B

Baroness Thornton (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 13 October 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

My Lords, it gives me enormous pleasure to follow my noble friend Lady Lowe, a fellow Yorkshirewoman. It is true that I am from Bradford and she is from Leeds, and there are historic issues there. None the less, Alison brings wonderful experience and knowledge to this House, as she has amply illustrated in her maiden speech. The themes which run through her life are public service in Leeds, race equality and mental health. She mentioned being CEO of Touchstone and serving her time on Leeds City Council. What she did not say was that she was the first black woman elected to Leeds City Council. She was also my youngest sister’s councillor for all that time. My sister testifies that she was very effective indeed. She stopped being a councillor in 2019 and went on to be an alderman in the city. She then became our deputy mayor in West Yorkshire, a position that she still holds today. I want to welcome this Yorkshirewoman to our Chamber. I know that she has a great contribution to make to our work. I thank my noble friend the Minister for her excellent introduction to this Bill and for the many meetings that she has had. There have also been many maiden speeches of such excellence and quality so far. We are blessed. In this short time, I want to raise three points and questions. Like many other noble Lords today, I feel a veteran of NHS reorganisations during the 28 years I have been here. It feels slightly like “Back to the Future Part II” with this Bill. That is a great film, so it is not a criticism and is no bad thing. My noble friend the Minister and I were Ministers when the NHS was run from the department, and it will be again. I thank many organisations and the Library for the briefings that we have received. Many make it clear that there is work to be done. I am still the relatively new chair of the Social Care Institute for Excellence. The noble Baroness, Lady Campbell, was its first chair when the institute was created by my Government in 2001. How inspired I am by the speech that she made today and the method by which she made it. My first question concerns social care. With both the Prime Minister and the noble Baroness, Lady Casey, focusing on its future, it is now way up the public agenda and a focus for both lived experience and inequality, which need to be tackled. Will this Bill help that process in the local systems that it is proposing? Not having local authorities on ICBs in the first draft did not augur well for me. How will integrated preventive neighbourhood health be delivered if there is not true co-operation on an equal basis between the NHS, social care, local councils and communities in commissioning local services? One representative on an ICB is not enough. In my ICB, that will be one representative representing nine councils. Linked to this is the question of the single patient record. How will that interface with social care records and data so that patients accessing social care do not have to repeat over and again the same information? There is also the question of confidentiality. My noble friend Lord Hunt will be exploring this and I will join him in that debate. The third point concerns the patient voice, which many noble Lords have mentioned. I am a veteran of community health councils—I served in Bloomsbury about 40 years ago and was in your Lordships’ House—possibly as the Minister—when we abolished community health councils and introduced Healthwatch. I think my noble friend and the Bill team will by now have realised that the abolition of Healthwatch is not welcome. The NHS marking its own homework is not a good idea and may be very risky, as we know. Just being permissive in the Bill about the patient voice at a local level is not sufficient. This needs to be nationally funded, with national powers to deliver proper patient voice at a local level. I welcome this Bill. I see the importance of streamlining the NHS as it has done. The noble Earl, Lord Howe, and I swapped places several times over 15 years as Minister and shadow Minister. I agree with my noble friend Lord Hunt that he is the person who delivered that Bill, the Lansley Bill, through his expertise in handling it in your Lordships’ House. However, that did not make it a right Bill. It has probably cost the NHS billions in bureaucracy that was unnecessary. I welcome this Bill on the basis that accountability will be put back where it should be—in the department—and that that will lead to a much more effective NHS.

More from Baroness Thornton (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.