Contribution
My Lords, this has been an interesting discussion, and rightly so. I will do my best to respond to those parts of the debate where I can. If I fail so to do, please contact me afterwards; a written response might be better.
It is right that we have this discussion because where public money is concerned, this House is entitled to expect clarity, discipline and proper accountability. Where the constitutional arrangements supporting the official duties of the monarch are concerned, this House is also entitled to expect a framework that is stable, proportionate and fit for purpose. That is what the Bill provides. At its core, it does three things. First, it resets the level of the sovereign grant to reflect the fact that the exceptional funding requirement associated with the Buckingham Palace reservicing programme is coming to an end, therefore bringing down the sovereign grant, which would otherwise be rolling forward into the future with the existing formula. Secondly, it establishes a mechanism for calculating the grant in future years: one in which, if the reserve was to fall below 10%, it might trigger a discussion as to whether more was needed. If it went above 50%, that might trigger a discussion about whether less was needed. Thirdly, it introduces powers to adjust the grant in exceptional circumstances. The noble Baroness, Lady Neville-Rolfe, asked what those might be. If we imagine a catastrophic fire, for example, one would want to respond to that. Taken together, hopefully those changes amount to a measured and sensible reform.
However, I want just to be clear about what the sovereign grant does and does not cover. It does not provide any personal income to any member of the royal family. It does not fund private properties, to answer the question asked by the noble Baroness, Lady Kramer. Its purpose is to support the monarch’s official duties as the Head of State and maintain the occupied palaces from which those duties are carried out. It supports staffing, official travel, upkeep of buildings used for state occasions, public engagements and constitutional functions. That is its purpose, and that only is the purpose of the Bill.
I know that the noble Lord, Lord Sikka, and other noble Lords would like a wider debate about the Royal Family and its funding. I recognise that they have raised questions about taxation and the position of the Duchy of Lancaster, and the noble Lord, Lord Berkely, asked about the Duchy of Cornwall. I know these are matters on which the noble Lords hold strong views and considerable expertise, but this Bill is a targeted piece of legislation. Its purpose is to amend the statutory framework governing the sovereign grant so that it continues to operate effectively at the end of the reservicing programme, with appropriate funds being made available. I will turn my attention to those matters.
We have had questions about adequacy—or inadequacy—from the noble Lord, Lord Redwood, and the noble Baroness, Lady Neville-Rolfe. The completion of the capital programme at Buckingham Palace does not mean that all capital programmes have disappeared. There remains a large and complex historic estate that requires ongoing maintenance and long-term planning; that has been included in this budget. There is a need to address the maintenance backlog, to address ageing systems, to strengthen cyber resilience—I mentioned this in my opening speech—and to improve energy efficiency. These funding requirements have been assessed through a detailed bottom-up assessment of the Royal Household’s costs, and an assessment of the Crown Estate’s expected profits over this period. But the key thing is the bottom-up assessment, which comes to £99.9 million; that is reflected across to the 20.5% of the Crown Estate. I will come back to this issue in a little while.
While the Bill reduces the grant, it is done in a way that should reflect the Royal Household’s genuine funding requirements for the years ahead, rather than setting the grant to an arbitrary figure. This has gone via the royal trustees, including the Prime Minister and the Chancellor of the Exchequer. The Chancellor of the Exchequer is my boss, and he would not assent to any thought that money had been spent where he was marking his own homework. This has been a process of some rigour, and a bottom-up process.
However, this still raises the question—it is a big question for some noble Lords on this side of the House—of whether this is value for money. The noble Lord, Lord Sikka, raised a number of questions about the poor and needy people we have in this country, and about how you think about expenditure on the sovereign relative to all the other ways that this money could be spent.
Might I just be a wee bit challenging on this? I tried to think my way through that, and of what I could compare the sovereign grant to. I thought I could compare it to a similar budget for your Lordships’ House, which would be 2.5 times the size of the sovereign grant. I wondered whether we might reflect on how the people of Britain listening to this debate—who, by the way, pay both of those bills—would assess the value of each.
I do not know for sure the answer to that question, but I thought my noble friend Lord Foulkes of Cumnock would recognise the quotation from Robert Burns:
“O wad some Power the giftie gie us
To see oursels as ithers see us!”
I do not know what the answer to that question is. By the way, I am big supporter of your Lordships’ House, and I have a sense that the people of Britain would give considerable support to the payment of a sovereign grant for our King to be able to carry out his duties.