Drumcree
Wednesday, 14 October 2026
Contributions
Statement
The following Statement was made in the House of Commons on Monday 12 October.
“With permission, Madam Deputy Speaker, I would like to make a Statement on Drumcree.
I should first alert Members to the fact that the decision that I will lay out in this Statement is subject to legal challenge. I respect the court’s role and will not anticipate its conclusions. I wanted to update the House as soon as possible, but I hope that honourable Members will understand that this may limit some of what I can say. I also note that this afternoon the Court of Appeal, sitting in Belfast, refused leave to appeal to the Garvaghy Road Residents Coalition. The court therefore confirmed the Parades Commission’s determination as it was made at the time on 25 September, as did I. My exercise of powers under Section 11 of the Public Processions (Northern Ireland) Act 1998, however, considered the situation as it stood on Friday 9 October.
The repeated stand-offs at Drumcree in the 1990s saw disorder, violence and horrific deaths, and they represent a particularly painful chapter in Northern Ireland’s history. At the heart of the matter is the return route of the Orange Order Portadown district’s parade from Drumcree church. Members of the Orange Order attach great importance to completing their route down the mainly nationalist Garvaghy Road, while residents of the road have long opposed its passage through their community.
For 28 years the independent Parades Commission had determined that the route should not pass down the Garvaghy Road, but on 25 September a Parades Commission determination allowed for 35 members of Portadown lodge to walk along the Garvaghy Road without the accompaniment of music on Sunday 27 September. To some, this was a legal victory that recognised the religious, cultural and personal significance of this procession. To others, it was a profound shock and a reopening of wounds they long thought closed.
On Saturday 26 September, following a challenge brought on behalf of the residents, a temporary injunction was granted, then appealed and overturned, before permission to seek judicial review was refused in the early hours of Sunday 27 September. The parade, lawfully determined, was due to take place at 8 am that same morning. However, the Orange Order was unable to complete that route due to an unlawful, unnotified protest by residents of the Garvaghy Road and their supporters, who blocked the road. For much of the two weeks since, Drumcree has once again been the scene of a stand-off. This is a deeply emotive and hurtful issue for many of those who have been involved in this dispute, either now or in the past.
I have spent the past fortnight in extensive conversations with all affected parties, trying to get a mutually acceptable agreement between the two sides. I hosted several rounds of negotiations at Hillsborough Castle over five days and maintained frequent contact with those involved, including Members of this House. During those discussions, we explored multiple options for ending the impasse. These included options such as the Portadown Lodge completing one final march along the Garvaghy Road on the condition that it would not apply to march that route again, and an option that would have seen Portadown Lodge accept that it had won the right to march but agree not to exercise that right. Other options included the residents accepting that the lodge had had established the legal right and would not challenge other parts of the route. Unfortunately, we could not secure agreement.
I want to thank the members of the Portadown Lodge for their time and constructive engagement. Their commitment to upholding the law and their co-operation with the police has been absolutely vital in maintaining calm and order. Having received a determination permitting them to march after 28 years, I recognise that they will feel bitter disappointment at its prohibition. I also want to thank members of the Garvaghy Road Residents Coalition for their engagement. They made clear to me the profound anxiety this dispute has brought, relighting painful memories. I deeply regret that we were not able to reach a compromise on a way forward. Although I was still keen to establish a local agreement, I did not want to see the stand-off continue into another weekend, with the consequent risk of protests spreading to other parts of Northern Ireland and the further deterioration of community relations. I therefore intensively considered all options for bringing this dispute to an end.
On Friday 9 October, the Chief Constable of the Police Service of Northern Ireland made an application to me under Section 9 of the Public Processions (Northern Ireland) Act 1998. As required by law, I reviewed the initial determination made by the Parades Commission relating to the application made by the Portadown district for 27 September 2026. I consulted the chief constable and the Parades Commission. The chief constable advised me that it would not be possible to enable the procession to happen without a major intervention, which would carry
‘an unacceptable risk of serious injury, disorder and a wider contagion affect across Northern Ireland’.
The Parades Commission also advised me that, while ultimately a matter for the courts to determine, the commission was of the view that in the light of this current assessment by the chief constable, the original determination does not now have enduring legal effect. As a result, given that the circumstances under which that decision was made have now changed considerably and in the interests of wider public interest and safety, I came to the conclusion that the procession should not go ahead as it was originally determined.
I did not take that decision lightly. I had tried to get a locally agreed solution and, as the Court of Appeal has held today, the Portadown district had a lawful determination from the Parades Commission allowing the procession. I have also not criticised the original determination made by the Parades Commission in good faith and based on the information it had at the time. Indeed, as part of my decision on Friday, I confirmed that original determination, which has also been upheld as lawful by the court, as anybody who criticises the Parades Commission should bear in mind. However, I must acknowledge that the situation has changed considerably, which is why I used my powers under Section 11 of the Act to prohibit the procession.
Respect for the rule of law is fundamental to our society. I am grateful to those who have behaved peacefully and legally, and sought to ease tensions in their respective communities. It is right to say that the Orange Order obtained a legal right to parade, but I agree with the chief constable, who has said that
‘upholding of the Parades Commission determination does not come at any cost’.
Upholding the law also entails judiciously preventing serious disorder, and that is why I am glad that, despite the manifest tension, events have passed peacefully in Portadown. That is in itself a significant achievement.
I thank the PSNI officers who have carried the burden of policing this difficult situation. However, nobody is able to grant themselves immunity from the law, and those who have acted unlawfully must face the consequences of their actions. It is not for me to determine how the police exercise their duties, but I am glad that the PSNI operation in relation to unlawful protesting on the Garvaghy Road is under way.
I am grateful to all those who have engaged with me in good faith and to those within this House who have worked diligently to reduce tensions. I particularly thank those who have sought to moderate their language. It is easy to stir up a grievance, but it is much harder to calm it down. I appeal now to everyone to help reduce tensions, and for all political and community leaders to consider carefully the effect of their words. I urge people to let the courts do their work, and to co-operate fully with the police and the Parades Commission.
The community in Portadown has been on the sharp end of intense attention for a number of weeks. It will take time to rebuild relations. Sometimes leadership is extremely difficult, but it is vital that at this time the political parties in Northern Ireland offer stability. That can be a challenge when loud voices dominate. However, in my conversations with both sides and with political leaders from different parties and traditions, I have met many extraordinary people of good faith who want to rebuild trust and co-operation based on mutual respect. I hope all Members will want to share in that ambition. I commend this Statement to the House”.
Lord Caine (Con)
My Lords, I am grateful for the opportunity to discuss the events at Drumcree in Portadown over recent days and the decision of the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland to prohibit an Orange Order parade from Drumcree church along the Garvaghy Road. At the outset, I would like to concur with what the government Statement says about not returning to the stand-offs that took place from the mid-1990s that resulted in widespread and large-scale disorder, awful violence and, most sadly of all, the loss of 21 lives. It was a particularly painful chapter in Northern Ireland’s troubled history, one that left terrible scars on society and which, I believe, fostered the heightened community tensions that led to the death of Robert Hamill, which we discussed on Monday. Any question of going back to those times is simply unimaginable. I was special adviser to the then Secretary of State, the late Lord Mayhew of Twysden, for some of that period. I was also at the Northern Ireland Office when disputes around the return parade through Ardoyne, in north Belfast, also led to serious disorder from 2012 until a resolution was found in 2016. So I speak with some small degree of experience of the issues with which the current Secretary of State, the noble Baroness the Minister and other colleagues and officials have grappled in recent days, and the predicaments they have faced. Ministers often face a choice between the least worst options, or, as I believe Alec Douglas-Home once put it, between the unpalatable and the utterly catastrophic. The police are also placed in a near-impossible position. We completely accept, therefore, the sincerity of the Secretary of State when he says that the decision on Friday to ban the parade was not one that was taken lightly. I believe, however, that the decision taken raises serious issues. The parade was permitted, with severe restrictions—35 people to walk the 10-minute route, with no bands or supporters—by the Parades Commission, which is the lawfully constituted body under the Public Processions (Northern Ireland) Act 1998. As its determinations carry the full weight of law, the parade was legal. The lawfulness of the Parades Commission determination was upheld by the Court of Appeal, chaired by the Lady Chief Justice, on Monday. The parade was prevented from taking place, however, by an unlawful protest, as a result of which a number of people, including senior politicians, are being investigated over possible breaches of the law. It cannot be excusable for any, but least of all lawmakers, to decide that they will obey the law only when it suits them. Yet does the Minister agree that that is what appears to have happened on this occasion? In his own statement, the chief constable said that for the march to proceed would have, “required a substantial public order intervention that was not assessed to be proportionate, and which would have carried an unacceptable risk of serious injury, disorder and a wider contagion effect across Northern Ireland”. Nobody doubts that these are serious matters that require full consideration. We are clear that nothing can be gained by any actions that will further heighten tensions, just as nothing will be gained by heeding those voices that wish to pull down the institutions in Northern Ireland. Is not the consequence of banning the march, though, that those who have broken the law and those whose actions have threatened “serious injury, disorder and a wider contagion” have in fact triumphed? I accept totally that this is not remotely the intention of Ministers and the Government, but will not the perception in Northern Ireland be that those who bring sufficient numbers on to the streets and threaten violence and disorder will prevail? Throughout the duration of the stand-off at Ardoyne, I attended countless meetings with nationalist politicians and residents who were adamant that Parades Commission determinations must always be upheld. At the same time, unionist politicians and the Orange Order exhorted us to use the same process and Section 9 powers employed by the Secretary of State on Friday to enable their parade at the time to take place. In 2013, we gave this serious consideration but drew back due to the implications for the authority of the Parades Commission, confidence in policing and, above all, upholding the rule of law. Again, I know this is not the intention, but I am deeply concerned that the Secretary of State may have crossed a line from which, in future, it will be difficult ever to retreat. Finally, the pledge of office in Schedule 4 to the Northern Ireland Act 1998 contains a commitment for Ministers, including the First Minister, “to support the rule of law unequivocally in word and deed and to support all efforts to uphold it”. Does the Minister believe that there should be consequences for any Minister, of whatever political party, who fails to abide by that pledge? In this respect, are there any plans to look at the powers of the Secretary of State under Section 30A of the Northern Ireland Act 1998? In his statement, the chief constable said that among the considerations in recommending that the Secretary of State ban the parade were the implications “for the Northern Ireland Executive and the peace process”. Can the noble Baroness tell the House what the chief constable meant by that? As I have said, I fully accept that there are no easy answers, but I fear on this occasion that the Government may have taken the wrong choice.
Baroness Suttie (LD)
My Lords, I too am grateful to have the opportunity to discuss the Statement made on Monday this week by the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland. These past few weeks have served as a stark reminder of just how fragile the peace process is and of how we must never take it for granted. These events also remind us of the power and importance of words. Words as well as deeds can inflame, cause hurt and ultimately turn people towards violence—a violence that has, mercifully, been so much less a part of people’s lives in Northern Ireland since 1998. The Belfast/Good Friday agreement left many of those issues concerning reconciliation and dealing with the past unresolved, and that is perhaps one of the lessons learned from these recent events, which have been further inflamed by social media and the highly personalised, unacceptable and often offensive language used. We need to find ways to bring about genuine reconciliation and move on from the past. From these Benches, we welcome all efforts at de-escalation and dialogue, and we therefore commend the intervention of the Secretary of State, which followed clear advice from the PSNI. That advice was clear: not to intervene risked a further increase in violence and a wider deterioration of the peace process. I also pay a personal tribute to the Minister, who I know has dedicated so much time over the last few weeks to trying to find compromises and solutions to these difficult and highly sensitive issues. As a Scot from a small town where traditions are fiercely upheld, I understand the importance placed on such traditions, but they should never, I believe, be at the expense of the security and safety of others. It is important that the rule of law is respected and upheld. We must put the community and its future first. People living side by side and getting on with their lives do not benefit from replaying the worst chapters of the past. A three-week stand-off costing £5 million in policing alone is money and resource that could have gone elsewhere. Those choices will inevitably have consequences for real people. Our job now is to support those who want to move forwards, protect the institutions, respect the rule of law and ensure that this dispute does not taint the hard-won progress of the last 30 years. Can the Minister say what practical support is being provided to the communities in Portadown, which have now lived through three weeks of disruption and tension? How is she going about supporting that? As I said, the policing bill is now approaching £5 million. Can the Minister confirm whether additional resource will be made available to the PSNI and whether that cost will fall on the Northern Ireland block grant? Finally, will the Minister commit to encouraging engagement with young people, a generation that has mostly grown up without this kind of division and violence, to hear its perspective on how we can move forwards?
The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Northern Ireland Office (Baroness Anderson of Stoke-on-Trent) (Lab)
My Lords, I am grateful to the noble Lord, Lord Caine, and the noble Baroness, Lady Suttie, for their considerate and thoughtful contributions to this deeply sensitive debate. As noble Lords will be aware, during his Statement in the other place the Secretary of State alerted Members that the decision that he laid out in his Statement is subject to legal challenge. We must respect the court’s role and not anticipate its conclusions. Therefore, noble Lords will understand that this limits what I can say today. However, I first want to thank many Members of your Lordships’ House, as well as Members of the other place, who, like me, spent a great deal of time in what was meant to be a quiet Recess—those famous last words—trying to manage a situation that was deeply troubling and, for many, heartbreaking. I also thank Portadown Loyal Orange Lodge No. 1 and the Garvaghy Road Residents Coalition for the time they genuinely took to come to Hillsborough and engage in active negotiations. We are about to talk about a range of issues and I will touch on the facts of where we currently stand. We talk a great deal about how fragile peace is, but I have also learned quite how resilient the communities in Northern Ireland are. The one thing we should hold on to is that, if this situation had happened 20 years ago, I am not sure we would have seen the level of peace, or relative calm, on the streets that we have seen, in spite of people trying to inflame. I cannot tell you how grateful I am for that. Let me set out the facts. Portadown Loyal Orange Lodge No.1 obtained a lawful determination permitting its procession. I thank the lodge for the time it gave me, as well as the Secretary State, and for its constructive engagement. Its commitment to upholding the law and its co-operation with the police has been vital in maintaining calm and order. The Parades Commission determination, as it was made at the time on 25 September, was upheld in the early hours of 26 September, and again at the Court of Appeal on Monday 12 October. However, the Secretary of State received a formal application from the chief constable on Friday 9 October, under Section 9 of the Public Processions (Northern Ireland) Act 1998, advising that facilitating the parade would carry an unacceptable risk of serious injury, widespread disorder and public safety threats. No responsible Minister could disregard that clear operational assessment. Upholding the rule of law requires judiciously preventing serious disorder. As the chief constable has noted, upholding a determination does not come at any cost. Crucially, nobody is above the law or granted immunity from it. The Police Service of Northern Ireland’s operation regarding unlawful protesting is under way and any individual who breaks the law will face police investigation. Noble Lords may also be aware that yesterday the first person went to prison, with a custodial sentence of six months. Noble Lords have also raised concerns regarding future parading, which is one of my personal concerns. The Secretary of State’s exercise of powers under Section 11 of the Act—not Section 9—was specific to the circumstances on the ground at Drumcree. The use of Section 9 powers under the Act is also specific to this situation and does not diminish the vital role of the Parades Commission, which remains the lawful body for regulating public processions in Northern Ireland. As I have stated, the courts have upheld the Parades Commission’s determination, as did the Secretary of State via his Section 9 power. However, we have to address concerns from both sides of the community around public confidence in the Parades Commission, which is why we have asked Justice O’Hara to carry out the independent judge-led review into the commission’s processes and procedures, and I am the Minister responsible for that review. The Secretary of State and his ministerial team, which includes me, spent two weeks intensively engaged on this issue, hosting successive rounds of negotiations at Hillsborough Castle with all affected parties, to attempt to secure a compromise. During these discussions, we explored multiple options for ending the impasse. These included options such as Portadown Lodge completing one final march along the Garvaghy Road on the condition that it would not apply to march down the route again. Another option would have seen Portadown Lodge accept that it had won the right to march but agree not exercise that right. Other options included the residents accepting that the lodge had established the legal right and not challenging other parts of the route. As we have seen in other parts of Northern Ireland, where a local agreement can be made, that is what sticks and helps us move on. In this instance, a local agreement could not be reached, but there is a clear distinction between failing to secure an agreement on a deeply complex issue and failing to act. We tried. On some of the specifics, I am going to need to reflect on Hansard , because there are obviously some things that I can and cannot say right now from the Dispatch Box. I want to reflect on one of the comments made by the noble Baroness, Lady Suttie. Members of your Lordships’ House are aware of the extraordinary respect I have for the people who delivered the Belfast/Good Friday agreement, many of whom are Members of your Lordships’ House. I do not think I ever realised what the pressures were on those very people until I sat in the rooms they had sat in to try to bring together two sides in a very difficult process. I am so grateful for what they did that has got us to this point. The noble Baroness also raised the question of practical support for the community in terms of next steps. We are now working with key partners and allies, both on the ground and in terms of institutional stakeholders, to see what has to be done. There needs to be some time. There is genuine hurt on both sides about what has happened, and there are obviously still ongoing court cases, but we are aware of the ongoing impact this is going to have on community tensions and relationships. The noble Baroness also raised the police Bill. There are current, ongoing discussions, but £5 million is an accurate figure of how much this has cost. While we are talking about that, I put on record my thanks to the PSNI. We have seen officers who have not had any leave for weeks go back to places where they have served historically. I spoke to many officers who served during the very dark days of Drumcree and the memories this brings back for them, as well as for the direct members of the community, are also real, and we need to be aware of that. I am very grateful to the officers of the PSNI, who did everything they could to hold the community together. During the process, I went to Gold Command to thank them for the work they were doing. There are other issues I will need to reflect on, but I will write to noble Lords if I have missed anything substantial. Events over recent weeks have passed peacefully and without major disorder, which in itself represents a significant achievement. I appeal to all political and community leaders to exercise restraint in their language and assist in lowering tensions. We have seen some extraordinary leadership from our political leaders in Northern Ireland in recent days and weeks; we have also seen the opposite from some. We must grant the community in Portadown the breathing space needed to rebuild trust and uphold the spirit of mutual respect at the heart of the Belfast/Good Friday agreement. That has to be our priority and, as we head towards 30 years—29 years next year—which is such a significant milestone of the Belfast/Good Friday agreement, there is a responsibility on every single one of us to live up to both the promises of that and the spirit of the Stormont House agreement.
Lord McCrea of Magherafelt and Cookstown (DUP)
My Lords, the Minister who has addressed us knows she is held in the highest respect across Northern Ireland. However, it must also be said that the Secretary of State has lost the confidence of a vast number of people within Northern Ireland, because he and the chief constable, in spite of a lawful decision made by the Parades Commission, with the court permitting 35 Orangemen to walk down Garvaghy Road, bowed shamefully to IRA supporters, the First Minister Michelle O’Neill, and a republican mob gathered from across not only Northern Ireland but also the Irish Republic to defy the law on Garvaghy Road and threaten violence. Can the Minister tell us how the Government are going to restore the rule of law in Northern Ireland and stop what is now clear to everyone: that there is two-tier policing, one for republican agitators and lawbreakers, and another for the law-abiding people of Northern Ireland?
Baroness Anderson of Stoke-on-Trent (Lab)
I thank the noble Lord for his question. I know how difficult this has been for many people who see parading as such an important part of their community and their culture, and of deep cultural significance. I will say two things. First, 90% of parades take place without conditions, and we have come so far from where we were. In terms of the rule of law, I stand at this Dispatch Box representing the British Government. We spend the majority of our time legislating: of course I believe in upholding the rule of law. But we need to make sure that that is not at any cost, and noble Lords are aware, because they were there—and I was not—of the sheer damage that was done and the number of lives that were taken throughout the Troubles, but specifically related to Drumcree. Therefore, this is the most heartbreaking and difficult of issues. The noble Lord is absolutely right that where the rule of law needs to be upheld is where the PSNI needs to make prosecutions. We are seeing the police investigation continue—I hate to use Civil Service language—at pace, given that someone has already gone to prison.
Baroness Foster of Aghadrumsee (Non-Afl)
My Lords—
Baroness Ritchie of Downpatrick (Lab)
My Lords—
Lord Weir of Ballyholme (DUP)
My Lords—
Lord Dubs (Lab)
My Lords—
Lord Rogan (UUP)
My Lords—
Viscount Hailsham (Con)
My Lords—
Baroness Foster of Oxton (Con)
My Lords—
Lord in Waiting/Government Whip (Lord Katz) (Lab)
My Lords, there is plenty of time to get everyone in who wants to contribute, as long as questions are brief, like the one we just heard. I suggest that we go to the non-affiliated Benches and then we can take turns around the House.
Baroness Foster of Aghadrumsee (Non-Afl)
My Lords, with the indulgence of the House, as the wife of a police officer who was at Drumcree 1, 2 and 3, I pay tribute to the men and women who stood on that road. I say that because they are often stuck in the middle and they often do not have a voice. I pay tribute to the men who stood there, because if violence had happened, they are the people it would have happened to. I pay tribute to the ordinary members of the PSNI. In his Statement in the other place, the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland said that “the Orange Order was unable to complete that route due to an unlawful, unnotified protest by residents of the Garvaghy Road and their supporters, who blocked the road”. He then said that he made the determination to amend the Parades Commission determination because the chief constable had advised him of the risk of “serious injury, disorder and a wider contagion affect across Northern Ireland”. My question is simple: where did the risk of serious injury and disorder come from? According to the Secretary of State, it did not come from Portadown Lodge and its supporters. He said yesterday that its commitment to upholding the rule of law and its co-operation with the police had been absolutely vital in maintaining calm. Where did the risk of disorder come from?
Baroness Anderson of Stoke-on-Trent (Lab)
I would like to align myself with the comments of the Secretary of State. I have now met the Portadown Lodge many times, and they have shown leadership. These are normal men who have been thrust into the limelight. They have shown leadership within their own community and they have complied with the law at every point. On any intelligence, we are currently subject to a judicial review and therefore I cannot comment further. I am very grateful for the leadership that the noble Baroness has shown during the process and the support she has given to others. The noble Baroness made a very important point about the PSNI, and I hope I did too. We cannot reiterate enough what we have put its members through, even in the last fortnight, both because they have heard from their colleagues over decades about what Drumcree means and the impact during Drumcree 1, 2 and 3 on the police officers who served then and because we asked them to stand again between two communities —the communities from which they come. When I was over in Northern Ireland, I was reminded that there can always be a perception that people like me can fly in and out, and go into one community and try to help. But I get to go home. Police officers do not necessarily get to do that.
Baroness Ritchie of Downpatrick (Lab)
My Lords, I thank my noble friend the Minister for the Statement that was delivered by the Secretary of State in the other place on Monday. As somebody who was elected in Northern Ireland over a long period, I witnessed the events of the last episode of Drumcree and know the impact that it has had on the Loyal Orders and the residents who live there all their lives. We must not forget that. I support law and order, but we very clearly need pragmatism, a de-escalation of community tension, respect for political and community difference, and respect for the need for compromise, which the Secretary of State referred to the other day. Those words were echoed by the former President of the United States, Barack Obama, when he was in Belfast last night, at Queen’s University. Will my noble friend the Minister outline the need for a return to Stormont and the Executive, and to building work on developing the budget, fixing public services and agreeing pay deals for public sector workers, as well as the unfinished business of reconciliation and the healing process? These are the very issues that those MLAs are elected to do.
Baroness Anderson of Stoke-on-Trent (Lab)
My noble friend highlights the rest of my job outside of current events. Trying to hold together the Executive has been an incredibly important part of the last few weeks. It is vital that the structures of the Belfast/Good Friday agreement hold. They are our best route through for making sure that we can deliver for the people of Northern Ireland. On a normal visit, when I am speaking to people in Northern Ireland in their communities about the issues they care about, I hear that they care as much about how we fix the roads and how we look after our public services as any other part of the United Kingdom. That is vital. My noble friend will be very aware of the ongoing conversations about the budget. There is a deal on the table—we just need everyone else to agree it. I feel as if I have said those words many times in the last three weeks. As the Secretary of State says, it is time for everyone to double down on compromise.
Viscount Hailsham (Con)
My Lords—
Lord Rogan (UUP)
My Lords—
Lord Weir of Ballyholme (DUP)
My Lords—
Lord Dubs (Lab)
My Lords—
Lord Katz (Lab)
My Lords, it is the turn of the Conservative Benches and then we will come to those who sit on the unionist Benches.
Viscount Hailsham (Con)
Does the Minister agree that many of us in England who believe strongly in the union would very much prefer the unionists in Northern Ireland not to honour their traditions in a way seen by others to be provocative?
Baroness Anderson of Stoke-on-Trent (Lab)
My Lords, genuinely I do not. Every part of the United Kingdom has its own traditions and celebrations—whether it is our different faith communities or our different geographic locations, we all have significant traditions that we respect and mark. While it may be easy for anyone in GB to say it would be easier if people did not want to parade and march, it is incredibly important that we live in a free and fair society that respects freedom of speech and expression, and that is exactly what this is. This is not unique to one side of the community. The Parades Commission makes determinations for both sides of the community. That is why the Parades Commission exists. It was established in 1998 to facilitate people having their traditions. I want to briefly highlight one of the most extraordinary experiences I had this summer, at the Fleadh, the Irish music festival in Belfast, to which 1.6 million people came over three days. At one point I found myself on the Titanic Slipways listening to Ulster-Scots bands play, while I was sitting next to the Taoiseach. This was in the middle of Belfast where, 30 years ago, that would have been a security threat given who was present; It would not have been something you could have considered. I was sitting with the Head of the Irish Government as we celebrated the culture of Ulster-Scots. That has to be the hope that we hold on to: that we can all respect each other’s traditions.
Lord Rogan (UUP)
My Lords, as a unionist and an Orangeman I will continue to honour my traditions in a peaceful and lawful manner. The Minister mentioned the Good Friday agreement. In the years following the signing of the Belfast agreement, pressure was placed on the Ulster Unionist negotiators to give more ground to Sinn Féin/IRA while republicans continued to issue threats and carry out shootings and maimings on the streets of Northern Ireland. Can the Minister tell the House what is to stop other rent-a-mobs, including non-republican terrorists, from issuing similar threats in the months to come to get their way on the public highways of the United Kingdom?
Baroness Anderson of Stoke-on-Trent (Lab)
I thank the noble Lord for his question. We must ensure that we have confidence in the Parades Commission. I do have confidence in the chair and the commissioners, but it is about making sure that there is public confidence. One of the things that came to light over the summer—it was my ignorance—was that there has been no review of how the Parades Commission has been operating since 2007. It was Lord Ashdown who had previously undertaken such a review. Now, 20 years later, it is easy to take some of these things for granted. We must ensure that the Parades Commission is fit for purpose, that everyone has faith in it and that its determinations are respected by all sides.
Lord Dubs (Lab)
My Lords, can we get the whole thing into perspective? I congratulate the Secretary of State on having made a very difficult decision. But can my noble friend the Minister indicate how many Orange Order marches take place every year without any trouble at all—hundreds, if not thousands? Some of them even take place in Donegal. I would use that fact to urge the unionists to say, “We’re having a pretty fair crack of the whip with our marches, surely we can listen to the chief constable”. The chief constable is a very sensible and effective individual. When he gives advice to the Secretary of State, it would be hard for the Secretary of State to ignore it. We should be grateful about that. The Good Friday/Belfast agreement is too important to be prejudiced on this issue. We must stick by it. Peace in Northern Ireland is too important.
Baroness Anderson of Stoke-on-Trent (Lab)
I thought about my noble friend many times over the last few weeks, not least because of how much time I spent in Hillsborough and how much time he spent there during the negotiations for the Belfast/ Good Friday agreement. For his service, I am always grateful, but in this area more than most. My noble friend is right about the number of parades that happen. Now, 90% of the parades happen without contention. For that I think the whole of Northern Ireland society is grateful. We cannot walk that back. We must ensure that we hold on to that. The one thing that I would say gently to my noble friend is that this was a legal determination through the processes that had been agreed. We put processes in place. People were going to like some decisions and not like others. However, when the decision has been made and is viewed to be lawful, we need to view everything through that prism.
Baroness Foster of Oxton (Con)
My Lords, it has been made clear that this was a small, legal parade. We are unfortunately in a position where he who shouts loudest appears to get their way. My concern comes with the comments and behaviour of the First Minister, Michelle O’Neill, who is also vice-president of Sinn Féin. A key point that has been raised is that there should be no interference from the politicians at the highest level. There was no need for any interference because all the processes had been agreed. However, that appeared not to be the case and therefore I believe it was a wrong decision by the police in Northern Ireland—and her interference did not help. Will the Minister and her colleague, the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland, remind the First Minister that she did say when asked that she was proud to stand with those in the neighbourhood but that the Orange march on 27 September was “unwanted, sectarian and triumphalist”? Will the Minister pass on the message to the Secretary of State and the Prime Minister that, in future, interference on this scale would not be welcome?
Baroness Anderson of Stoke-on-Trent (Lab)
My Lords, it is important that the rule of law be upheld. Everyone, no matter their position, should co-operate fully with the police. Holding public office brings responsibilities to the whole community we represent. Every political leader should uphold the law and consider how our conduct affects the confidence of all those we serve. There is an ongoing police investigation in the specific case the noble Baroness raises, and it is inappropriate for me to comment on specific cases.
Lord Weir of Ballyholme (DUP)
My Lords, first, I join my colleague in indicating the level of personal regard in which the Minister is held in Northern Ireland. However, the events and decisions of the last fortnight have been deeply damaging to both the political process and the rule of law: a First Minister who seems to believe that she is above the law and can pick and choose—by defying the law and, indeed, encouraging others on to the streets to also break the law—which laws she abides by; and a situation in which a legal determination was overturned not on the basis of legal challenge or the merits of the decision itself but on the basis of an illegal protest and the threat of violence, which sends out the clear signal, sadly, that the more unlawful you can be and the more that you can actually threaten violence, the better your chances of success are. That is deeply worrying to society as a whole. What actions do the Government intend to take to try to restore public confidence in both the integrity of the political process and the primacy of the rule of law?
Baroness Anderson of Stoke-on-Trent (Lab)
The noble Lord raises two very important points, which are fundamental to everything that has been achieved during the 28 and a half years since the Belfast Good/Friday agreement was signed. We have come so far, and I want us to ensure that we hold on to quite how far we have come. On the decision that the Secretary of State made, he considered the chief constable’s assessment that facilitating the procession “would carry an unacceptable risk of serious injury”, and wider disorder. He could not responsibly disregard that advice. But the noble Lord is absolutely right. We now have a job of work to do to make sure that people respect the rule of law and have an appreciation for why Stormont is so important. We will continue working with all the political parties to try to deliver that.
Lord Bellingham (Con)
My Lords, speaking as a—
Baroness O’Grady of Upper Holloway (Lab)
My Lords, I welcome the Secretary of State’s intervention. I also thank my noble friend the Minister for her vision of the Belfast Fleadh, which I think is a vision of modern Belfast that many people sign up to. But this particular march, as we know, is associated with a history of violence and sectarian murders, including of the Quinn children. That explains why memories among the residents are still so raw. Will my noble friend the Minister confirm that it is beholden on Governments, courts and state agencies to uphold the European Convention on Human Rights, including freedom from sectarian violence, which is explicitly enshrined in the Good Friday agreement that we all support?
Baroness Anderson of Stoke-on-Trent (Lab)
My Lords, of course we all have a responsibility to uphold every part of the Belfast/Good Friday agreement. The responsibility is on each and every one of us. I spent time with the residents’ association from the Garvaghy Road, and heard, especially from the women, of their genuine fear of what happened, and of their memories of Drumcree 1, 2 and 3, including what happened, as we heard earlier this week, to Robert Hamill. That being said, I do not want to diminish anyone’s pain, because there is always too much pain and heartbreak in Northern Ireland. We experience it nearly every day, especially in your Lordships’ House when we discuss these matters. I will say to my noble friend that there is pain across the piece in Drumcree and further afield. When we discuss anything about the Troubles there is no part of this where there is anything but hurt.
The Deputy Speaker (Baroness Garden of Frognal) (LD)
My Lords, I am afraid that time is up, so I apologise to those noble Lords who did not manage to get their questions in.
Source: UK Parliament Hansard API. Debate ID: 5416617.