B

Baroness Browning (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 13 October 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

My Lords, it is always a pleasure to follow the noble Baroness, and I add my congratulations on the maiden speeches that we have enjoyed and are going to enjoy today. I thank the Minister for the time she has spent in organising briefings for us on this Bill, which is very long, large and quite complex, but I support it in general. The single patient record is urgently needed, but I suspect will not be urgently delivered, so will the Minister, in the course of our deliberations, set out some sort of timetable? My anxiety—she is probably already aware of this—is that I can think of very few large government computer systems that have been an absolute joy to behold. I just wonder what she and her department are doing to make sure that the single patient record will be commissioned in such a way that we can all have confidence that, when it is available, it will work properly. We have heard already in this debate from the noble Baronesses, Lady Leaman and Lady Hollins, about the impact of this Bill in particular on people with learning disabilities and autism. The single patient record will be so important for anybody with a vulnerability. I hope that the Minister will countenance adding to the single patient record not just the key medical requirements that need to be on it, but also some of the other pieces of information that make all the difference to somebody with autism, for example. Many of them already have hospital passports which they take into hospital with them. We know that these are not just simple bits of trivial information. We know from reports from organisations such as Mencap that failure within hospitals in particular—not in mental health hospitals but on general wards—to fully understand how an individual with autism functions has led to deaths of very fit and able people who should never have died on a ward. I see the single patient record as a good step forward. I have some concerns about ICBs, because they are in a state of reorganisation at the moment. I worry about their ability to commission for areas that are particularly large; for example, if they contain large rural areas and some urban areas, the rural areas may get missed out in terms of the demography of their needs. I am particularly concerned because commissioning for end-of-life hospice care lies with the ICBs, and we know that hospices are under huge pressure at the moment. I was at a meeting earlier today on this very subject and was horrified to find that there are several hospices around the country with quite large numbers of empty beds—not because there are not patients for them, but because they cannot afford to fill those beds at the moment. We realise there is already a serious problem but, surely, if commissioning for a local community is the responsibility of these ICBs, we can at least get end-of-life care right—certainly at the very end of life, when palliative care and possibly hospice care are needed. At the moment, that does not seem to be working as it should. We know that very many people die on busy, noisy hospital wards when the reason they are still there at the point of death is that there have been no alternative arrangements for them. Death can come quite quickly. I am thinking of people with dementia and Alzheimer’s. You know that a diagnosis of Alzheimer’s is of a terminal illness, but very often the decline in the final weeks can be quite rapid. If that happens, very often that person is not in the right place to be cared for in the final weeks, sometimes days, and there is not time to move them. I hope that, as we progress with this Bill, we will have time to talk about these individual situations, because although this is the minutiae of the Bill, the devil is always in the detail.

More from Baroness Browning (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.