B

Baroness Tyler of Enfield (LD)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 28 October 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I underline first of all what the noble Lord, Lord Hunt, said about how very less than ideal it is to be dealing with an important group of amendments of such sensitivity this late in the day, but we are where we are. I very much support the amendments put forward by the noble Lord. I remember clearly my personal anguish at not being able to visit my mother for a long time in her care home. It really was agony for me. What happened during Covid must never be allowed to happen again. I think of those care home residents who died without the love and support of any of their relatives by them. It is an absolute scandal. It is shocking. We must make sure it does not happen again. My amendments are about unpaid carers and their relationship with the NHS. As we know, unpaid carers have very frequent contact with the NHS, but recognition and support for them can be very variable indeed. This Health Bill presents an important opportunity to place essential rights and support for unpaid carers in legislation for the first time, to bring them on a par with existing rights that carers already have in relation to local authorities. My amendments are designed to improve the identification, health and well-being of carers, as well as improving the provision of breaks, to which they should be entitled. There are some 4.7 million unpaid carers in England, and the value of carer support is worth £152 billion in England alone. That happens to be about the same as the budget of the whole NHS. We have so many unpaid carers that they are holding the NHS together. Turning to Amendment 88, on the duty to identify and record unpaid carers, the Care Act 2014 already places duties on local authorities relating to the identification of unpaid carers, but no equivalent duty exists for integrated care boards, which commission in the vast majority to health services. Unpaid carers are more likely to come into contact with health services earlier than they are with local authorities, and there is evidence of significant underidentification of unpaid carers within the NHS. Analysis by the Nuffield Trust of 13 million GP records found that for every one carer identified by GP practices, four were not, meaning around 1 million carers were effectively missing from GP records. So, there are real problems with identification rates, which are compounded by the fact that more carers are identified in affluent areas than in deprived areas. There are many cogent reasons why identification is important. For example, public health measures can be targeted at unpaid carers, such as free flu vaccinations and assessments for common health problems. Winter pressures on the NHS can be alleviated with targeted support and advice for unpaid carers, and of course, inclusion of unpaid carers in hospital discharge planning could help to reduce avoidable readmissions. That is just to name but three. The last key point I will make here is that, ironically, unpaid carers can take a long time to identify themselves and understand that they are carers. In fact, some research I saw said that for some 36%, it took up to three years to understand they were a carer. Without a statutory duty, I fear that identification of carers will continue to depend on local priorities and resources. While some areas have excellent systems, others identify very few carers. A statutory duty here would introduce much greater consistency. Amendment 89 would place a duty on ICBs to promote the health and well-being of carers. I think we all know that unpaid carers consistently experience poorer physical and mental health outcomes than non-carers: they just forget and neglect their own health needs. I have just one statistic here: the GP Patient Survey 2025 found that 72% of carers reported a long-term condition or disability, compared with 60% of non-carers. Many carers are just not able to prioritise their own health. Most tellingly, Carers Week research from last year found that 40% of current carers said they had postponed or cancelled a medical appointment, test, scan, treatment or therapy because of caring. That is an estimated 4.8 million people. My final point here is that ICBs rely heavily on unpaid carers to keep people well at home and reduce hospital admissions. Therefore, supporting carers’ health, I maintain, is vital to NHS sustainability. Finally, my Amendments 175 and 176 are about a right to a break for unpaid carers and a national respite scheme, and I very much thank other noble Lords who have added their names to these amendments, and to all my amendments in this group. These two amendments essentially do the same thing: they ensure that carers who are assessed as being entitled to a break actually receive one, because although many carers in England are entitled to this assessment under the Care Act, many assessments just do not result in meaningful breaks or replacement care. There are many statistics here, but I will mention just one: official data from 2023-24 shows that only 8% of all unpaid carers were assessed or supported by their local authority, which is a shockingly low figure. Unsurprisingly, carers describe severe exhaustion, burnout, isolation and worsening mental health resulting from being unable to step away from these caring responsibilities. Local flexibility in the delivery of breaks has too often resulted in inconsistency and postcode variation. Whether an unpaid carer can access a meaningful break should not depend on where they live or the financial pressures facing their local authority. That is why Amendment 176 also establishes a requirement for the Secretary of State to provide financial assistance to deliver this. There was much more I wanted to say, but the time is very late.

More from Baroness Tyler of Enfield (LD)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.