Contribution
My Lords, it is a great pleasure to follow my noble friend Lord Foulkes of Cumnock. This Bill comes at a time when many households are struggling to make ends meet. Under this Bill, the core funding of the Royal Household—that is, after ignoring the money allocated for refurbishment of Buckingham Palace—rises from £51.8 million for 2024-25 to £99.9 million for 2027-28. That is an increase of 97%. I am not aware of any ordinary household that has secured an increase of this magnitude in its income to discharge its essential duties. The average real wage of workers has barely changed since 2008; 25.3 million people live below the minimum income standard. Around 300,000 people a year are dying while waiting for an NHS hospital appointment, but here we are giving away a large chunk of money.
This massive increase is being given to a family which, according to Forbes magazine, could be worth £21 billion. Anyone with lifetime savings of over £16,000 is generally disqualified or severely restricted from receiving universal credit, housing benefit or income support, but under this Bill, a mega-rich family would continue to receive public money. Many people would not be happy with that arrangement, and clearly the Government must notice that issue.
Profits from the Crown Estate, which is, in essence, a property business owned by the monarch but run independently, go to the Treasury. Its profits are used as a benchmark to calculate the funding given by the Government to the Royal Family in the form of sovereign grant. But then there are questions. Do the Crown Estate, the Crown jewels, the Duchy of Cornwall and the Duchy of Lancaster belong to the nation, or are they private property of the Royal Family? If they are public property, all revenues must go to the public purse. If they are private property, those assets and related income streams must be taxed in the same way as any other private property and the beneficiaries must pay income tax, capital gains tax, corporation tax and inheritance tax. Perhaps the Minister can clarify what makes something a public property or a private property and why they need to be treated differently in this case.
What we have had for decades is what I call a medieval fudge. We distinguish good societies from the rest by appealing to the rule of law, but the laws do not apply equally to all. Some get privileged treatment. The King is exempt from inheritance tax. Ordinary mortals are not. The duchies do not pay corporation tax or capital gains tax. The King voluntarily pays income tax on his private income and a portion on the privy purse not used for official duties. Why should payment of income tax be voluntary for anyone? Do not we have a rule of law? I am sure many people would like to pay taxes voluntarily, but they will never get that chance. Can the Minister explain why the King’s exemptions from income tax, inheritance tax and capital gains tax continue, and what revenues could be collected if those exemptions were to be abolished?
In June 2026, the King published data showing that he paid around £30 million in voluntary income and capital gains taxes for the period 2022-23 to 2024-25, which continued the practice started during his time as the Prince of Wales. The current Prince of Wales also embraces similar disclosures. These selected snippets should not be confused with transparency. Anyone completing a tax return must disclose employment income, income from trade or profession, investment income, dividends from home and abroad, capital gains, business profits, inheritance and more—but there are no such disclosures in the snippets which are put into the public domain. There is no transparency about the wealth or income of the Royal Family, and this is in the early 21st century. Nothing is known about the King’s investments, how they are held, where they are held, or income therefrom. Various tax exemptions erode the UK’s tax base as well.
In the absence of meaningful data, it is hard to know what the correct amount of tax paid by the King or the Prince of Wales actually should be. The sovereign grant does not count for income tax purposes, but if normal individuals receive sums from the state to enable them to make ends meet, they are taxable. For example, the state pension, carer’s allowance, contribution- based jobseeker’s allowance and contribution-based employment and support allowances are all taxable. There is one rule for the poor and another for somebody else. The King does not pay capital gains tax on capital off the Duchy of Lancaster and pays income tax on his private income only to the extent that it is not used for official purposes.
In the House of Commons debate on this Bill, Ministers referred to “personal”, and another word they used was “official” expenses, but none offered any clear distinction between the two. Are support staff, palaces, various residences, servants, kitchens, and chauffeurs really for personal or official purposes? Hopefully, the Minister can clarify. Presumably, whatever is personal should not be funded by the public purse, so it would be helpful to see details of that particular information.
One of the most anomalous positions is that of the Duchy of Cornwall. Is it really a public organisation? Is it a Crown body? Is it a corporation, or is it just a private fiefdom, a state within in a state? If it is part of the Crown, then all the checks, balances, scrutiny and accountability that apply to public assets should also apply to the Duchy and its custodian, who is the Prince of Wales. Its records should be subjected to periodic scrutiny by the National Audit Office to determine whether the organisation is operating efficiently, effectively and lawfully and whether the public is getting value for money. However, none of this applies to the Duchy, because we are told that it is a private estate.
Is it really a private estate? The business of the Duchy extends far beyond Cornwall. It is one of the biggest landowners, spread across 20 counties in England and Wales. Its operations include, or have recently included, the manufacture and sale of biscuits, snacks, jam, marmalade, honey, chocolate, organic food, seeds, holiday cottages and farm produce. It owns warehouses, Dartmoor prison, the Oval cricket ground and more. It certainly does not easily fit with the word Cornwall here. It extends far beyond Cornwall and it is really a conglomerate. Its 2026 accounts show that it has assets of £1.3 billion and a financial surplus of £21.55 million. It is a commercial entity, and it competes with local, national and international businesses, but it does not pay corporation tax or capital gains tax because now we are told that it is actually a Crown body. So the Duchy claims exemption from taxes on the basis that it is a Crown body.
Inevitably, these exemptions must lead to unfair competition. The payment of taxes provides for education, pensions and healthcare for the workers and social infrastructure used by the Duchy to make profits. However, because of the tax exemptions, the Duchy does not bear any of the social costs of that infrastructure. It is effectively having a free ride on the back of ordinary taxpayers. That cannot be right at all.
The Duchy complies with the UK’s employment and health and safety laws. It collects PAYE and national insurance; it collects and pays VAT. This gives the appearance that it is actually a business, subject to the laws applicable to all other businesses. But then at the same time, we are told that it is not a commercial organisation and cannot really be treated as a corporation. Well, what is it? I hope the Minister will be able to tell us exactly what it is and why on earth it should be exempt from the laws which apply to any other commercial entity.
Page 92 of the Duchy’s 2026 accounts, which noble Lords might want to have a look at if they are finding it hard to go to bed tonight, contains interesting information. It says:
“Certain Duchy properties were occupied by His Majesty The King and his … staff for living accommodation or commercial activities. These were let at open market values; the total value of annual rent charged amounted to £503,711”.
This is a rent that the Duchy receives by renting out Highgrove House. So, the King pays rent to the Duchy of Cornwall, presumably out of the sovereign grant—but the Duchy is owned by his son, the Duke of Cornwall, so one member of the family is paying rent to another. Money does not go to anybody outside at all. It is retained within the family, so can the Minister explain how this interfamily transaction affected the calculation of the sovereign grant? Is it really a cost in any way whatever?
To sum up, major reforms are needed on transparency, accountability, calculation and the grant of the sovereign grant. The Royals frequently say that they wish to be treated as normal people. I urge the Minister and the Government to fulfil that particular wish.