L

Lord Patel of Bradford (Non-Afl)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 13 October 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

My Lords, first, let me congratulate all the Peers making their maiden speeches. Nobody will be surprised that I am particularly pleased that another person from Yorkshire is part of this House now. There is much to welcome in this Bill. For example, a single patient record could improve continuity, consistency and safety, particularly for people with complex needs. However, sensitive information, including mental health records, needs robust protection. Patients must understand how their information is used, and those unable to access digital services must not be excluded. In the time available, I will touch briefly on five areas where I will seek further debate and scrutiny and will pursue or support amendments. First, on patient voice, I believe that abolishing Healthwatch and removing the statutory foundation trust governance model risks weakening independent challenge, particularly for people whose voices are least heard. As a former chair of a teaching hospital foundation trust, I know the value of governors as a bridge between communities and hospital leadership. Among their many valuable roles, they appoint the chair and the non-executive directors, approve the chief executive’s appointment and hold non-executive directors to account for the board’s performance. These are substantial powers of public accountability, which should not be lost without an effective replacement. We know Healthwatch’s effectiveness varies across the country, partly, I would argue, because of unequal funding. The answer should be to strengthen its resources, independence and influence. If Ministers nevertheless proceed with abolition, which I hope they do not, a credible replacement must be ready before long-established and trusted local relationships are dismantled and lost for ever. Secondly, in respect of independent patient safety investigation, Clause 65 would abolish HSSIB and transfer its functions to CQC. In July 2024, the then Secretary of State, Wes Streeting, described CQC as “not fit for purpose”. Of course, its new leadership deserves support and time to put its house in order, but rebuilding CQC will take considerable time and resources—hardly an ideal context for a complex merger. I know that Ministers have stated that transfer will happen only when CQC is ready, but what timetable do they envisage? How will staffing expertise from ongoing investigations be protected meanwhile? It is crucial, therefore, that Parliament requires published tests of readiness and assurances of continuity. The Bill thankfully retains safe space protections, but how will investigations remain operationally independent of regulation and enforcement? I will pursue or support safeguards that give staff and families confidence to speak candidly. Thirdly, on mental health, the Minister, having steered the Mental Health Bill through the House last year, knows very well how far we still have to go to achieve parity of esteem. This Bill must protect mental health’s priority and funding. The Commons Health and Social Care Committee recommended making compliance with the mental health investment standard a statutory requirement. That deserves serious consideration. Fourthly, in respect of ministerial powers, Clause 10 permits variation in the balance of provider types where the Secretary of State considers it in the interests of the health service. Clause 11 adds a broad power to direct integrated care boards. These powers need clear limits and transparent justification. Patients should not wait longer because suitable capacity to treat NHS patients, including in the independent sector, is disregarded solely because of who provides it. Finally, I argue that efforts to reduce health inequalities must address geography. Nearly one in five people in England—that is 20%—live in coastal communities. Professor Chris Whitty’s report in 2021, Health in Coastal Communities, highlighted their heavy burden of physical and mental ill-health. In some coastal communities, male life expectancy is as much as 10 years below that in inland areas, and suicide rates are more than 50% above the England average. These inequalities remain stark and unacceptable. How will the Minister ensure that commissioning, prevention and workforce plans address coastal disadvantage? Poorer health outcomes in coastal communities will continue to hold back national progress. Even where national averages improve, they can mask persistent inequalities in communities that are left behind. I want this Bill to succeed. Ministers must therefore report transparently on reorganisation costs and benefits so that Parliament can judge whether these changes deliver better care. Success must mean better care, a stronger patient voice and healthier lives.

More from Lord Patel of Bradford (Non-Afl)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.