B

Baroness Neville-Rolfe (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 13 October 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

My Lords, as a Peer who normally speaks on the economy, I am conscious that health is the largest recipient of public spending, with £203 billion spent in England alone in the current year. This is significant, not only in terms of personal welfare but economically. A healthier population, not stuck at home on waiting lists or with chronic conditions, would aid growth. Health is a subject dominated by experts, but many of us have experience of the strength and weaknesses of very large organisations. Standing back, it is clear to me that the NHS is much too big and complex, with too much bureaucracy and too many managers overlapping with one another. Accordingly, I support the abolition of NHS England. I have become increasingly sceptical of the value of such stand-alone government bodies unless they are small and expert. They lack day-to-day contact with Ministers. They have become self-promoting with PR, HR and higher pay than Civil Service equivalents. It is a recipe for expenditure growth and poor value for money. And it may not be good for consumers—patients in this case—who need to be looked after, as we have heard from the noble Lord, Lord Winston, and my noble friend Lady Coffey. Historically, hospitals and specialist care were run by doctors—very clever people who really understand their work. Now they are run by managers, who are often paid more, and there are several layers, with bureaucracy making work for each other and for the medical staff. Can the Minister say how many management layers there are in the DHSC directorate overseeing the NHS and how many within the NHS itself? Is there a plan for cutting out layers and generating savings from the reduction in duplication that the Bill promises? What are the salient numbers? These are questions in addition to the good questions asked by my noble friend Lord Howe about the costs and the benefits. I experienced the limitations of the present arrangements when I was a Minister in the Cabinet Office trying to speed up hospital-building. The truth is that the differences and arguments between the health department and the NHS were a major cause of delay. When modern hospitals are built, such as Chase Farm Hospital in Enfield, they are transformational for patients and staff. How long have the last five new NHS hospitals taken to complete? How much of that time is taken in the approval process as opposed to actual construction? By how much will the reforms in the Bill reduce the delays? The best way to improve healthcare would probably be to restore the effectiveness of the GP service, which is taking a reducing share of resources. A weakness of the present service is the lack of continuity of care, an issue that I will return to in Committee. It is very difficult to see or talk to the same doctor regularly. GPs constantly need to familiarise themselves with the basic facts. What a waste. I support the single patient record, the NHS app and interconnectivity across the NHS. If, for example, you attend A&E, a great deal of time and cost could be saved on tests and analysis. However, there is a huge gap which I would ask the Minister to investigate: the recording of care provided by the private sector. Many people are lucky enough to have employee schemes, and yet the test results hardly ever seem to get on to the NHS record. I believe in the value of outsourcing appropriate services. Advances have been made, for example, in audiology and optometry. However, there is a worrying shift in culture under this Government. I have an example in eye health clinics, which I ask the Minister to investigate. I am told that they have to operate to an indicative activity plan; that they cannot exceed a monthly quota of operations; and that they are obliged to operate a minimum waiting time decided by reference to the NHS offering; and that if the NHS providers slow down, they have to slow down too, even if they have spare capacity. If half of this is true, it represents a poor state of affairs. Whether the objectives of today’s legislation are achieved, including the clarity of authority and accountability sought by the noble Earl, Lord Howe, depend on the implementation of all that is replacing them. We need to know a lot more.

More from Baroness Neville-Rolfe (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.