B

Baroness Campbell of Surbiton (CB)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 13 October 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

My Lords, before I contribute to this debate, I would like to thank the Procedure Committee for allowing me to bring my AI-generated voice into the Chamber, and the technical department and the other members of the House of Lords staff who have made this possible. This is cutting-edge technology that will enable me to contribute to debates in my own, once-clear voice before it begins to deteriorate due to my disability. I hope that your Lordships will agree with me that this is an exciting development for the House of Lords, showcasing to the world inclusion in democracy at its best. With that, may I introduce noble Lords to Baroness Campbell mark 2? I welcome the Bill and share much of its vision. The Government’s commitment to integrated, personalised care and support is long overdue. If implemented correctly, it could transform thousands of lives. However, I also feel compelled to deliver a warning against the potential re-emergence of an institutional medical model. For decades, the disabled people’s Independent Living Movement has fought clinical paternalism, which defines us by our medical condition. We are individuals with the right to control our lives, choosing what we do and who supports us. NHS personal health budgets—PHBs—were designed to give individuals support to lead ordinary lives on their own terms, however complex their medical needs. The 2019 guidance promised greater choice and control and enhanced independent living. Direct payments enable people to employ personal assistants, or PAs, and to decide how and when they are supported, so I am nervous when I hear the Prime Minister speaking of healthcare and social care staff as one workforce. We must not replace personal control with a one-size-fits-all service. Notional personal health budgets in a national care service could squeeze out direct payments in favour of standardised care packages. Where a PHB is a direct payment, individuals have greater control over NHS funding, and it offers better value, with average savings of 12% to 16% compared with conventional services. Some ICBs are showing creeping rigidity over the use of PHBs. As I recently highlighted in the Guardian, individuals have been prevented using budgets to enable their PA/carer to support them when they are away from home. Lucinda Ritchie was forced into residential care from hospital against her will, rather than returning to her adapted bungalow and her experienced PA team. Only after we raised the alarm and involved the BBC did her ICB change its mind. This will not do. In July, the Minister and I discussed my proposal for an inquiry into ICB practices to address these issues. Perhaps she could update me on this, and on whether the Government remain committed to PHBs for 1 million people by 2030 and for anyone who would benefit from them by 2035. Sadly, evidence from the Coalition for Personalised Care tells a different story. Since the restructure, hardly any ICBs have a named lead for PHB expansion. Without the dedicated NHS England team, PHBs have declined from 188,489 in 2023-24. An NHS-funded PA/carer provides essential support for people with complex needs. I am here today contributing equally with your Lordships as a result of a PHB. I am fortunate. Denying portability effectively institutionalises a person at home. When systems dictate that people cannot travel or place rigid rules around support, they treat the home like a hospital ward, flying in the face of Article 19 of the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, ratified by the UK in 2009. I will therefore be scrutinising the Bill to ensure that integration and devolution to ICBs does not weaken PHB protections and freedoms. Choice must be safeguarded through stronger guidance, including a right to portability and flexibility. ICBs must not use residential care or budget withdrawal to coerce individuals. Let us ensure that the medical model does not swallow decades of progress on disability rights and independent living. I am not a medical diagnosis but a wife, grandparent and working member of the House of Lords. ICBs would do well to reflect on that.

More from Baroness Campbell of Surbiton (CB)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.