B

Baroness Neville-Rolfe (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 14 October 2026

Debate

Sovereign Grant Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I am grateful to the Minister for introducing the Bill and the context for its passage so clearly. The sovereign grant provides the public funding that is necessary to support the monarch in carrying out their official duties and to meet the associated costs of the Royal Household, including the maintenance of the occupied royal palaces. Those tasks are vital, and it is right that they are provided for. His Majesty’s Official Opposition support the Bill. Like the Minister and my noble friend Lord Redwood, we recognise the considerable contribution made by His Majesty the King and other working members of the Royal Family in carrying out their constitutional and public duties, both at home and overseas. Most of that is admired around the world. The working members work hard, and the profits from the Crown Estate go to the Treasury—as I remember when I sat in the Minister’s seat and the receipts were rising. Buckingham Palace alone attracts some 683,000 visitors each year, which is a big boost to the wider economy. It is not only a symbol of the monarchy and the Royal Family but one of the most recognisable symbols of the UK itself and our national history, which we want people to understand, both here and abroad. Buckingham Palace, Windsor Castle and the Mall provide the setting for some of the great occasions on which this country comes together: royal weddings, state ceremonies, the award of honours, remembrance days and moments of national celebration. These sites are seen by millions at home and around the world and form an important part of how our country presents itself internationally. The sovereign grant helps to ensure that the buildings and spaces for which it is responsible remain fit for purpose, properly maintained and worthy of the national institutions they represent, so that they can continue to be a source of national pride for generations to come. The sovereign themselves plays a vital role in representing our country at home and abroad. They remain, I believe, a significant source of British soft power and of stability, as the noble Baroness, Lady Kramer, pointed out. The central purpose of the Bill is straightforward. The sovereign grant was temporarily increased to meet the costs of the 10-year Buckingham Palace reservicing programme. As that programme reaches its conclusion, it is reasonable that the level of funding should be reconsidered and that those exceptional capital costs should no longer be reflected in the baseline grant. Indeed, the principle that the grant should be reset once the reservicing programme had concluded was established under the previous Government. As we have heard, the Bill accordingly sets the sovereign grant at £99.9 million for 2027-28, compared with £137.9 million in 2026-27. That is a sensible objective, but this Bill does rather more than reset the grant for a single financial year, and I would be grateful for further clarification on the longer-term changes. As the noble Lords, Lord Foulkes of Cumnock and Lord Berkeley, said, it is our job to do the scrutiny that the House of Commons has not had time to give this—although I am not in the same place as them or the noble Lord, Lord Sikka. I will leave the Minister to respond to their wider comments. I turn to my questions on the Bill itself and to Clause 2 and the new reference percentage of 20.5%. The Government have explained that this figure arises from the review undertaken by the royal trustees and that it reflects a bottom-up assessment of the expected requirements, alongside forecasts for Crown Estate revenues. Ministers in the other place also explained that the assessment includes future expenditure on the occupied palaces, modernisation of digital infrastructure and cyber security, and other operating costs. That is helpful, but I hope the Minister can provide the House with a little more detail about the calculation; after all, 20.5% is a very precise figure. Can the Minister explain more fully how the royal trustees translated their assessment of the future needs of the Royal Household into that particular reference percentage? That leads to a wider question of whether the revised mechanism is sufficiently resilient to future changes in Crown Estate revenues. The attraction of a statutory formula is that it provides predictability and a degree of separation between the day-to-day decisions of Ministers and the funding necessary for the discharge of the monarch’s official functions, but any formula is as effective only as the assumptions on which it rests. It would therefore be helpful if the Minister could explain how the Government expect the new arrangements to operate if the Crown Estate revenues depart significantly from current forecasts. How quickly will the system be capable of responding? That brings me to Clause 3, which is the most constitutionally interesting. It provides for an appropriate amount of the sovereign grant to be one that would leave the adjusted value of the reserve fund at no less than 10% and no more than 50% of annual expenditure. Where the normal formula produces a result outside that range and the royal trustees cannot correct it under the existing mechanism, they must identify an appropriate alternative amount and the Treasury must make regulations giving effect to it. Can the Minister explain the basis for those two thresholds? Why were 10% and 50% considered the appropriate lower and upper limits? What assessment has been made of the level of reserves genuinely required for financial resilience? More fundamentally, Clause 3 slightly changes the balance of the existing framework. The 2011 system is principally formula-based. The Bill retains that principle but it also creates circumstances in which the Treasury will have a direct role in altering the amount of grant. There may be perfectly good practical reasons for providing flexibility. Nevertheless, when Ministers are given powers to alter the level of public funding provided under a statutory framework, Parliament is entitled to understand precisely how those powers are intended to operate. That is particularly relevant to new Section 6B, which allows the Treasury to increase the sovereign grant during the course of a financial year when Ministers consider that there are “exceptional” circumstances requiring them to do so. The Treasury must consult the royal trustees, and any such regulations require the approval of the House of Commons. Can the Minister give the House some indication of what the Government envisage falling within that definition? Finally, I return to the underlying purpose of the Bill. There is a perfectly clear rationale for revisiting the sovereign grant as a substantial, time-limited programme of work at Buckingham Palace comes to an end. There is, equally, a strong case for ensuring that the statutory framework is capable of responding where its normal operation would otherwise produce an obviously inappropriate level of funding. We therefore support the Bill, but I look forward to the Minister’s response to the questions I have raised.

More from Baroness Neville-Rolfe (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.