L

Lord Frost (Non-Afl)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 22 October 2026

Debate

Puberty Blockers and Cross-sex Hormones

Contribution

My Lords, it is a pleasure to follow the noble Baroness, Lady Cass, on any subject, but particularly this one. I am grateful to the noble Baroness, Lady Deech, for securing this very important debate. I have not spoken much about this subject in public, but I have followed it closely; I feel strongly about it. I wanted to speak today because I simply fail to understand the logic behind what is going on and what we are allowing to proceed. I support what the Government have done so far on this general issue—the bans and the indefinite pauses on puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones. The Government deserve credit for this, particularly given the strongly held opposition from a narrow group of their own supporters on this subject. However, what I cannot quite follow—I have learned that many other people cannot follow it either—is what is happening now. The Government have judged these drugs too uncertain to give children in the ordinary way of things, but are now prepared to support giving them to 11 and 12 year-olds as an experiment. We know that the MRHA, as a regulator, had misgivings about this and suggested a minimum age of 14—still too low, in my view—but somehow, it has been persuaded to change its mind and think that 11 or 12 is okay. It is not clear entirely why; perhaps the Minister could shed some light on that. One must ask why this trial is necessary at all. As far as I can see, the only reason one might want to do it is to learn whether we might one day be able to administer such medicines to children who feel gender dysphoria; of course, we already use them in other extremely limited circumstances. If we do not ever wish to do that, why would we want the trial? I recognise that others may not share my view, but personally, because of my own convictions about the nature of reality and sexual difference, I cannot imagine circumstances in which we would ever want to do this. The view that we might rests on the much-disputed premise that a child can have a gender at odds with his or her sex, and that if so, it is the body rather than the beliefs should change. I am afraid I simply do not accept that. I know others will, but I do not. By the way, in passing, I worry that if the Government’s conversion practices Bill ever made it into law, what I have just said would become quite a risky thing to say in quite a lot of circumstances. Gender dysphoria clearly is a real thing, and children who suffer from it deserve all kinds of psychological and social support—the best we can possibly give. But by crediting the belief that in certain circumstances the body should change to reflect the psychology, we surely make dealing with it harder not easier, because that appears to offer a way out. I do not accept the logic behind the trial at all. I just do not understand it. As I have said, I recognise that others may take a different view on the nature of gender and sex differentiation. We live in a free society, of course—but it is a free society for adults, and we have a duty to protect children. In the previous debate we heard the Government saying they were banning sexualised chatbots for children under 18, presumably because they think children under 18 cannot deal with that sort of content. Surely, therefore, we must protect children from irreversible medical treatment, decided on at an age at which no reasonable person would think they could reasonably consent, even in a trial. I do not see how we can, in conscience, proceed with such a trial involving 11 year-olds. I experienced some of the Covid pandemic from the inside of government, more as an observer than a participant. I am afraid I learned from that period that sometimes the cleverest scientists and the most highly respected medical authorities could not see the wood for the trees, and ended up supporting things that were, I think, indefensible. We need to stick to principles sometimes, and one of my principles on this is that it is wrong to administer irreversible treatments to 11 and 12 year-olds. To be honest, I find it shocking and disgraceful that we can do it. It should be opposed in every way possible.

More from Lord Frost (Non-Afl)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.