T

The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Northern Ireland Office (Baroness Anderson of Stoke-on-Trent) (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 14 October 2026

Debate

Drumcree

Contribution

My Lords, I am grateful to the noble Lord, Lord Caine, and the noble Baroness, Lady Suttie, for their considerate and thoughtful contributions to this deeply sensitive debate. As noble Lords will be aware, during his Statement in the other place the Secretary of State alerted Members that the decision that he laid out in his Statement is subject to legal challenge. We must respect the court’s role and not anticipate its conclusions. Therefore, noble Lords will understand that this limits what I can say today. However, I first want to thank many Members of your Lordships’ House, as well as Members of the other place, who, like me, spent a great deal of time in what was meant to be a quiet Recess—those famous last words—trying to manage a situation that was deeply troubling and, for many, heartbreaking. I also thank Portadown Loyal Orange Lodge No. 1 and the Garvaghy Road Residents Coalition for the time they genuinely took to come to Hillsborough and engage in active negotiations. We are about to talk about a range of issues and I will touch on the facts of where we currently stand. We talk a great deal about how fragile peace is, but I have also learned quite how resilient the communities in Northern Ireland are. The one thing we should hold on to is that, if this situation had happened 20 years ago, I am not sure we would have seen the level of peace, or relative calm, on the streets that we have seen, in spite of people trying to inflame. I cannot tell you how grateful I am for that. Let me set out the facts. Portadown Loyal Orange Lodge No.1 obtained a lawful determination permitting its procession. I thank the lodge for the time it gave me, as well as the Secretary State, and for its constructive engagement. Its commitment to upholding the law and its co-operation with the police has been vital in maintaining calm and order. The Parades Commission determination, as it was made at the time on 25 September, was upheld in the early hours of 26 September, and again at the Court of Appeal on Monday 12 October. However, the Secretary of State received a formal application from the chief constable on Friday 9 October, under Section 9 of the Public Processions (Northern Ireland) Act 1998, advising that facilitating the parade would carry an unacceptable risk of serious injury, widespread disorder and public safety threats. No responsible Minister could disregard that clear operational assessment. Upholding the rule of law requires judiciously preventing serious disorder. As the chief constable has noted, upholding a determination does not come at any cost. Crucially, nobody is above the law or granted immunity from it. The Police Service of Northern Ireland’s operation regarding unlawful protesting is under way and any individual who breaks the law will face police investigation. Noble Lords may also be aware that yesterday the first person went to prison, with a custodial sentence of six months. Noble Lords have also raised concerns regarding future parading, which is one of my personal concerns. The Secretary of State’s exercise of powers under Section 11 of the Act—not Section 9—was specific to the circumstances on the ground at Drumcree. The use of Section 9 powers under the Act is also specific to this situation and does not diminish the vital role of the Parades Commission, which remains the lawful body for regulating public processions in Northern Ireland. As I have stated, the courts have upheld the Parades Commission’s determination, as did the Secretary of State via his Section 9 power. However, we have to address concerns from both sides of the community around public confidence in the Parades Commission, which is why we have asked Justice O’Hara to carry out the independent judge-led review into the commission’s processes and procedures, and I am the Minister responsible for that review. The Secretary of State and his ministerial team, which includes me, spent two weeks intensively engaged on this issue, hosting successive rounds of negotiations at Hillsborough Castle with all affected parties, to attempt to secure a compromise. During these discussions, we explored multiple options for ending the impasse. These included options such as Portadown Lodge completing one final march along the Garvaghy Road on the condition that it would not apply to march down the route again. Another option would have seen Portadown Lodge accept that it had won the right to march but agree not exercise that right. Other options included the residents accepting that the lodge had established the legal right and not challenging other parts of the route. As we have seen in other parts of Northern Ireland, where a local agreement can be made, that is what sticks and helps us move on. In this instance, a local agreement could not be reached, but there is a clear distinction between failing to secure an agreement on a deeply complex issue and failing to act. We tried. On some of the specifics, I am going to need to reflect on Hansard, because there are obviously some things that I can and cannot say right now from the Dispatch Box. I want to reflect on one of the comments made by the noble Baroness, Lady Suttie. Members of your Lordships’ House are aware of the extraordinary respect I have for the people who delivered the Belfast/Good Friday agreement, many of whom are Members of your Lordships’ House. I do not think I ever realised what the pressures were on those very people until I sat in the rooms they had sat in to try to bring together two sides in a very difficult process. I am so grateful for what they did that has got us to this point. The noble Baroness also raised the question of practical support for the community in terms of next steps. We are now working with key partners and allies, both on the ground and in terms of institutional stakeholders, to see what has to be done. There needs to be some time. There is genuine hurt on both sides about what has happened, and there are obviously still ongoing court cases, but we are aware of the ongoing impact this is going to have on community tensions and relationships. The noble Baroness also raised the police Bill. There are current, ongoing discussions, but £5 million is an accurate figure of how much this has cost. While we are talking about that, I put on record my thanks to the PSNI. We have seen officers who have not had any leave for weeks go back to places where they have served historically. I spoke to many officers who served during the very dark days of Drumcree and the memories this brings back for them, as well as for the direct members of the community, are also real, and we need to be aware of that. I am very grateful to the officers of the PSNI, who did everything they could to hold the community together. During the process, I went to Gold Command to thank them for the work they were doing. There are other issues I will need to reflect on, but I will write to noble Lords if I have missed anything substantial. Events over recent weeks have passed peacefully and without major disorder, which in itself represents a significant achievement. I appeal to all political and community leaders to exercise restraint in their language and assist in lowering tensions. We have seen some extraordinary leadership from our political leaders in Northern Ireland in recent days and weeks; we have also seen the opposite from some. We must grant the community in Portadown the breathing space needed to rebuild trust and uphold the spirit of mutual respect at the heart of the Belfast/Good Friday agreement. That has to be our priority and, as we head towards 30 years—29 years next year—which is such a significant milestone of the Belfast/Good Friday agreement, there is a responsibility on every single one of us to live up to both the promises of that and the spirit of the Stormont House agreement.

More from The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Northern Ireland Office (Baroness Anderson of Stoke-on-Trent) (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.