L

Lord Kakkar (CB)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 13 October 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

My Lords, it is a pleasure to follow the noble Baroness, Lady Coffey. In so doing, I add my own thanks and congratulations to the Minister on the very thoughtful way in which she introduced the Bill and laid out the arguments for bringing it to your Lordships’ House. I also declare my interests as the chairman of the King’s Fund and King’s Health Partners. We need to look at the arrival of this particular Health Bill in your Lordships’ House in the broader fiscal context. Over the past 60 or so years, we have seen an increase in expenditure on healthcare from 2.8% of national income in the mid-1950s to 7.3% by 2020. At the same time, expenditure on defence has fallen from 7.8% of national income to 1.9%. So there has been a substantial shift in the priorities of the state over that period of time, which has allowed substantial additional investment in the provision of healthcare and the development of the NHS. Indeed, if one looks over the 40-year period prior to Covid, in only two of those 40 years was the budget that had been agreed for expenditure in the NHS in the previous year actually delivered; more often than not, it was overspent by, on average, some 1.3%. The question that we have to ask ourselves, in considering the provisions laid out in the Bill, is: are we now moving into a fiscal situation where it may be impossible for future Governments to provide, year on year, increased expenditure to support the delivery of healthcare in our country? The Bill therefore represents a substantial opportunity to address questions on whether the structures are indeed correct and whether those structures will provide us with the opportunity to address not only clinical, organisational and workforce challenges but fiscal challenges, where it will not necessarily be possible to provide as much as has been provided by repeated Administrations over many decades. In that context, one has to try to understand the lens through which any of the provisions of the Bill—and, indeed, scrutiny by your Lordships—should be conducted. Of course, we have heard that, ultimately, the purpose of the health service is to ensure that the best clinical outcomes are delivered for every patient compassionately and sensitively; to secure the safety of all those engaging in health services; and to ensure that the service is delivered with maximum efficiency, ensuring that the valuable taxpayer contribution is delivered for the greatest benefit. In addition, it is vital that any measures your Lordships decide to adopt are also able to ensure the adoption of innovation at scale and pace because, ultimately, that is the only way in which the substantial amounts of public expenditure committed to the delivery of the NHS might be distributed more broadly to ensure that we can start to address a prevention agenda; large amounts of additional expenditure will probably not be necessary. We have heard, rightly, that many areas of the Bill should be scrutinised. I completely agree that there needs to be clarity of understanding around the distribution of responsibility, powers and accountability between those being drawn back into the Department of Health, to be exercised by the Secretary of State, and how that sits with a broader devolution agenda, ensuring that integrated care boards have the capacity to deliver what needs to be done at a local level; this should fundamentally determine how the health service is delivered. It is critical that we ensure that legislative measures are able to secure the social licence and public confidence that will allow for the delivery of the single patient record, which will ultimately be transformational in how care can be delivered safely, effectively and in a cost-effective fashion. The patient voice is critical. If we go to other jurisdictions around the world that have put a lot of effort into gathering the experiences and views of patients in real time, we see substantial improvements in clinical outcomes and safety in those institutions. These are vital matters, all of which are to be considered in the broader context of the challenges now facing our country if we are going to provide what we must: adequate scrutiny and the delivery of vital reforms to the delivery of healthcare.

More from Lord Kakkar (CB)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.