Contribution
My Lords, I have great respect for the Minister. As a fellow Scot, he will make sure that every bawbee gets value for money. I understand that he will have had a brief from down the Corridor. In fact, having read Commons Hansard, the words were quite familiar. But I hope that he will listen to the debate here in the House of Lords and transmit the views of Members, because unfortunately the Bill was not given the full scrutiny it deserved on the Floor of the House of Commons, which was rather regrettable. The Lords needs to give it some scrutiny today. Although we are not in a position to table any amendments because, understandably, the Speaker of the House of Commons has designated this as a money Bill, we still have a duty to shine a light on the inequality built into this mechanism and the lack of transparency and accountability.
The reality is simple. If the Government genuinely wanted a needs-based system, the Royal Household would submit an annual Budget request to the Treasury like any other public entity. Instead, we now have a formula tied to Crown Estate profits. That is a system designed as a “heads I win, tails you lose” proposition—frozen against losses when profits fall, yet fully open to the upside when they surge.
When we ask the public to fund an institution to the tune of about £100 million a year through the sovereign grant, at a time when, sadly, we know many people in this country face severe pressure on their household budgets, we here have a duty to ask two fundamental questions: first, are we getting value for money and, secondly, do the actions of the institution match the value that it preaches? I argue that in both cases the answer is no.
We hear various royal pronouncements on climate change, yet official reports reveal hundreds of private jet and helicopter flights for short domestic trips, one recently to the races where the royal concerned could have easily gone by car. The taxpayer has funded two new helicopters for the Royal Family, whereas Mountain Rescue has to raise money for its helicopters through charitable efforts. Is that right in the 21st century? Then we see commendable statements on homelessness, from the Prince of Wales in particular, but the Crown maintains many empty or underutilised luxury estates across the country: in Scotland at Balmoral, in London—not just Buckingham Palace but all over the city—and at Sandringham.
In terms of value for money, our monarchy remains by a vast margin the most expensive state-funded royal family in Europe. In Spain, the public grant is only about £7 million. In Sweden, it is under £15 million, and in the Netherlands, it is £45 million. In European terms, we are one of the big spenders, as far as the Royal Family is concerned. If we take a baseline of 2011, £31 million, and adjust that for inflation, our sovereign grant, even allowing for this kind of expenditure, would be between £45 million and £50 million, not the £99.9 million proposed. That figure does not even account for police security; I have had letters from local councils about the cost that they are required to meet for security. The tax advantages of the income from the Duchies are not taken account of.
I am not challenging the role of the sovereign, in particular, but while European neighbours have streamlined their royal houses, we continue to fund a sprawling network of so-called working royals on ribbon-cutting duties or pulling open tableaux. That is not real work. It is not like a teacher who works five days a week or a nurse in a geriatric hospital who might be working a 12-hour shift. It is not real work that they do. I might just say that Princess Anne is a notable exception. It is interesting that all her offspring have given up their royal titles and work for a living. Perhaps that is an example that other members of the Royal Family might think about.
The fundamental issue here is accountability. When George Osborne introduced the sovereign grant, he claimed that removing parliamentary debate would depoliticise the monarchy. In reality, it has stripped away democratic oversight, and the tightening of freedom of information rules means that transparency is now virtually impossible, breaking the assurances that were given previously to Parliament. Shielding the institution behind FoI exemptions and blocking debate has enabled a runaway increase in public funding.
To achieve such accountability, three key actions are necessary, and I sincerely ask the Minister to take account of the debate here today and to take these suggestions to his fellow Ministers in the Treasury and elsewhere. We should consider, first, a return to annual parliamentary scrutiny through regular debates and votes, as with other public bodies. Secondly, we should also treat the Royal Household like any other public body under the Freedom of Information Act. Thirdly, we should ask the Commons to task its Public Accounts Committee to conduct a full, root-and-branch review of all royal funding and finances. Parliament is here to safeguard public money, and it is time we modernised, streamlined and properly brought transparency to this institution. I hope the Minister will genuinely and sincerely take account of this debate and, with colleagues, look again at this matter.