B

Baroness Murphy (CB)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 22 October 2026

Debate

AI, Screen Usage and Social Media: Effect on Children

Contribution

My Lords, the noble Lord, Lord Patel, always likes to give us a challenge when he sets a debate, and this is certainly one of the greatest challenges we have had, in terms of its widespread topic. I will just pick out a few things; so much has been said and it has been a very interesting debate. The rapid rise of generative AI systems, particularly conversational chatbots such as ChatGPT, has of course sparked new concerns regarding their psychological impact on all users, but especially children. I stress that, while there are legitimate concerns, about which we have a heard a great deal, the real problem in my view is that children are missing out in their lives when they are stuck in front of a highly addictive screen: friendships, social activities, physical activity and family time. Although of course I appreciate there is an amazing ability for children to reach out to relatives in other countries, to talk to friends on screen and so on, but what they get from generative AI systems can be very harmful. When you introduce a young child to reading books, you do not just plonk a book in a child’s hand say, “Here you are, read that”. You read with them, getting them to know gradually what the words mean, how they connect and how to grasp a story. The parent supervises the child before letting them loose on any old book. The same surely should be true of AI and the internet in general. As many people have said, parents need to be educated about it themselves if they are to help their children. Teachers above all need to know about this stuff in the classroom, and perhaps we are very far behind several other countries in getting to grips with that. So my question to the Minister is: what is the Government doing to ensure that the Department for Education is preparing its teachers, and teachers are preparing parents, for activity in this area? While these AI tools offer unprecedented access to educational information and opportunities to learn, learning is not a solitary activity. Being part of a class with a good teacher is worth a hundred hours of unguided self-learning. Interestingly, the Minister of Education in China mandates AI literacy and tech courses starting in elementary school. Middle and high school students tackle machine learning, ethics and model design. They regulate AI exposure quite fiercely and perhaps it is time that we thought about that as well. In the UK, the Scottish Government published their own—I have to say, rather vague—policy in March, but left everything open to local flexibility. In England and Wales, although AI usage has skyrocketed, we have not produced a similar policy on how to develop this stuff. In fact, UK students boast some of the highest generative AI adoption rates globally, using it for nearly half of their academic work. Teachers are permitted and encouraged to use it, but where is the guidance and regulation? Where is the education for teachers? It is the companionship from AI chatbots that poses a real problem: the anthropomorphic nature of them. There is a growing body of evidence that these objects may induce or exacerbate psychiatric symptoms in vulnerable children and adolescents. False social attachments can lead to some serious harms indeed, and we have already heard from the noble Lord, Lord Alton, about the tragic case of Sewell Setzer in the States, who died by suicide following months of intensive interaction with AI chatbots. I have come to the end of what I can say about this. We need to understand the mental health implications, but we also need parental and teacher education to get this stuff in the curriculum, too.

More from Baroness Murphy (CB)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.