Contribution
My Lords, I, too, congratulate the superb maiden speakers we have heard so far. I am sure that those yet to come will be equally excellent.
I wish to address a matter that ought not to be controversial in any civilised society: the right of women to privacy, dignity and safety in NHS services. For years, there has been a deliberate erosion of the rights of biological sex women across all parts of the health service, as men claiming to be women have occupied spaces specifically created for biological sex women. Different trusts have adopted different policies. Professional bodies have issued conflicting guidance. Many of them have stated that men calling themselves women but who have full male genitalia should have full access to women-only spaces. Women and NHS staff alike have often been left uncertain about their rights and responsibilities.
However, the legal position is now crystal clear. The Supreme Court has clarified the meaning of sex in law, and the Equality and Human Rights Commission’s statutory code has now come into force. The question before us is no longer what the law means; the question is whether the NHS intends to implement it or will continue to obfuscate. Despite the clarity provided by the courts and the statutory code, the NHS appears to be moving at a glacial pace. Guidance promised months ago has yet to provide the certainty that women and healthcare staff deserve. Trusts remain uncertain, patients remain uncertain and the risk of inconsistency remains widespread, as well as hostile action being taken against women who request single-sex provision.
Women should not have to argue for rights that Parliament has already recognised and the courts have already clarified. A woman of biological sex admitted to hospital should have confidence that a women’s ward is exactly that: a ward for women of biological sex. A woman receiving intimate care should be entitled, wherever reasonably practical, to request a female clinician or chaperone without being made to feel awkward, unreasonable or discriminatory. A woman who asks for female-only provision should never be criticised, stigmatised or treated as though she has committed a hate crime for daring to ask. Indeed, the evidence we have all seen in the past few years shows repeated cases where women and female NHS staff have suffered detriment, harassment or disparagement when raising concerns about sex-based facilities. That is wholly unacceptable in a modern health care system.
This is not about hostility towards any other group, since every citizen should be treated with dignity and respect, but rights based on gender identity cannot be allowed to erase rights based on biological sex. Parliament created single-sex exceptions for good reasons: for privacy, dignity, safety, cultural needs, religious needs and the protection of vulnerable patients. Those protections matter most when people are at their most vulnerable: ill, frightened, recovering from surgery, receiving intimate treatment or coping with trauma.
I therefore ask the Minister three straightforward questions. First, when will the Government publish definitive NHS guidelines implementing the laws clarified by the Supreme Court and reflected in the new EHRC code? Secondly, will that guidance make it clear that women are entitled to single-sex accommodation based on biological sex and that requests for female clinicians or chaperones should be respected wherever reasonably practicable? Thirdly, will the Government ensure that no woman and no NHS employee is subject to disadvantage, disciplinary action or accusations of prejudice simply for seeking or defending lawful single-sex provision? The time for consultation, delay and equivocation is over. The NHS now needs clear instructions, clear leadership and clear accountability to ensure that single-sex provision exists not merely in theory but in practice. The courts have spoken, the law has been clarified and women have waited long enough. The NHS must now obey the law.
Finally, a word about the Quality Care Commission mentioned in the Bill. In my experience, it is a useless waste of space, as the Public Services Committee pointed out a few years ago in our inquiry into home delivery of medicines. It has brought only about 100 criminal prosecutions in its history, and the overwhelming majority have been against private care homes and smaller providers, yet some of the greatest scandals in modern NHS history, involving hundreds of deaths, emerged without any prior criminal prosecution by the regulator. When a resident falls in a care home, the CQC rushes in to take action, but when systemic failure occurs across major NHS hospital trusts, the CQC arrives after the scandal rather than before it. In my opinion, it cannot be trusted to investigate NHS scandals unless it is beefed up in this Bill. There seems to be a cosy consensus between the health watchdog and the Department of Health never to investigate the NHS, almost like an old boys’ club in the past.
I look forward to the Minister’s reply on my points about single-sex provision and on my latter comments on the CQC.