Contribution
My Lords, this Bill is wide-ranging and touches all parts of the structures of our NHS, but I am going to use this Second Reading to focus specifically on its impact on people with autism and ADHD. Last Friday, the Government published their own independent review of ADHD and autism services. They found more than 500,000 open referrals for ADHD and more than 250,000 people waiting for an autism assessment. I thank the Minister for her introduction, and I add my congratulations to the noble Lord, Lord Jabbar, on his maiden speech. I am very much looking forward to the four maiden speeches still to come.
This Bill does not mention autism or ADHD, but it changes who runs three things those patients rely on: the national programmes, the data and the patient voice. I want to ask the Minister about each of these, so that these patients are not lost in the move. I turn first to the programmes. Professor Fonagy’s review and the ADHD taskforce before it point the same way. Both want more of the routine, ongoing care for adults with ADHD to be provided by GPs rather than specialist clinics. The taskforce had no power to act on its own findings. That job fell to NHS England, which this Bill, of course, abolishes.
I asked ADHD UK what this means for the people it represents. Its chief executive, Henry Shelford, told me it was hard-fought to find anyone in NHS England with responsibility for ADHD at all. His fear is that ADHD will now be lost again. He also asked me a very simple question: when do the reports end and the action begin? The Government have said they will respond to the review in a mental health strategy in the coming months, and I welcome that, but could the Minister tell the House who in the department will lead this work once NHS England has gone? When can people waiting today expect to see a difference? The same question applies to autism. NHS England runs the national programme for autistic people and people with a learning disability. Can the Minister tell us where it will sit next year, and who will run it?
The second issue is data, and two kinds matter here. The first tells us how many people are waiting: NHS England publishes those figures regularly. The second tells us how many people are autistic or have ADHD in the first place. Here, the review found very little. There is no recent England-wide study of autism in children, and the best ADHD figure dates from 2017. My own Written Questions have confirmed that the Government do not centrally assess whether there are enough assessment services, so the waiting figures are the best evidence we have.
This Bill moves the teams who produce those figures into the department. ADHD UK warns that, if that work is split up, the national ADHD data dashboard will lose the figures it depends on. Can the Minister reassure us that they will still be published on the same schedule, and in a form we can compare with today’s? Will the Government commission the regular surveys the review recommends?
The third consideration is the patient voice. Locally, Healthwatch is often where a parent turns when the school, the GP and the hospital each say it is someone else’s job. My Liberal Democrat colleague Helen Morgan pressed hard on this in the Commons, and I welcome the Minister’s commitment to review the plans for local Healthwatch. Her letter to Peers says that the new patient experience directorate will focus on seldom-heard groups. Many autistic people and people with ADHD will never fill in an online survey or sit through a public meeting, so how does the department intend to reach them?
As many noble Lords have said, there is one part of the Bill I warmly welcome: the single patient record. An adult is diagnosed with ADHD by a specialist; the GP is asked to take over prescribing, and the GP declines due to lack of funding. The specialist has already discharged them, and the patient runs out of medication. A shared record could help to prevent that. It could also help at age 18, when too many young people have to start again with adult services.
I understand the Government’s aim of a simpler NHS. I hope the Minister can reassure the House that simpler will not mean that these patients become easier to overlook. There are more than 500,000 open referrals for ADHD and more than 250,000 people are waiting for an autism assessment. Each of them deserves to know who will answer for their care once NHS England is gone.