Hansard·Lords Chamber·Vol. 860

Prisoner Early Release Scheme

Wednesday, 14 October 2026

31 contributions9 members

Contributions

  1. Commons Urgent Question

    View contribution permalink →

  2. The following Answer to an Urgent Question was given in the House of Commons on Tuesday 13 October.

    View contribution permalink →

  3. “This Government inherited a prison system on the brink of collapse. In July 2024, men’s prisons were operating at 99% capacity. At one point, fewer than 100 places were available across the male estate. Without intervention, we risked running out of prison places, leaving courts unable to sentence offenders and police unable to make arrests.

    View contribution permalink →

  4. This Government have acted to increase capacity and to reform sentencing. We have committed to delivering 14,000 prison places by 2031 and have already delivered 3,200. The last Government added just 500 net places in their time in office. We have also accelerated the removal of foreign national offenders, returning around 11,700 to their countries of origin. It is in that context that we launched the independent sentencing review in October 2024 and subsequently passed the Sentencing Act 2026 earlier this year to place the prison system on a more sustainable footing and ensure that space is always available for the most dangerous offenders. The Act also aimed to avoid the chaotic emergency release schemes carried out with little scrutiny or warning by the Conservatives.

    View contribution permalink →

  5. However, we know that aspects of these changes have caused concern, and we are determined to do the right thing for victims. That is why the Government listened to the concerns raised, paused the implementation of the progression model and conducted an urgent review. As the Lord Chancellor confirmed in this House on 1 September, in addition to the 18,000 dangerous offenders already ineligible for the progression model, this Government have excluded rape and serious child sex offences from eligibility for changes to release dates under the Sentencing Act. Unlawful killings, including manslaughter, causing or allowing the death of a child, and death by dangerous driving, are also excluded, as well as indecent assault, ensuring that more historical child sex offences prosecuted under older laws are treated consistently with equivalent offences today. That means that hundreds more dangerous criminals will be staying behind bars for longer, including those who killed PC Andrew Harper in the line of duty.

    View contribution permalink →

  6. The first releases on the progression model took place on 1 October, with His Majesty’s Prison and Probation Service working closely with operational partners to ensure that eligible offenders were released safely into the community. As the second tranche of releases begins today, robust arrangements remain in place to manage releases, support probation practitioners and supervising offenders, and ensure that those subject to electronic monitoring requirements are fitted with a tag. As part of the supervision of offenders released into the community, HMPPS will maintain rigorous oversight of those on licence, with measures in place to recall those who are non-compliant.

    View contribution permalink →

  7. We recognise the significant effect that release date changes can have on victims. We will ensure that those in the victim contact scheme who are affected by the new exclusions are informed if there are any changes to the release date of the offender in their case. I have also instructed my officials to attempt to contact victims not in that scheme to provide information, should they wish for that to happen. We have launched the victim support offender release helpline, with nearly £19 million of additional funding, to provide victims with emotional support, practical advice such as safety planning, and general information about sentencing changes.

    View contribution permalink →

  8. It is important to add that the Minister for Prisons, Probation and Reducing Reoffending is unable to be here today because she is currently speaking with governors about early release and how the implementation of the progression model is going”.

    View contribution permalink →

  9. Lord Keen of Elie (Con)

    My Lords, when discharging more and more criminals before completion of their prison sentence, one simple measure of public protection would be electronic tagging. We know that the Government have failed to implement this measure, with many of these criminals leaving prison early without a tag. Will the Minister advise how many of the latest cohort of 600 criminals were released without a tag, and will he undertake that any further criminals who are released early will be electronically tagged before they leave prison?

    View contribution permalink →

  10. The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Ministry of Justice (Lord Lemos) (Lab)

    My Lords, we inherited a failing tagging system with record backlogs, but since 2024 we have been working hard to fix this and the install rates are up nearly 50% since then. We are also investing £100 million in electronic monitoring, tagging offenders before releases and strengthening victim protections via new alert systems. All of this helps us to cut the number of unmonitored offenders and protect victims. We are confident that we have enough equipment and Serco field resource to deliver. The situation has improved. Our quarterly electronic monitoring statistics include figures for the number of prison leavers fitted with tags, and the next quarterly update will be published in October.

    View contribution permalink →

  11. Lord Foulkes of Cumnock (Lab Co-op)

    My Lords—

    View contribution permalink →

  12. Baroness Brinton (LD)

    Excuse me.

    View contribution permalink →

  13. Lord Foulkes of Cumnock (Lab Co-op)

    I am really sorry.

    View contribution permalink →

  14. Baroness Brinton (LD)

    I am grateful to the noble Lord. I want to follow on from the question of the noble and learned Lord, Lord Keen, about tagging. Other countries quite often tag prisoners before they leave or at the prison gates. I want to raise one other global example which worked really well but does not relate to prisoners. Taiwan introduced tagging for people having to isolate at home during Covid very quickly by using local resources, and that worked very successfully. Will the Government undertake to look at both the issue that the noble and learned Lord raised about prisoners being tagged before they leave and innovative ways of making this work across the country?

    View contribution permalink →

  15. Lord Lemos (Lab)

    The Government will do so, of course. As the noble Baroness and the House will know from discussions around what is now the Sentencing Act, we have introduced a presumption that offenders released early will be tagged. We have a range of tagging options at our disposal: curfew tags, alcohol tags and GPS tags. I am interested in what the noble Baroness said about Taiwan; I did not know about that. None the less, the situation is clear and we all understand it. It was not a good situation with tagging; we are improving it, but it is clearly a central aspect of how we will manage the criminal justice system in the future.

    View contribution permalink →

  16. Lord Foulkes of Cumnock (Lab Co-op)

    I sincerely apologise to the noble Baroness, Lady Brinton, for jumping the gun. If the party opposite was ever returned to power, it is proposing, I think, to create 50,000 new prison places. As I understand it, in 14 years it created only 500 new prison places and closed 23 prisons. Is the Minister aware of the miracle solution found by the noble and learned Lord, Lord Keen, and his colleagues?

    View contribution permalink →

  17. Lord Lemos (Lab)

    I believe in miracles—I am a Catholic—but even I think 50,000 is a lot. We are undertaking the largest prison-building programme since the Victorian era. In December 2024, this Government published our plan to create 14,000 additional places. I do not think I have said from the Dispatch Box before that we have already delivered through new prisons the expansion and refurbishment of the existing estate and temporary accommodation amounting to some 3,300 places. We have therefore made a substantial impact on prison place supply. My noble friend is right that under the Conservative Government there was a net increase of only 500 places in 14 years, and indeed they were responsible for closing 23 prisons. As for the 50,000 new places that the leader of the Opposition has promised, seeing will be believing.

    View contribution permalink →

  18. Viscount Hailsham (Con)

    My Lords, many of us want to know how many newly released prisoners have been tagged, and how many have been returned to prison having committed an offence. We are not getting that information from the Government at the moment. Is the explanation for that failure either that they do not have the information, or that they choose not to give it? If it is the latter, why?

    View contribution permalink →

  19. Lord Lemos (Lab)

    Neither of those are the explanation. As I have already said, we quarterly release figures both on tagging and on reoffending, and we shall continue to do that. That is the Government’s position.

    View contribution permalink →

  20. Lord Pannick (CB)

    My Lords, have the Government conducted any assessment of how many additional serious crimes are likely to be committed as a result of the early release scheme?

    View contribution permalink →

  21. Lord Lemos (Lab)

    It is very early days for the early release scheme, and I want to make one thing clear. There is a great deal of confusion in the public debate about early release schemes. There have been a succession of such schemes under the previous Government, and indeed we in this Government had two early release schemes because there were fewer than 100 prison places. The early release scheme we are now engaged in is part of the earned progression model. This is a new approach to sentencing that came out of the Gauke review, which we discussed at length in the proceedings of what is now the Sentencing Act. This is not just early release to reduce prison numbers; it is a considered policy approach that we put through the Sentencing Act. We have made lots of assessments and debated them, but it is very early days for this new model, and I do not think that the noble Lord would expect me to quote numbers after such a short period of time.

    View contribution permalink →

  22. The Lord Bishop of Manchester

    My Lords, I declare my interest as a trustee of the Clink Charity. We work both inside and outside prisons, helping prisoners prepare for release. Prisoners now being released under these schemes, often at very short notice, are coming out ill-prepared. I wonder if the Government have made an assessment of what additional preparation needs to be made and how that can be done to allow prisoners to adjust to life outside without reoffending.

    View contribution permalink →

  23. Lord Lemos (Lab)

    I thank the right reverend Prelate for that question, and I know he has been deeply involved in this area of work. It is not good to disagree with Bishops, but I am going to, if I may. I do not accept the characterisation that people are ill-prepared. In this round of early releases, under the earned progression model, we are releasing people in tranches over 10 phases. During the last early release scheme, which was so urgent, we released more people in only two tranches. We are doing a great deal to prepare people for release, and we are working with the Probation Service. These early releases are much better planned and delivered, and I expect that to have a considerable benefit.

    View contribution permalink →

  24. Lord Woodley (Lab)

    My Lords, as we are all aware, these early releases are putting huge pressure on the Probation Service, which is suffering badly after the last Government’s failings. The workloads are high, and that is reflected in the resignations. Does the Minister agree that these outstanding public servants should be paid properly for the job that they do, and that we should do everything we can to make sure that their ballot for strike action does not have to take place?

    View contribution permalink →

  25. Lord Lemos (Lab)

    As I have said from this Dispatch Box many times before, we are asking a lot of probation —and we are asking more under our new model, particularly regarding the second phase of intensive supervision. We have invested £700 million and we are onboarding a number of new probation officers—1,300 this year. On my noble friend’s question, we certainly hope that there will not be industrial action. We are working to reduce the workload of probation officers, and we have committed to achieving that. I do not want to leave your Lordships under any illusion: building a viable Probation Service that is bigger and better than the one we inherited is a key priority in making our new approaches to sentencing effective.

    View contribution permalink →

  26. Lord Clarke of Nottingham (Con)

    My Lords, the main cause of the present prison crisis has been Governments of all parties over the past 30 years trying to prove they are tough on crime by encouraging the sentencing of ever more people to prison for longer and longer periods. I think we now have the highest incarceration rate in Europe, and the average sentence is about double what it was when I was Justice Secretary 30 years ago—and it is probably more than that compared with the distant past when I practised at the criminal Bar. The Government are now going to build more prisons. If they insist on doing that, could they use the space in the prisons to devote more time to rehabilitation? The public will be better served if we put more effort into—and had more space in which to put the effort—reducing reoffending when prisoners are released, so that we have fewer victims of future crime. Meanwhile, despite our policy, the rate of serious crime in this country has never been lower. It has been falling for the last 30 years, as it also has in countries that have reduced their sentencing policies, such as the Netherlands.

    View contribution permalink →

  27. Lord Lemos (Lab)

    I entirely agree with the noble Lord about the way in which sentence lengths have increased. That is why we made the changes we did in the Sentencing Act. He is absolutely right to say that there is no evidence that that has any direct correlation with the rates of crime or, importantly, the public perception of crime. As a novice and amateur politician, I have to say that assumptions that legislating for longer sentences on the basis that that will change public opinion clearly have not been correct. On the noble Lord’s question about rehabilitation, we know what works for rehabilitation, and we are doing more on drug treatment and so on. However, we will not be able to do anything effective on rehabilitation or reducing reoffending if we have massively overcrowded prisons and massively overstretched staff. That is the problem we need to address.

    View contribution permalink →

Source: UK Parliament Hansard API. Debate ID: 5416616.