B

Baroness Tyler of Enfield (LD)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 13 October 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

My Lords, it is an absolute pleasure and privilege to follow the first two speakers and to directly follow the noble Earl, Lord Howe, a veteran of the 2012 Bill; and I am very much looking forward to no fewer than five maiden speeches. As we have heard, the Bill introduces significant structural changes to the NHS —although some of them feel contradictory—and of course the development of a single patient record, but these must be viewed within the wider context of the state of health and care in this country. According to the Health Foundation, while we have seen some welcome improvements, the big picture is that health inequalities are widening—particularly the life expectancy of the richest and of the poorest—healthy life expectancy is falling, declining working-age health is costing the economy dear, and waiting times remain unacceptably high. The big question for me is whether this Bill provides a legislative framework to enable the three “big shifts” set out in the 10-year plan, because there is a clear consensus that we need to move to a more preventive community-based health system. The obvious concern is that these structural reforms will simply serve as a distraction from much-needed improvements in patient care, service design, workforce planning and productivity gains. I will touch briefly on four key issues. Other very important issues, including structures, a single patient record and patient safety, will be covered by my noble friend. The Bill transfers to the Secretary of State a duty to consider inequalities in access to health services and outcomes achieved. Although welcome, that is not nearly strong enough. The Bill should place a clear duty on the Secretary of State to act to reduce health inequalities, a call supported by many external organisations. This needs to be accompanied by co-ordinated action across government to tackle the wider social determinants of health, along with transparent reporting on progress. There is a golden opportunity in this Bill to put tackling health inequalities on a statutory footing, and I look forward to working with other noble Peers to get the Bill substantially strengthened. On patient voice, in the debate on the King’s Speech I expressed my serious concerns about the proposal to abolish Healthwatch England and local Healthwatch. At Report in the other place, following strong concerns about removing trusted and independent channels for people to make their voices heard, the Government committed to review the Healthwatch provisions. I welcome this and very much hope that the Government will think again. The Bill as drafted unhelpfully separates public voice functions concerning the NHS from those related to social care and public health. It does not put an equivalent independent national and local patient voice function on a statutory footing. I know that many noble Lords, like me, want the Government’s review to deliver a system which both preserves independence and has sufficient authority to secure action when concerns are raised. At the risk of stating the obvious, the most cost-effective route would be to stick with the current arrangements, particularly the trusted local relationships built up by local Healthwatch over 13 years. So I ask the Minister: what is the scope of and timescale for this review, and who will be consulted? I now turn to unpaid carers. I pay tribute to the 4.7 million unpaid carers in England, whose contribution is vital to our health and care system. The value of the care they provide is estimated at £152 billion a year in England—roughly equivalent to the NHS budget—and unpaid carers outnumber NHS staff by around 3:1. Despite this, carers can too often feel invisible and unsupported by the NHS. This Bill provides an important opportunity to ensure that carers are recognised by the NHS and can rely on support such as respite breaks actually being available. So I intend to bring forward an amendment to introduce a new duty on ICBs to identify unpaid carers and to match what already happens within local authorities, along with an amendment to strengthen provision for breaks for unpaid carers. I want to talk briefly about what I call the forgotten areas. Adult social care is largely absent from the Bill. That is a real missed opportunity for integration. The Prime Minister has brought forward the publication of the Casey commission’s final report to next summer and has committed to setting out plans for a national care service before the next general election, but I do not think that we can wait that long. Significant challenges remain in the short term. Pressure on providers, workforce shortages and unmet need continue to pose major challenges to both social care and the NHS, meaning that urgent action to stabilise the sector is vital while longer-term reforms are developed. There are other things that I would like to have said on children’s and young people’s health and mental health services, but time prevents me doing so. In my view, those areas are very much overlooked in the Bill, so I intend to return to them in Committee. I would very much welcome further discussion with the Minister and her team on the issues that I have raised. I look forward to working with her, along with other noble Lords on all Benches.

More from Baroness Tyler of Enfield (LD)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.