Contribution
It is a pleasure to follow the noble Baroness, Lady Hollins, with her excellent expertise.
I want to focus not on the main issues of the Bill—a really useful Bill, with huge value—but on other issues which are not fully mentioned in the Bill, one of which is whether the whole financing of the NHS is appropriate. We do not have enough transparency around that. Ever since we have had the internal market, there has been a big problem with competition, which raises issues around not understanding what procedures actually cost—how much they cost us as taxpayers and how much they cost in different areas of the country. When you have localisation, as we intend, that makes it rather more difficult.
The other issue is that of compassion, which the Bill does not describe. It is a great Bill in what it actually says, but the way it is expressed is difficult to read and it does not help us very much in thinking about what we are actually doing with patients in hospital or in general practice.
I have a colleague—a cleaner—who I do not know well, who went into hospital, vomiting, some months ago. She had blood in her vomit and pain in her abdomen. It was a very short history. She lay in hospital for two or three days and she was never examined physically, which is not untypical. A physical examination is, in my view, the essential way of getting to understand the patient, and we are not providing that. At the moment, people are not being examined at any stage in their initial treatment, and what follows is an inadequate history of the patient’s illness. Finally, on the fourth day, I spoke to her on the phone and she told me that a doctor had walked past her, looked at her notes and said, “Oh, you’ve got stomach cancer”, and then walked on. That was her first idea that she might have something seriously wrong. That is really happening, and I have seen it again and again. We are not communicating.
A lot later, I complained to the chief executive of the hospital. It was difficult to find him and difficult to find his phone number. I had to use a rather nasty way of doing it, by phoning the press department of the hospital to say that I was writing a letter to one of the newspapers and that before I sent it I wondered whether the chief executive perhaps wanted to see it. I still did not get a response, but, the following day, I went to visit my friend in hospital, and my telephone rang. It was the chief executive, who said, “Is that Robert Winston?” I said yes. I did not say where I had come from. He said, “Where are you? Can I speak to you sometime?” I said that of course he could and that I was actually in his hospital at the moment. He asked me where, and I told him I was in the huge ward upstairs. He came straight up. This chief executive did something quite remarkable. He got down on his knees, in his trousers, on the floor—the patient was lying in bed—put his face right up against hers and said the right things to her.
We have the ability, but we are not doing it nearly enough. It should not take a chief executive—it should be a doctor or a nurse. But all the doctors in that hospital, when I saw them when I was there as a patient, are operating computers outside of the wards most of the time, and are not actually with the patients. In fact, the last time I was in hospital with my leg, for 11 days, I never knew who in fact was running the ward. I never saw what we would now call the chief nurse—I did not know who that was. Most of the nurses I saw were not very well qualified at all. Indeed, one of the nurses who was dressing my leg at one point—who had plenty of time to talk because it was late at night—said that he had 10 nurses he was trying to train, who were all very good young women, but, of the 10, if he was lucky, only three might stay in Britain because they were so disenchanted.
We cannot have that happening in our health service. We have to understand that so much part of that service is not this dry language we need to use in the Bill, but in fact the warmth we have in actual communication and listening to patients. We have to have people who are listening and facing a patient, not facing a computer. We talk about personalised medicine— I have said this before—but the medicine we are practising now is impersonal unless we actually make certain that we are touching the patient and listening to the patient.