B

Baroness Janke (LD)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 13 October 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

My Lords, it is a great privilege to speak in this Second Reading debate. I congratulate noble Lords who have made their maiden speeches on their very eloquent remarks and look forward to hearing those that are still to come. Health services are a top priority across the nation, so I hope, as many noble Lords have said, that we can address our fellow citizens’ concerns through the progress of this Bill. Most people judge the quality of service on their own experience of front-line care, yet many have extreme difficulty even getting a timely doctor’s appointment. Anxiety and fear are the facts of life, particularly for elderly and vulnerable patients, who worry that they will not have proper access to healthcare when they need it. This is so much so that A&E has become the default destination for desperate patients who are unable to find timely care or advice from their local surgery. Analysis from the Health Foundation shows that, over the decade to 2022-24, healthy life expectancy in the UK fell by about two years, to 60.7 for males and 60.9 for females. Of 21 high-income nations analysed, the UK had the second-steepest decline. As other noble Lords have said, health inequalities are worsening. The gulf in healthy life expectancy between the most and least deprived parts of England is now 19.4 years for males and 20.3 years for females. Cuts to local authority services over more than a decade have severely limited public health services and their ability to effectively deliver policies that prevent sickness. Squeezed school budgets and staff cuts have led to less effective health education, while cuts to community healthcare professionals such as health visitors, school nurses, district nurses, dentists and optometrists have whittled away at community healthcare, with devastating effects. The proportion of young people reporting a health condition that limits their ability to work increased from 26% in 2015 to 44% in 2025. Local pharmacies, which have been the pillars of community health, are in widespread decline due to a £2 billion funding gap, with 45% relying on personal savings or remortgaging their homes just to keep their doors open to the public. We on this side welcome the focus on primary health care in the 10-year plan and the Prime Minister’s plans for devolution, but this Bill does not reflect these principles. It is a driver of greater centralisation and unprecedented powers to Ministers, as many noble Lords have said, at the expense of local involvement and accountability. To abolish Healthwatch is to lose the voice of patients and local communities, the very areas that need to be strengthened. No good reason has been given for this, and the abolition of the HSSIB, with transfer of its functions to the CQC, is not justified in the light of the well-documented shortcomings of the CQC. The vision of a well-resourced, community-based health service is very powerful, and what our residents want and need, but it is hard to see how the Bill before us will deliver the Government’s 10-year plan to shift from sickness to prevention and from hospital to communities with the current crisis in community and primary care. Where are all these devolved functions that we have been promised in the Cabinet statement Rewiring the State? We on this side will press the Government to address these fundamental problems throughout the progress of the Bill, including through more resourcing into primary care through a primary care investment standard. The King’s Fund echoes the thoughts of many people looking at this Bill from the point of view of the patients. For those on the outside looking in, these technocratic restructures might look like rearranging the deckchairs on the Titanic while many core problems around the nation’s health remain unresolved. Every minute spent navigating reorganisation is a minute not spent planning and delivering high-quality healthcare, which is what we all want.

More from Baroness Janke (LD)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.