Contribution
My Lords, I am very glad to follow the noble Lord, Lord Stevens, with whom, as another old colleague, I have had many discussions on many issues on the health service, not always in agreement. I congratulate the Government on introducing this Bill to modernise the service, with its explicit emphasis—and I emphasise explicit—on patient experience. The plan to place patient experience alongside clinical outcomes as a key measure of care quality is enormously important and, I would say to the noble Lord, Lord Lansley, a very positive purpose of this particular legislation. Some of these proposals, as he will know too well, have been in the pipeline a long time, and it is very welcome that they will now be properly enacted.
In the interests of time, I will mention just some of the improving changes which have particularly occurred to me and then raise a couple of questions about delivery. First, I am extremely pleased that every integrated care board will have members representing local authorities, and that, as the Minister has said, Commons amendments have already strengthened this membership. I am certain from previous experience on district health authorities that including some of the people from neighbourhood services, such as housing and transport, will improve public health and indirectly reduce inequalities.
A major change which will directly benefit patients is one which other speakers have mentioned: the final arrival—and it is a final arrival—of the single patient record. It seems extraordinary to me that it was 25 years ago that I was the Minister responsible for trying to streamline patient records in this way. After a lot of effort, that proposal was bogged down in many objections about shared technology and confidentiality. I am sure the details about the new electronic patient record will be rightly closely examined in Committee, because there are in fact, in this new digital age, some justifiable concerns, some of them from across the Atlantic, about who is ultimately handling and indeed owning the confidential patient data.
To me, it is reassuring that in future, overall responsibility for patient experiences will be integrated into a new directorate with responsibility at ministerial level. I welcome the fact that it may be possible to revive the original Nye Bevan commitment to answer all questions about the health service at the Dispatch Box. However, in spite of the new directorate, I have some questions about how public involvement and patient voices are to be effectively organised.
I do not think it can be stressed too often, as speakers have done before me, that a successful system must be independent, easy to access and have clear lines of accountability. Anyone wanting to express an opinion about their care or raise a complaint about treatment should be sure that this can be done in a straightforward way to an independent authority, and that, if necessary, quick action will be taken.
My main concern about patient voices is, as has been mentioned, the abolition of the Healthwatch structure, particularly at a local level. I can understand completely the laudable ambition to bring patient voices directly to the boards that commission and organise their services, but I am afraid that this can appear a more daunting official channel than the informal and, to many people, safer neighbourhood space of Healthwatch. I was frankly alarmed to learn that the figures show that, in 2024, over half of those who experienced what they described as “bad care” said they did not report it because they feared that doing so might jeopardise any future treatment. We need to be certain that any new system does not deter any service user from coming forward, especially, for example, if they are particularly vulnerable in some way or may be put off by complicated IT systems.
The Minister has already helpfully said that the Government are committed to reconsidering some of these proposals in this House. I also note that at Third Reading in the Commons, the Secretary of State spoke of “some previous arrangements”. May I ask the Minister and her colleagues to look again at the record of community health councils, which were abolished in 2003? I think they still hold some valuable ideas for the development of patient empowerment in 2026. I look forward to further proceedings on this important modernising Bill.