L

Lord Young of Cookham (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 13 October 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

My Lords, it is a pleasure to follow the noble Baroness with her ministerial experience. My view is that this Bill should be judged against the three priorities that the Government set for the NHS two years ago: from analogue to digital, from hospital to community, and from sickness to prevention. First, on analogue to digital and the single patient record, we do not actually have a National Health Service. We have a series of local health services—medical centres, pharmacies and district general hospitals, held together by a network that is often not fit for purpose. Quite often, it is not the individual treatments or consultations that go astray but the communications between them. Hence the need for a single patient record. A recent personal experience confirmed this. At a routine annual check-up, the consultant recommended a precautionary jab for shingles and said that she would notify my GP. Two weeks later, nothing had happened, so I contacted my GP. I quote from her subsequent reply to the consultant: “The letter we have received includes an attachment PDF but we are unable to open this link in the format that you have sent this letter. Please could you send us the PDF document as an opened document to action”. This was an NHS GP communicating with an NHS consultant within the same foundation trust about a treatment. Technology has transformed a doctor’s instruction from one that was illegible to one that is inaccessible. In my case, it did not matter, but it shows how the professionalism of those working for the NHS can be let down. Hopefully, a single patient record will remedy this. I note that GPs have expressed some reservations. I know from my experience as a Health Minister over 40 years ago that GPs can defend their corner with vigour. At that time, the BMA negotiators were their chairman, Sir Anthony Grabham, and their future vice-president, David Bolt. When it came to negotiating resources for the GP contract, “Grabham and Bolt” is exactly what happened. On the second priority—from hospital to community —the ICB will have more commissioning powers to focus on primary care and community services. I very much welcome that, but I fear the major shift from hospital to community has been kicked into the long grass by the Government’s approach to adult care, as mentioned by the noble Baroness, Lady Tyler. This is the fifth Parliament since 1997 with a healthy government majority to duck that issue. Every day, there are 13,000 people in hospital who do not need to be there because of the absence of reform of social care. The dish that was oven-ready in 2019 is still waiting for a recipe. If the noble Baroness, Lady Casey, had been instructed to report within two years, we could have had her report by now and legislated in the next Session. This unforgivable procrastination will make achieving the targets in the 10-year plan more difficult. Finally, on sickness to prevention, I very much welcome the Tobacco and Vapes Act and its generational ban on selling cigarettes, as well as the record investment in smoking cessation services. However, funding that was previously ring-fenced at ICB level is now going to be part of a baseline budget and under threat. Research from ASH has found that the removal of this ring-fence has already led to services being decommissioned, and some 83% of services said that they face an uncertain future because of a lack of secure funding. When it comes to funding prevention, we have the mechanism for raising £5 billion over five years through a “polluter pays” levy on tobacco manufacturers, for which the noble Lord, Lord Rennard, and I have been advocating for many years and which the Minister supported in opposition. With the Chancellor searching for cash, we could both begin by recommending that to him.

More from Lord Young of Cookham (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.