Contribution
My Lords, I approach this topic from the point of view of someone who worked for two years, when I was a trainee psychiatrist, in a transsexual clinic for adults at University College Hospital. In those days—I am going back 45 years—men and women came to seek help usually as confirmed transsexuals. In those days it was mostly men wishing to be women; there is a slight reverse nowadays in the desire to change. They had received no help of any kind from childhood. Very muscular men with large Adam’s apples and deep voices struggled to manage in society, or went abroad to seek surgical help to transform themselves into a better facsimile of a woman—with unpredictable consequences and sometimes horrendous outcomes.
Like many people, and I suspect I was in those days in the same school of approach as the noble Lord, Lord Frost, to these problems—I was very young—I thought to myself, “Well, these people are deluded. Why on earth are we colluding with this stuff?”, but I gradually came to the conclusion that my task as a psychiatrist was to try to help all individuals feel more at ease in their own skin and live the life that helped them to feel more content and at one with society, and for lifelong transsexuals that help must be given before puberty. As we have heard from my noble friend Lady Cass, those who are chosen for these trials and treatment have usually been feeling this way since they were aged three or four, when they thought back to when their gender identity was formed.
How and when should medical intervention be proffered, therefore, if it is to be given before puberty? If you do not, the outcome can be quite horrendous, in terms of lifetime achievements for these people. The review by my noble friend Lady Cass of the special problems posed by gender dysphoria, and it is now two years since it was published, has been enormously helpful and influential in ensuring that unregulated prescriptions ceased and that prescription puberty blockers and other medications only take part within a carefully regulated research framework, with the aim of establishing better guidance. I remind noble Lord that we do trials for drugs on children in very many walks of life, often in quite serious life-threatening disorders and others, when we feel it will be helpful. We do it with the children’s assent when it has been explained, but with parental consent as well, and it is under those terms the proposals for research are handled at the moment. I pay tribute to the determination of the noble friend Lady Cass to stick to her guns in the face of much upset in the transactivist world on one hand, and on the other those who do not wish to see any interventions before an adolescent can fully understand and make their own decisions. My view is that she got the balance right. These children need a holistic approach to treatment, as we have already pressed, and strong up-to-date medical evidence. However, they often have lots of other problems that need to be looked at. If you do look at those problems in detail, you will end up with a very small group of people who need this kind of intervention.
We know that the children and their parents will get drugs from unregulated sources if we do not make progress in establishing appropriate routes, so I support the PATHWAYS research programme because it has such a broad look at all aspects of the impact of these drugs. It also checks on bone density, brain function, fertility and the longer-term outcomes. We know that very many of these people will eventually turn out to be homosexual as men and women. Very few will remain transsexual all their lives, but it is those on whom we need to concentrate.
Many of these children have struggled for a long time to come up to speed with their problems, but they cannot do it without more help. To leave them without any sort of support for their gender dysphoria, when you know that they are confirmed transsexuals, does suggest that you are turning them away and saying, “No, you are deluded. We won’t help”. I do not think we can do that as a caring society. We need to recognise and support them in what they wish to do.