Contribution
Recently, at a meeting about this Bill, the noble Baroness, Lady Gerada, remarked to me that she had been through at least 15 major reorganisations of the National Health Service. Well, I can beat her. I have endured at least 22. I joined the NHS in 1966 as an auxiliary nurse—what healthcare assistants were called then—for three months before going up to medical school in Manchester. I worked on the John Player Ward at Nottingham General Hospital. We were very near the Player factory, and one of my jobs was polishing the brass ashtrays. I kid your Lordships not. Perhaps some things do change. I take heart from that.
The Minister will understand if there is a somewhat jaundiced view among old hands at this game. We fear very little will change substantially for patients’ experience of the NHS or the outcomes of care. On almost every measure, the NHS now compares very badly with other OECD countries, including most of Europe. The weaknesses of the delivery structures of health and social care are evident. Of course, modest improvements happen when another bung of money is provided, and hard-pressed and talented staff are grateful for that. But the NHS is slow to adopt innovations, unable to drive increased productivity, cut waste, use data effectively or reduce variations in care or outcomes related to inequality and deprivation. Everyone is so absorbed in struggling with day-to-day troubles, the future can go hang.
It would have been nice to have a Health Bill that recognised that some aspects of the current system seriously neglect some groups. Perhaps the largest of all the neglected groups is those with dementia. There is no ambition here to make the NHS social care services work for them, or indeed the other groups that have been mentioned by many people around this House—although, of course, we are grateful for the recent investment of research monies.
We need radical service transformations—a change that involves a more sophisticated model of primary care, properly resourced, providing continuity of care, as mentioned by the noble Baroness, Lady Neville-Rolfe, and one that is able to deliver on diagnostics. So much more is carried out by GPs and their associated staff in the community in other countries, in Europe and in Canada and Australia. I will not get started tonight on mental health services, as I fear I will not be able to stop.
So we are chucking out NHS England. I supported its creation. I thought the Department of Health was consumed by NHS acute hospitals to the exclusion of everything else, and the idea was to create a body that would focus on the NHS machinery and nothing else, removing the NHS from political interference and leaving the department to pursue all its other responsibilities, including public health and social care. But it did not work, partly because the Bill of the noble Lord, Lord Lansley, was not implemented, as he said himself. It was only half implemented. So now we have a Government who want to bring all these key arm’s-length bodies back in-house. It will be the same stuff as usual—just different titles. Absolutely nothing will change, except there will be a resumption of ministerial meddling. As always, there will be a hope of saving money—but fat chance, I fear.
I turn to other provisions of the Bill. On ditching governors of trusts—well, I hold no particular torch for governors; we wait to see whether the alternatives work. The department will appoint chairs of trusts now, guaranteeing further political meddling there too. As for abolishing Healthwatch, some are doing great work, as we have heard; others are not. I would like to know how the Minister thinks local patients’ voices are going to be heard in reality. It is very vague indeed.
The one positive about the Bill that we have all mentioned is the single patient record, if we can get it to work without spending billions—if we do, that will be a real miracle. Watching the presentations, I was thinking back to visiting acutely mentally disturbed people creating mayhem in the community in south-east London, and wondering whether I would have access to a user-friendly single patient record on my phone. Well, I hope so. I am an optimistic soul.
Sixty years on from my first job in the NHS, it is time to hold on to the principles and find a better way of delivering them. It is not cheap any more. People are voting with their feet, if they have the money. Of course, that does not help the vast majority of people who we need to provide for. We are all being failed by the unwillingness of successive Governments to grasp the challenge to create a better system, which so many other countries now have done.