B

Baroness Pitkeathley (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 13 October 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

My Lords, it is a privilege to speak in this debate and especially to be present for so many maiden speakers. In almost 30 years in your Lordships’ House, I have lost track of the number of health Bills in which I have participated. However, I can be sure of one thing. In each health Bill, I would have begun my Second Reading speech with a plea, indeed a rant, to Ministers that it was of no use bringing about any reforms in healthcare without including social care, since the two are inextricably entwined. They are entwined not only in how they are delivered but in the minds of patients and families, who understandably have no ability to distinguish between a medical bath and a social bath. There are a few of us in your Lordships’ House who have been saying this for a very long time; indeed, I have often referred to them as the usual suspects. Imagine, then, how I and others feel as we contemplate this Health Bill. The atmosphere has changed completely, even since the Bill was introduced into the other place. Social care is at the top of the agenda now, where it should be, and where we have been hoping it would be, some of us for more years than we care to admit. The Bill provides the legal basis for the largest NHS reorganisation in a decade, but let us never forget that structural reform rarely of itself improves care for patients and their families. It is the practical changes which follow that deliver better care. I welcome the Bill’s ambition to modernise the way health information is shared, particularly the development of a single patient record. This could be genuinely transformative for unpaid carers. At present, carers can spend an enormous amount of time repeating information, navigating different parts of the NHS and trying to make sure that professionals understand the circumstances of the person they care for. A more joined-up record could reduce that burden and, with the appropriate permissions and safeguards, make it much easier for carers to be properly involved in managing someone’s care. There have been debates about this in the other place, and I am hopeful that carers may be included in the regulations as people who can have access to the single patient record with the right safeguards. I would be grateful if the Minister could confirm that carers will be explicitly recognised in those regulations. However, information sharing is only part of the picture. We also need to make sure that the NHS actually recognises who its carers are and understands what they need. There is strong evidence of underidentification, particularly in primary care, and carers do not feel consulted or asked about whether they are able or willing to provide care at hospital discharge in spite of legislation to the contrary. Identification is important because carers need information and advice to carry out their role. They may be administering medication, using healthcare equipment or helping someone to move safely, yet there is not always a clear point of contact within the NHS for making sure that they receive the information they need. A Labour Government introduced the first systematic identification of unpaid carers through the GP contract, which sadly has been stopped by later Governments. There is potential in the Bill to do more to ensure that carers are better identified by the NHS and consistently supported. We need to ask whether the system is delivering what carers actually need. I hope the Government will continue to work with carers and their organisations to ensure that they are supported to sustain their vital role. The more we focus on social care, the more we must ensure that the relationship between health services and local authorities is strong and productive. If we are to make the shift to community-based services from hospital services a reality, we have to ensure that the two services are equally valued and equally understood. The influence of local government at ICB level is crucial for supporting people at home, preventing crises before they arrive, and improving the well-being of communities. Thankfully, the original proposal to remove the statutory local authority seat has been revisited, but we still have to consider whether at least one board member from local authorities is adequate. When it comes to the patient voice—for me that includes the voice of carers and families—the issue is not so much the structures but the outcomes. At a time of significant change for both health and social care, we must ensure that the patient voice is at its strongest. I am glad that carers are also to be recognised by local bodies. What seems to be missing is an independent national voice. I hope the Minister will confirm that we all have responsibility to ensure that the patient voice is strengthened and not weakened by whatever provisions finally emerge.

More from Baroness Pitkeathley (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.