Contribution
My Lords, I am very grateful to the right reverend Prelate for supporting amendments around the rights of carers. We look forward to debating that in Committee.
Overall, I welcome the Bill. I see it as removing the last vestiges of the 2012 changes introduced by the noble Lord, Lord Lansley; it places Ministers at the heart of decision-making and improves patient outcomes through the single patient record.
I listened with great interest to the noble Earl, Lord Howe. We have been debating NHS structures for far too long. He looked back of course to the 2011 debates that we had on that Bill. In your Lordships’ House in October 2011, we had two days of Second Reading debate with over 100 speakers, such was the concern about the Bill. My noble friend Lady Thornton played a leading role in that. The noble Earl said that the upheaval then was a price worth paying, but I put to him that it was a hugely unpopular, hugely expensive and damaging restructuring. I looked at his Second Reading speech then, and he anticipated that to an extent. But he argued, in essence, and he said it today, that the aim of the proposals from the noble Lord, Lord Lansley, whom we will hear from very soon on this, was to make the service patient-centred and to give greater autonomy to clinicians. But that did not really end well, did it? Because the reality was anything but.
In essence, GPs were not prepared to take on the task of commissioning services; NHS England never established full independence; and Ministers refused to take responsibility for large aspects of the running of the service. What is so tragic, looking back, is that the coalition Government inherited the NHS in the best condition it had ever been. Waiting lists had been virtually eradicated with the 18-week wait for elective surgery and the four-hour wait in A&E; 100 new hospitals had been built or were in the process of being built; and there were new services such as NHS Direct, which was far better than the current service that we have, because qualified nurses were the people who took the calls.
In 2010, the British Social Attitude Survey showed public satisfaction with the NHS at an all-time high of 70%: by 2024 it had fallen to 20%. During the years following those changes, there has been a continuous stripping away of that blueprint, but the framework lingered and undoubtedly contributed to NHS performance deterioration. That is why I welcome direct ministerial control and the resulting enhanced accountability to Parliament.
My noble friend stressed devolved decision-making. I agree with that. What I would say to her is that it has to be balanced out by strengthening mechanisms of local accountability and scrutiny as well. That is why I very much welcome the review in relation to Healthwatch. My hope is that a strong, independent public voice at local level will be maintained. I also hope and urge my noble friend to re-look at the proposals to abolish councils of governors for foundation trusts. They play a really effective role. Local people get involved in the running of their hospital by electing governors. The governors hold the board to account. They are a vital safeguard, being the eyes and ears of local people in their local institutions. They can broaden the trust connection with local communities. Numerous visits to patient areas provide valuable feedback. The National Lead Governors’ Association has shown in its briefings to us that it can be a statutory, independent warning system, escalating front-line safety concerns to non-executive directors. So, I hope the Government will look again at these proposals.
My noble friend rightly pinpointed the single patient record as the most important aspect of this Bill. I agree with her. She will be asked questions about the confidentiality of patient information. She will have seen, I think, the recent HSJ and Sky News survey that showed most NHS trusts are ill prepared to protect patient information. She will have seen the prosecution of staff in some cases, and certainly disciplinary action against staff who have looked inappropriately at patient records. Clearly, that will be a matter for debate. Overall, I very much welcome this Bill and look forward to our debates in Committee.