L

Lord Stevens of Birmingham (CB)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 13 October 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

My Lords, it is almost as if we are intruding on private grief as this debate unfolds, but what a pleasure it is to join so many distinguished former colleagues from across the National Health Service. Frankly, there is much to welcome in this Bill, but at its heart is yet another top-down administrative reorganisation of the NHS. Folding NHS England into a government department and converting operational managers into Whitehall civil servants clearly corresponds to the current zeitgeist, but as we legislate, I suggest that we should be clear-eyed about both the potential benefits and the inherent risks. The strongest argument in favour of folding NHS England into the department is clearly that it offers the opportunity to reduce duplication—fewer checkers and more doers. In fairness, I think it is also the case that the Secretary of State could have achieved the same result with a more explicit division of labour between NHS England and the Department of Health and Social Care, which is what the Government’s impact statement says—namely, that headcount reductions could have been made by the Department of Health and Social Care without legislation. Picking up on the point made by the noble Earl, Lord Howe, I think it is surprising that a year and a half after the announcement was made about the abolition of NHS England, when describing the so-called full economic assessment of what the costs and the benefits will be in the impact assessment, all the cells where there should be pound notes are blank. The costs are described as not available and the benefits are described as not available. All we have is the press release that was issued at the time of the original Budget. As to the philosophical argument about the need to promote more democracy, let us be clear: this is not a binary. It is not about control or no control by the Secretary of State; it is matters of degree. Our Health Secretary sets the NHS budget, sets its priorities and oversees its performance. Although we have cast our mind back to 2012, let us not forget that, in 2022, Parliament set up the arrangements that we are now about to disband. Since the 2022 Act, the Secretary of State has also had a legal general power of direction, and this Bill proposes even more of that. Particularly striking are measures that would allow political appointments throughout the NHS locally. Turning the clock back 25 years, Schedule 3 gives the Health Secretary the power to appoint political place people to every hospital board in the country. Even more surprisingly, Clause 37 allows the Secretary of State to fire individual named executive directors of foundation trusts, and Clause 11, in effect, means that for the first time ever in the history of the National Health Service, local health board chief executives serve at the pleasure of the Secretary of State, whose subjective opinion determines their hiring and firing. However sanguine we may be about the way in which those powers would be exercised by the current Government, one has only to look across the Atlantic to envisage a future in which that could be a cause of considerable and deep-seated concern. So, yes, removing duplication; a debate about what democracy really means in this context; but the third “D” is, of course, the risk of disruption. Frankly, the NHS is feeling the effect of that at the moment. The new Secretary of State, Yvette Cooper, has reportedly and rightly been asking how all this administrative turbulence is affecting the big patient care challenges facing the NHS. Waiting lists remain stubbornly over 7 million, despite heroic efforts across the service to get them down. Cancer waiting times are off track by up to three years. In maternity and early years, Yvette Cooper has again rightly focused on the need for further attention. Parliament has just had a divisive debate on assisted dying, but one thing we all agreed on was the need for better palliative and end-of-life care. The modern service framework is currently missing in action. All of this runs the risk of distracting from the things that would genuinely make a difference to patients. Instead, 18 months on from the original announcement, we still do not have the operating model which the NHS is supposed to be putting into place from April next year. We have unclear resourcing for ICBs, which will not even know their boundaries, apparently, until at least 2028, and the role of the regions, not mentioned in the Bill, as yet undefined. As the old adage says, only two things will survive a nuclear war, cockroaches and the regional tier of the National Health Service. It would be good to hear a little more on that front. The practical test for this Bill, therefore, is: will the changes actually improve patient care? Will they drive value for taxpayers? Many believe that this is, as we progress, the triumph of hope over experience. Our job at the amending stage of this legislation is to try and improve the chances of success.

More from Lord Stevens of Birmingham (CB)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.