L

Lord Black of Brentwood (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 13 October 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I join the noble Lord in congratulating the noble Lord, Lord Jabbar, on his excellent maiden speech, and look forward to the others today. I welcome the opportunity that the Health Bill gives us to discuss significant public health issues, and the Minister will not be surprised that what I want primarily to address is fracture prevention—this is our second outing today. More than 3 million people in England live with osteoporosis; many do not know it, with damaging consequences for their health, ability to work and quality of life. Half of women and one in five men will break a bone because of it, and the end result of untreated osteoporosis—a hip fracture—is the second largest cause of unplanned NHS bed days. An horrendous postcode lottery means that people from deprived areas are at a 25% higher risk of fractures. The Prime Minister wants good growth in every postcode, and I hope that he will start here, as good health is crucial to good growth. Much pain and suffering are avoidable: we have safe and effective medicines and a proven model—the fracture liaison service—which picks up people after that first fracture and makes sure that they are diagnosed and treated. It will pay for itself in two years. Filling in the gaps in coverage would save health and social care services more than £600 million over five years. None of this is in dispute, and I know that the Minister, who has been stalwart in her support of this cause, understands that. It was fantastic that the Government committed to a national rollout of FLS to every part of England before the election, but progress has been achingly slow. We still have no confirmed funding, rollout plan, implementation timetable or clinical leadership. That is where this Bill comes in. In 2024, the Government inherited a position where FLSs served half of NHS trusts. Ministers pledged to roll out these services in every part of the country by 2030. So far, 50-plus additional FLSs are required to fulfil that commitment, but since the election, as we heard from the Minister earlier, only five have been established, all the result of local initiatives by determined doctors. Over that period, the message from Ministers has been consistent—“The rollout will happen, the deadline is 2030, we have time”—that is, until this summer, because now Minister Karin Smyth in the other place has taken to relying on ICB-level coverage figures to make the perhaps dubious claim that the rollout is 92% complete. These figures are irrelevant because the reconfigured ICBs are enormous. Within them, the service footprint has hardly changed: 94% of the services Ministers are counting are the ones they inherited in 2024. At the current rate of progress, fulfilment of the Government’s commitment will take 38 years. Where government fails to fulfil a pledge, it is up to this House to do something about it. I expect an amendment to be tabled to require a clear implementation plan for fracture prevention, along the lines of the one tabled in the other place with support from Government and Opposition MPs. To be clear, its aim will not be to create a new policy, simply to ensure that existing commitments are adhered to. There are a couple of issues in the Bill which relate to people living with HIV. I declare my interest as a trustee of the Terrence Higgins Trust. First, the Bill will legally transfer commissioning of specialised services, including HIV care, to ICBs. There is a danger that as a result HIV care will be deprioritised. Commissioning of HIV care was delegated from NHS England to ICBs from April 2024, and THT and other HIV charities warned that NHS England was giving up a key lever for ending new HIV transmissions. As of June 2025, only 21% of ICBs referenced HIV in their joint forward plan. This makes the development of local HIV action plans and clear reporting against national care standards essential. Will the Minister please set out how the Government will ensure that transferring HIV commissioning to ICBs does not lead to HIV being deprioritised? Secondly, there are concerns around the welcome introduction of the single patient record, which will be particularly important for the two-thirds of people living with HIV who also have comorbidities. There is a danger in how patient confidentiality will be safeguarded. As HIV remains highly stigmatised in some areas, 10% of people living with HIV have not shared their HIV status with their GP. It is vital that confidentiality is central to the development of this record, and that the development of the single record includes consultation directly with people living with HIV. I look forward to the Minister’s response on these points and to engaging constructively on this and other matters in Committee.

More from Lord Black of Brentwood (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.