Contribution
My Lords, I congratulate my noble friend Lord Jabbar on his excellent maiden speech; it was a wonderful contribution to our deliberations, full of warmth, humility and humour. I am particularly pleased to welcome a fellow Mancunian to your Lordships’ House, since my noble friend lived and was educated in my former constituency—although I take absolutely no credit for his future eminent career. Again, I offer him many congratulations on his speech; we all look forward to many more in the future.
I turn to my own brief contribution to the Second Reading of the Health Bill. I carefully listened to my noble friend the Minister’s opening of the debate, but I have to say that I am still rather perplexed. It is still not clear whether the Bill is a key part of the Government’s drive for devolution, via the transfer of power to local communities to determine how they tackle huge local health inequalities, the development of neighbourhood care centres and the moving of services from acute hospitals to primary and community settings; or whether it is a centralising Bill, with the Secretary of State for Health and Social Care taking back huge powers to determine the priorities for healthcare across the country. I accept that these are not binary positions, but clarity of purpose, responsibility and accountability is essential. Throughout our deliberations on the Bill, we will be seeking such clarifications.
For example, we will seek clarity on how the public’s voice and, crucially, the patient’s voice will be heard loud and clear, and independently, at local level following the proposed abolition of Healthwatch and the councils of governors on hospital trusts; and clarity on exactly when NHS England will be abolished. Is that in 2027, 2028 or beyond? There is still confusion among the staff in both NHS England and the Department of Health about exactly when these things will happen, and these are costs that are building up within the health service.
We need clarity on the role and accountability of regional NHS offices, particularly in relation to commissioning—this is from my particular interest in the commissioning of health and justice—and the relationship of elected mayors with a direct appointment to ICBs with the strategy for local healthcare. We also need an assurance from the Minister, which I hope she will be able to give me today, that the provision in the Health and Social Care Act 2012 that every ICB should include a non-executive director to have specific oversight of mental health services in local areas is maintained.
I will say a brief further word on specialist commissioning currently undertaken by NHS England, again in respect of health and justice, because under the new commissioning plan such services will be devolved to ICBs. Will the Minister confirm that all resources will be transferred from specialist commissioning at NHS England to ICBs and, in future, will the Department of Health have oversight and accountability for the continued development of health and justice services?
Next, I will make a brief comment on the single patient record, which I greatly support. I thank my noble friend the Minister for her letter last week attempting to clarify the Government’s position regarding the criminal justice system. The letter states that relevant healthcare professionals providing direct care in criminal justice settings will be able to access the single patient record information, but this would not give the police, courts and other criminal justice personnel general access to the single patient record. Will the Minister provide a clear definition of “direct care” and confirm that liaison and diversion healthcare staff, especially mental health nurses who provide crucial healthcare support in police stations, courts, prisons and street triage, will have access to these records?
I have two quick final points. The first is to advocate again for allied health professionals and, noting my own interest here in the register, including speech and language therapists, so that they will be afforded appropriate prescribing rights to facilitate the development and efficiency of neighbourhood healthcare.
Secondly, the Government have confirmed today that they will bring forward an amendment in this House to establish a maternity commissioner, which I fully support. However, I find it strange that when I and many other noble Lords advocated for a mental health commissioner during our recent Mental Health Bill deliberations, that was vigorously resisted by the Minister. She argued that the then Government were opposed to the establishment of commissioners and that the CQC was the appropriate body, as the regulator, to have oversight of such mental health services. Have the Government now changed their mind and is it now the intention that further commissioners can be established? I suspect this may be further debated during the passage of the Bill.