Contribution
My Lords, I applaud the speech by my noble friend Lady Campbell. I agreed with every word, and I will not repeat any of her aspirations.
The success of the Government’s ambition to improve the delivery of healthcare and to promote more integrated services closer to people’s homes will partly depend on clinical leadership and commissioning. Patients—people —view success according to the relevance, quality and speed of care and support that they receive, not on the statistical findings that are reported. Clinicians need to agree the best possible outcomes with each patient, given their own history and preference. Operationalising care pathways must never lose sight of the individual patient.
The noble Baroness, Lady Tyler, reminded us of the importance of the social determinants of health. Health also requires a joined-up financial partnership with other policy areas, including education, social care, housing and criminal justice, if population health is to improve and evidence-based prevention is to be as effective as it could be.
My own expertise and interest are in people with mental illness, people with learning disabilities and autistic people, whose voices are too often unheard. It is through this lens that I will raise a few concerns.
The Royal College of Psychiatrists has rightly argued that workforce planning must be central to the success of this Bill, but this must include retaining the staff we currently have. We know that among NHS staff there are a lot of stresses and illness across the whole service, so attending to the mental health needs of staff will be important. There is no health without mental health. Going back to the 2012 Act, the one thing that I fought for was parity of esteem for mental health. There is still a huge amount of work to do, and the integration that this Bill seeks to promote must include the integration of psychiatric expertise across the wider health and care system.
The Health Bill seeks to strengthen the duty on the Secretary of State to reduce inequalities. People with learning disabilities arguably face the greatest inequalities of all. The latest LeDeR report tells us that adults with a learning disability still die, on average, 19 years younger than the general population. Some 39% of deaths reviewed were avoidable, with failures to provide adequate care not being “isolated errors” but described as “systemic” failures. Concerningly, the future of the LeDeR programme is in doubt, despite it being described as imperative that we commit to continue to identify and reduce these health inequalities.
I recently met people with learning disabilities, family carers, academics, charities and professionals to precisely discuss this problem. There was considerable agreement that we need a new national learning disability strategy, co-produced with people with learning disabilities and their families, bringing together what we already know works and identifying where further evidence and work are needed. Short-term crisis management and a rationing approach to community support are contributing significantly to poorer health outcomes for people and greater cost to the public purse over time. This has been so well documented in many reviews over decades. Will His Majesty’s Government consider developing such a strategy, with measurable objectives for reducing these extraordinary inequalities in both health and social care?
We could create a health and social care system that works for everyone. To make this a reality, people with learning disabilities and their families cannot be an afterthought but must be at the forefront of co-producing the new national care service, which really ought to be part of this Bill.
I welcome the single patient record, provided that it is a summary that is not overinclusive of confidential personal information. For people with learning or other communication disabilities, having key information that is relevant, up to date, and available across all areas of health and care could help to integrate care, avoid duplication of effort and error, and highlight areas of unmet need. As ICBs take on new commissioning functions, we need to be confident that there is effective national oversight and consistency and that, where there are smaller patient groups with quieter voices, they are not just forgotten about. Healthwatch is a vital service to enable people to have a voice.