B

Baroness Rafferty (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 13 October 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I, too, congratulate noble colleagues on the excellence and inspiring nature of their maiden speeches and look forward to those to come. I commend the Minister for introducing this Bill and promising a form of joined-up care on a scale that has eluded successive Governments. However, integration is not achieved by structural change alone. It is achieved when there are enough staff on the ground, with communities having a meaningful say in how that care is designed. I speak today as a district nurse and a former governor of a large NHS foundation trust. That is why I want to focus on two connected points: what the Bill’s changes to integrated care boards could mean for community nursing and what we risk losing when foundation trust governors are abolished. The Bill strengthens ICBs as strategic commissioners, and that ambition matters profoundly to community nursing. District nurses, specialist community nurses, health visitors—my colleague the noble Baroness, Lady Coffey, also flagged their importance—public health nurses and practice nurses care for people with complex needs in their own homes, care homes, schools and local clinics. They help people manage long-term conditions, recover from hospital, avoid unnecessary admissions and receive palliative care near the people and places that matter to them. According to the Nuffield Trust, the health think tank, district nurse numbers fell by 43% in full-time equivalent terms over the past 15 years from more than 7,500 to just under 4,500 in 2023-24, with a patient to population ratio of 1:14,000. When we talk about moving care from hospital to community, that shift needs enough skilled staff with enough time for visits, reliable access to equipment, clinical support, safe caseloads and proper investment. If hospital activity moves into the community without the workforce and resources moving with it, the result will be not integration but rather unmet needs transferred to patients, families and overstretched nurses. The Association of District Nurse & Community Nurse Educators has also registered its concern that the proposed reprocurement of community nursing education programmes may reduce the number of providers even further. The transfer of powers to the Secretary of State outlined in Clause 7 for education and training sets out a duty to ensure that there are sufficient people with appropriate education and training specifically to meet the workforce needs of the health service. It also requires that there is an effective system in place for the planning and delivery of education and training of people to meet those needs. In the light of this, can the Minister confirm that attention will be given to community nursing services as a matter of priority to stem the dwindling numbers and boost much-needed capacity? This brings me to the public voice. I will not reiterate the excellent points made by my noble friend Lord Hunt of Kings Heath, the noble Lord, Lord Patel, and others, but I just flag the value of volunteers as members or governors of foundation trusts. In my trust, there were over 1,000 volunteers, and they did excellent work and provided an invaluable source of soft intelligence for the board. Might the Minister be willing to reconsider the abolition of governors and undertake an evaluation of best practice case studies, so that expertise will not be lost in translation for the new arrangements which might eventuate? I hope these points will prove constructive in supporting the progress of the Bill and I look forward to working with the Minister to achieve that.

More from Baroness Rafferty (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.