Contribution
My Lords, I say to the noble Lord, Lord Young of Cookham, that I could always read my writing, most of the time. I have accused the noble Earl, Lord Howe, previously of being a class act and I repeat that today. With his usual silken charm, he demonstrated how wonderful the 2012 Bill that he took through this House was. He succeeded partly because he had the ironclad majority of a coalition Government. Despite hundreds of amendments, he was successful in not giving quarter on any of them. However, I compliment him and accept that Healthwatch England, the public health measures that were put into the Bill and the safety arrangements were part of his doing in this House, which he conceded to not through amendment but his own charm.
This is the second Bill in a 30-year history of major reorganisation of every part of the NHS. Research by think tanks shows that they often end up not achieving what they set out to do, as the 2012 Bill proved. Some say the Bill is not necessary. Certainly, some parts of it are probably not. But it should be judged not simply on the organisational reforms it introduces but on whether it strengthens the NHS’s ability to deliver on the Government’s wider agenda to improve the health and health outcomes of the most disadvantaged.
The Bill will abolish NHS England and transfer its powers to the Secretary of State. Additional powers extend far beyond this. While the powers of the Secretary of State are far-ranging, there is nothing in the Bill on powers to improve the health of the nation, tackle variations in care and reduce the inequalities of healthy life expectancy and outcomes. I hope through amendments to try to have discussions about improving the health of the nation and reducing inequality.
Healthwatch has been mentioned several times. I agree that abolishing Healthwatch, the only independent voice of the patient, is probably not necessary. Annexing Healthwatch England and local Healthwatch with ICBs will weaken the independence and the voice of patients, particularly those of the marginalised and the frail. The NHS as a whole is poor at listening to the voice of patients. It is often patronising, as evidenced by the reports of many inquiries, from the Francis inquiry on Mid Staffs to the recent maternity services inquiries. All of them reported that patients’ voices were not listened to.
Structural changes will not lead to making the voice of the patient stronger. While there is some variation in local Healthwatch, we have been mostly successful in bringing together communities, social care and other public services. Equally, abolishing the HSSIB is unnecessary and we should restore it. In fact, we should give it more powers to establish a process for the reporting of incidents. In my view, Clause 65 is therefore not necessary.
I welcome the single patient record strategy, which has much to offer, but how it is to be implemented will be in secondary legislation. There are serious issues relating to transparency, confidentiality, control of access to data and, importantly, public trust that need to be addressed, as the Minister mentioned. How is information that patients do not want to share, such as in maternity and mental health, to be handled?
I have concerns about the lifting of the common law of confidentiality, abiding to which is a promise that all health professionals make through taking an oath and is never to be broken. I intend to amend Clause 52 to reinstate the common law of confidentiality so that it applies to all those who share patient data. At the same time, it will help public trust. I hope the House will find common cause with that amendment. Implemented with care, the SPR has the potential to improve patient and population health and drive innovation.
It is disappointing that the Government did not take the opportunity with this Bill to address some of the commitments already made, such as in rare cancers, neonatal care, mental health and, importantly, end-of-life care, which is espoused by the Prime Minister. I look forward to our discussions. I will enthusiastically support any amendments that improve the Bill, and I hope my amendments will also do so.