the Government may have taken the wrong choice.

More from Lord Caine (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.