T

The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Department of Health and Social Care (Baroness Merron) (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 13 October 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

My Lords, the NHS matters deeply to people across our country; it profoundly touches all our lives. Every one of us will have our own experience of the National Health Service and our appreciation of the care it provides, and we will all have hopes for its future. As the needs of patients are evolving, so must the National Health Service. Our job is twofold: first, getting the NHS treating patients on time again; and, secondly, reforming the health service so it is fit for the future. These ambitions run throughout the core of the Bill. Modernisation does not mean change simply for its own sake, but making considered changes that drive real and tangible benefits to patients, who are at the heart of all we do. It means making better use of technology, empowering local leaders to meet patient needs, and taking a clear view of what needs to be done nationally so that more funding and resource reach the front line. Before turning to the substance of the legislation, I will make a few points of gratitude and note: first, to all Peers who have engaged constructively with the development and scrutiny of the Bill, and who I know will continue to do so. I also want to appreciate the work of my ministerial colleague, the Minister of State for Health, Karin Smyth MP, who led the Bill through the other place, where there was considered debate of more than 400 amendments in Committee, Report and Third Reading. The Bill was approved at both Second and Third Reading without dividing, which is a sign of the broad consensus on its central aims. On a number of issues, the Government have listened to concerns and amended the Bill. We remain committed to working with both noble Lords and the other place as the Bill continues its passage. I am confident that this House will take a characteristically constructive approach to its important role of scrutinising every line of the Bill. I thank all noble Lords who have already discussed the Bill with me and who attended the information session after First Reading; I look forward to further discussions in the days and weeks ahead. I am sure noble Lords would also want me to congratulate no fewer than five noble Lords—which I understand is a most unusual number, in a good way—on the occasion of their maiden speeches. I thank them for choosing this Bill in which to make their own introduction to this House. I look forward to hearing from them and I warmly welcome them to your Lordships’ House. As the Chief Whip said, we have a world-first today. I am most grateful to the noble Baroness, Lady Campbell, for making this happen, and for making AI help her make her speech. I am grateful not just to the noble Baroness for choosing this Bill in which to do this, but to the parliamentary authorities for making this possible and ensuring that accessibility prevails in this House. I turn first to what I believe is one of the most important reforms in the Bill: the single patient record. For many years, patients, carers, clinicians and campaigners have spoken to the shortcomings of fragmented information systems. Too often, information follows institutions rather than individuals; too often, patients and carers repeat the same story over and over again to different professionals; and all too often, healthcare staff make decisions without a complete picture of a patient’s needs. When records are incomplete or inaccessible, opportunities for mistakes increase and continuity of care can be compromised; at worst, these consequences can be deadly. A report on maternal deaths published in 2025 found that failures to share critical information between providers were a significant factor in nearly half of the cases examined; this could have been avoided. The Bill establishes the legal foundations for the single patient record to create a single, secure and authoritative account of patient information. It will bring together health and social care records so that those providing care can access the information that they need, when they need it. It will empower patients to make informed decisions about their health, while supporting clinicians to provide safer, more joined-up care. Public support, I am glad to say, is strong. Independent public deliberations show that 76% of participants supported the principle of a single patient record. The benefits are real, including every year: 20,000 fewer A&E attendances, 6,000 fewer hospital admissions, more than £20 million in medicines savings and the release of around half a million hours of doctors’ time. This surely is a prize worth having. I am grateful to noble Lords who attended the single patient record round table. I recognise the concerns that were expressed about privacy, confidentiality and public trust, so I can assure your Lordships’ House that the single patient record will operate with strict safeguards, strong cybersecurity measures, clear controls over access, robust oversight arrangements and full compliance with existing legal protections. The Bill is about safer care, not weaker protections. It is about empowering patients; it is not about diminishing their rights. I turn to the abolition of NHS England and the guiding principle of the democratic accountability of our health system. Since NHS England was established, the number of staff working across NHS England and the Department of Health and Social Care has increased substantially. I have experienced the overlapping responsibilities and convoluted processes that slow up decision-making and divert attention away from patient care—something that I know none of us wants. This Bill will return the functions of NHS England to government and the wider NHS system where appropriate. In doing so, it will provide greater clarity for the system. It will restore democratic accountability and free up resources to be reinvested on the front line, where we want to see them. There will also be greater clarity about where responsibility lies, ensuring that Ministers are accountable for national decisions while devolving more power to local NHS organisations. On that point, let me turn to the matter of devolution and local leadership. This Government believe that a more devolved NHS will be a more effective NHS. Those closest to patients are best placed to understand their needs. That is why the Bill devolves decision-making, empowers integrated care boards, strengthens strategic commissioning and provides greater flexibility for local leaders. Having said all that, I also recognise concerns around local representation and expertise. We listened carefully to those concerns during the passage of the Bill in the other place. As a result, the Government amended the Bill to restore the requirement that every ICB includes a local authority member, jointly nominated by relevant upper-tier local authorities. I believe that this amendment strengthens the Bill. It ensures that important expertise on social care and public health continues to inform decision-making and helps to lay the ground for future social care reform. Looking ahead, integrated care boards will act increasingly as strategic commissioners of local health services, with responsibility for a broader range of services and resources, while holding that responsibility in their own right rather than as duties delegated to them by others. We want decisions to be made as close to communities as is feasible, with the ICBs providing strategic leadership while working closely with local authorities and other local partners. Neighbourhood health will be at the very heart of this approach. I know that patient safety is a concern shared by noble Lords across the House. Before turning to that issue, I extend my congratulations to the noble Baroness, Lady Neuberger, on her appointment as chair of the Care Quality Commission. I look forward to working with her and I am sure we all wish her well. No Government should ever pretend that things do not go wrong in the NHS. When they do, patients, families and the public must have confidence that lessons will be learned and acted upon. The independent review, led by Dr Penny Dash, identified a patient safety landscape that has become cluttered and confusing. The sheer number of recommendations to health bodies in this landscape—over 1,400 in the last 30 years—can make it very difficult for them to focus on doing the right thing. The Bill streamlines that landscape. It transfers the functions of the Health Services Safety Investigations Body to the Care Quality Commission, helping to create a clearer connection between learning from failures and improving care. At the same time, we will ensure that vital safe space protections remain in place. The Government also recognise the importance of ensuring that the CQC is ready to take on these functions, and that is why we are taking a carefully managed approach to implementation and have been working closely with the CQC to monitor its operational readiness. This transfer will happen only when the CQC is ready. I want to assure your Lordships’ House how seriously we take consideration of patient safety. We will listen to noble Lords’ concerns and keep them updated on any and all progress in this important area. The Dash review also spelled out how to simplify the arrangements for the patient voice. The Bill abolishes Healthwatch England and local Healthwatch, placing responsibility for listening and responding to patients and the public with the organisations that plan and commission services: ICBs and local authorities. Again, I recognise that noble Lords have raised concerns about these reforms, and I am grateful to my noble friend Lord Hunt for meeting me to discuss them. I look forward to continuing discussions with noble Lords as part of our review of these measures. Let me take a moment to remind the House of the additional amendments that the Government have made during the passage of the Bill thus far. They relate to pharmacy regulations, visiting in health and care settings and reforms relating to medicines and medical devices. Together, these changes support patient well-being and access to high-quality care and innovation. In bringing my remarks to a close, I wish to highlight one further commitment relating to a statutory maternity and neonatal commissioner. The Government accepted the recommendation of my noble friend Lady Amos, and I thank her and her team for all their hard work in delivering the national maternity and neonatal investigation. The Secretary of State has made it a priority to bring forward an amendment to establish a statutory maternity and neonatal commissioner to provide independent leadership, oversight and accountability for maternity and neonatal care in England. This is an important opportunity to strengthen accountability and champion the interests of women, babies and families throughout the system. I thank noble Lords for the questions and points they have raised about the role, and I look forward to working with them on this important development. The Bill will not solve every challenge facing the NHS, but it will be a significant and necessary step towards a modern, accountable and patient-centred health service. It will help information to follow patients rather than institutions. It will reduce bureaucracy and strengthen accountability. It will give local leaders greater freedom to deliver for their communities, and it will place the patient voice closer to decision-making. I, for one, welcome all of that, and I beg to move.

More from The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Department of Health and Social Care (Baroness Merron) (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.