L

Lord Lansley (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 13 October 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I am glad to have the opportunity to contribute, not least coming straight after the noble Lord, Lord Hunt of Kings Heath. Having listened to my noble friend Earl Howe on the Front Bench, noble Lords will be aware of how lucky I always was to have him on the health team and speaking on behalf of the team in this House. It means I do not have to revisit all those issues; I thought he explained perfectly well what the intentions of the 2012 Act were. I will add just a single point: the 2012 Act was not implemented. Clinical leadership on the part of general practitioners was stifled, pretty much at birth, by the way in which the management systems in the NHS told them they could live with the deficits or they could have autonomy; they could not have both. And NHS England was not created by the 2012 Act; it was the accretion of subsequent responsibilities. What was created was the NHS Commissioning Board, and the focus on commissioning and clinical leadership is what we should continue to have at the forefront of our mind. If there was duplication with the department, it was largely because the department never let go. Ministers did not understand that they had to let go; they had to give the NHS autonomy, otherwise inevitably there would be confusion and duplication. I read the Bill looking for the positive purpose, and all I find is abolition: abolition of NHS England, abolition of Healthwatch, abolition of the HSSIB, and abolition of foundation trusts. What I wanted to find in the Bill was positive purpose. I follow not least the noble Baronesses, Lady Tyler of Enfield and Lady Campbell of Surbiton, in saying there is much we can do now to deliver on a government manifesto commitment. None of these things in the Bill are manifesto commitments. What there is, is a commitment to a national care service. We should use this Bill and the debates around it to help to fashion that by, as the noble Baroness, Lady Campbell, said, strengthening the existing statutory provisions for personal budgets that combine health and social entitlements; by strengthening joint commissioning between ICBs and local authorities through devolution; by implementing the cap on care costs in the Care Act 2014, which has been in legislation for 12 years and no subsequent executive has seen fit to implement Parliament’s intentions. I listened with interest and approval to what the Prime Minister said about the difficulty of people with severe dementia not accessing NHS Continuing Care in circumstances where somebody with cancer would. We can deal with that and I will bring forward an amendment that should, if it works, enable more people with severe dementia to access NHS Continuing Care. We can do positive things with this Bill and I hope we shall. When it comes to abolishing NHS England, I just say to the Minister that she should be careful what she wishes for because every issue will land on the Minister’s desk. At the moment, Ministers are still wandering around saying they have cut the waiting list by half a million. Good grief, when I left the department, the waiting list was 2.64 million; it is now 7.37 million. The numbers have been going up, not going down, in the past three months. She says that patients should be treated on time. When I left, 162,000 patients were waiting more than 18 weeks; it is now two and a quarter million. There is a very long way to go. If she thinks running everything from the Department of Health is going to solve the problems, she might like to talk to her former colleagues in Cardiff, because running things from Cardiff did not sort the problems of the NHS in Wales. I think she might like to think again about whether this will solve her problems. I do not need to repeat what my noble friend said from the Front Bench about the importance of the independence of the HSSIB in relation to its investigations and the patient voice through Healthwatch, and I hope this House will be robust in defending them. I hope that the single patient record will work. I am scarred from trying to manage the results of introducing new technology in the NHS, but I think this time we have to crack it. It is important to have the statutory provision and the implementation very firmly in our debates. Finally, I will just say this: my noble friend was right that commissioning and clinical leadership in the NHS are exactly where we should focus our efforts and make sure that we give clinical leaders in the NHS the autonomy to make that happen.

More from Lord Lansley (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.