B

Baroness Coffey (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 13 October 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I congratulate those making their maiden speeches today. I must admit that I am particularly looking forward to hearing the noble Lord, Lord Wormald, who was my Permanent Secretary, albeit for a short time. He is a brilliant civil servant and I am sure we will learn a lot from him. I also look forward to hearing from my noble friend Lord Singh of Solihull, who, with his expertise in psychiatry, I am sure will add to many of the comments that have already been made. Real culture difficulties cannot be addressed by legislation, only by standards and leadership. However, the Bill puts back in the control of the Government, the Minister and the Secretary of State when things go fundamentally wrong in the NHS. Because of the direct level of accountability that an elected Government have, and when we consider that 40% of day-to-day spending is spent on the NHS, it is absolutely right that elected politicians and the Government have the levers to pull. One of the things I point out to the House is that, for example, I remember challenging the NHS chief executive about the culture of basically almost saying “The NHS can do no wrong” or, “We’ll make sure it gets better”, and saying it really would make a difference if they were to remove the foundation trust licences of some of the worst-performing hospitals in the country. But they would not do it, because that is not the NHS culture. So I hope the Bill gets strengthened, but I hope it does not get watered down, and I say that in a number of ways. I would like it to go further in the link between decision-makers and accountable representation. I welcome the amendment that was made to reinstate local government on to ICB boards in the House of Commons. But, on what I have heard about the patient voice, I am really sorry to say that Healthwatch has never really delivered properly the patient voice, either locally or nationally, and nor has the investigation board. Look at the outcomes it has produced: not very much. Meanwhile, there are MPs, local councillors and people involved in patient participation groups, and there is the formal structure of PALS within hospitals that tries to get things fixed. However, too often patients are scared to make a complaint, particularly when they are in hospital, in case all of a sudden, because of their concern about culture, their treatment will get worse, not better. It takes some bravery to stand up against it, but you can be braver once you are out of the hospital doors and back home. This is the element that builds on what the noble Lord, Lord Winston, talked about: how patients get treated has to be key to this. Albeit I was a Secretary of State for a short time, but one of the things I am proud of is that we put together the starting point with the plan for patients. The Prime Minister today, who was a Health Secretary in the past, used to mainly talk about staff and systems and very rarely used the word “patients”. I know that the Minister that we have today will certainly not go down that track, and I very much encourage her not to. As regards thinking about where potentially there could be some improvements to the Bill, we have an environment plan, which is long term, so I wonder whether we could have a health improvement plan that statutorily needs to be updated every so many years. Personally, I think we should look more at the role of health visitors and think how that can be delivered locally in terms of the local NHS, not just for children but for pensioners. Could we do something here in the Bill about palliative care and about transparency? My noble friends on the Front Bench have already said how, if we are taking away certain things, we need to increase the amount of transparency. I fully agree with that. That applies not only potentially to ministerial directions but more broadly. Wes Streeting mocked me when I had set a target of somebody being able to meet their GP within two weeks. It is still government policy today, by the way. That was designed to open up how patients were able to access their GPs and what was happening in their surgeries. It was on the grounds that not everybody needs to be treated within 48 or 24 hours; it was about people who have discovered a bit of a lump and are feeling uncomfortable and then just keep putting it off because it is not urgent. That is how we miss cancer and other health conditions, and that is why making sure that we have patients at the heart of what we do will be critical to the outcome of making sure that the Bill is a success. The SPR will help it, but I hope the patient owns it—not the doctors or the NHS. It is the patient’s property.

More from Baroness Coffey (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.