L

Lord Berkeley (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 14 October 2026

Debate

Sovereign Grant Bill

Contribution

My Lords, it is a real honour to follow my two colleagues who spoke before me and have given so much detailed information about what is wrong with the Crown Estate and the sovereign grant system. I welcome my noble friend the Minister’s clarification of what is in the Bill; it is certainly an improvement on what we had before, but there is an awful lot more to do. I deprecate the lack of scrutiny that the other place has given this Bill because it is the kind of thing where they could, with all the help that they can get, provide some useful challenges to what the trustees produce. Of course, the first thing is that any challenges need to be independent. Most people would think that the trustees, who are the Prime Minister, the Chancellor of the Exchequer and the Keeper of the Privy Purse—which we can look upon as the royal family—appear to be marking their own homework, which is not a satisfactory way of providing an independent assessment. A related point is the continued feeling, among many in the country and in both Houses, about deference. People seem to have stepped back from being positively critical of some things that have happened for fear of upsetting members of the Royal Family. This is coupled with a feeling that many members of the Royal Family—and I exclude those whom my noble friends have spoken about—have an expectation that people consider to be out of touch with a reduced monarchy and the financial situation in which many find themselves. It is unclear to me which royals are on “official duties”, as they are apparently called. As my noble friend Lord Foulkes said, why do they need two helicopters? I am probably seen as the black sheep of the Royal Family-critical group, because I have the honour of having been quoted in a book a few years ago by the then Prince Charles, who said, “Don’t worry about Lord Berkeley, he’s a nutcase”. I think that is a bit of an honour, actually. In any future investigation, one of the most important things that must be done is to address the question of the expenditure that is applicable to the Royal Family and the King as the Head of State—let us call these “official duties”—and what ends up in their private use. Where does the revenue sit: is it private or public? Is the grant value for money? To give an example, Buckingham Palace has been mentioned as a cost to the taxpayer, and it seems as though as good job has been done. The costs are reasonable and it is now nearly finished, and that is to be welcomed. Not many noble Lords will know, however, that the income from visitors to Buckingham Palace goes into the pocket of the sovereign. If the taxpayer has paid all these millions to rebuild it, as an emblem of the state and everything else, surely the income from visitors should go to taxpayers, as a small reimbursement of what they have paid. In passing, this is rather a good example of how a building can be refurbished to a high quality at a reasonable cost. Perhaps those who are in charge of trying to upgrade the Houses of Parliament should get a few lessons from them, but that is a little beside the point. The taxpayer is paying renovation costs, and the King or the Duke of Cornwall are getting the income benefit. This is very odd, and it is not declared. A similar example is when royalty go on official visits. As noble Lords will know, it is normal for royalty to give a gift to their host and to receive one in return. Sometimes they are small gifts and sometimes they are large ones. But, again, it seems as though the gifts that go to the sovereign or whoever it is are retained by the sovereign, when it is the taxpayer who has paid for the gift that the sovereign gives. It should be one or the other but, of course, it is hard to ask questions as it is all very secret. Other noble Lords have mentioned the problem of property. Recently, I found it very interesting to read Royal Mint, National Debt, a book by Norman Baker, the former Member of Parliament for Lewes in East Sussex. It lists 21 properties that are royal residences, as well as 13 others. Do the royals really need 21 properties to fulfil their royal duties? Every time the incumbent changes, it seems the new one insists on buying a new property without giving up the old property. Do they let it out? If so, where does the income go? My noble friend mentioned the Duchy of Cornwall, which, as noble Lords will know, made a profit of about £22 million last year. But, as my noble friend said, it does not operate like other estates. The duchy also receives income from people in Cornwall who die intestate, and it gets a nice cut of the mineral rights from the mining in Cornwall, of which there is quite a lot. However, that does not mean that the profit—or even some of it—goes to housing in Cornwall or on the Isles of Scilly, or to maintaining services and transport. As noble Lords will know, there is a big issue with air services to Scilly at the moment. A useful contribution would be to improve the airport on St Mary’s to category 3 so that it did not get closed because of fog so often. The duchy has offered a very nice site on St Mary’s for building an abattoir, which is useful for the local farmers—although it took a long time for that offer to be made. But we can be quite sure that, the abattoir having been built—which other people will fund—any charge for its use will go straight into the pocket of the duchy, rather than those who funded it. I welcome the National Audit Office’s input so far, but it needs to be much wider in scope—in addition to what the House of Commons should do. The first thing to look at is need. Is there a need for this expenditure? Secondly, is it official or private, as some of my colleagues have said, or is it the usual thing: the Treasury pays the cost, and the income goes as a profit to the private part? There needs to be a debate about affordability. Taxpayer value for money is not evident at the moment, and it needs to be. The most important thing is that this must be seen to be undertaken by an organisation that is separate from the Government and the Royal Family. I do not know whether that organisation should be a separate committee or the National Audit Office, but something needs to be done to remove the deferential attitude—that we must not upset anybody—that seems to cover so much of this. As my noble friend said, this is a business. If it is a business, it should be treated on business terms, where everybody is equal. In the future, I hope we will have a longer debate. I hope my noble friend the Minister will take comments from many noble Lords this evening and, with his colleagues, consider what we can do to make this a modern, affordable monarchy.

More from Lord Berkeley (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.