B

Baroness Sugg (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 13 October 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I am grateful to the Minister for setting out the Government’s approach to the Bill, and to other noble Lords who have shared their significant wisdom and experience, be that through long-term careers in the health service or their lived experience of previous health Bills and NHS reorganisation. I particularly welcome the maiden speeches we have heard and those to come. I am sure that all noble Lords share the desire to ensure that the modernisation and reform of healthcare leads to better outcomes for patients and a more productive, efficient and accountable NHS, and improves value for taxpayers’ money. In the time available, I will focus on three issues relating to women’s health; I know that, in her role as Women’s Health Minister, the Minister has a clear focus on this. I turn first to the Government’s commitment to introduce an amendment to the Bill to appoint a maternity and neonatal commissioner. As the Minister stated, this was a recommendation from the final report of the national maternity and neonatal review, led by the noble Baroness, Lady Amos. The Minister will be well aware of the many reports identifying systemic failures in maternity care, alongside repeated recommendations that have yet to be implemented. It is therefore unsurprising that the latest survey from Savanta, published last weekend, found that 75% of adults are concerned about standards of maternity care in NHS hospitals. The maternity and neonatal commissioner must have the power and resources needed to deliver the national action plan, which we expect in December, and which the Government say will “overhaul services and drive long-term change”. Can the Minister tell us when the amendment on the commissioner is likely to be tabled, to ensure that your Lordships have sufficient time to scrutinise it properly in Committee? The second issue I will focus on is the single patient record. As the King’s Fund has observed, the single patient record presents a significant opportunity to improve people’s experiences of health and care by bringing together fragmented information and giving patients full access to their records. I am grateful to the Minister and her department for the helpful meetings and briefings provided ahead of this debate. However, much of the detail will be set out in secondary legislation. There are understandable concerns around privacy, public trust, access, data governance and NHS interoperability. Until greater detail is available, questions will remain for patients and healthcare professionals. The Minister acknowledged this in her opening speech, and I was interested in the idea of the noble Lord, Lord Patel, on this issue. I have a particular interest in privacy, especially around sexual and reproductive healthcare and other sensitive treatments, such as for mental health, addiction and, as we have heard from my noble friend Lord Black, HIV. The SPR could significantly improve patient experience and eligibility decisions by reducing reliance on patients recounting complex medical histories. However, patients may not wish to share every aspect of their healthcare and see every aspect of that history appearing within a standardised record or being readily available and accessible through a mobile device, albeit with a password. These concerns are particularly acute for women and girls at risk of domestic abuse or honour-based abuse, for young people under 16, and for patients whose close relatives or associates work in the NHS. It is important to protect the long-standing right of patients to access sexual healthcare and related services anonymously, and the role this plays in providing inclusive public health services. While I recognise that these matters will be addressed through secondary legislation, it would be helpful to understand how the regulations will be developed and consulted on. In particular, can the Minister provide any reassurance that explicit patient opt-in consent, on a by-episode basis, will be considered before highly sensitive records are included within the SPR, with patients retaining the ability to withdraw that consent at any point? I also echo the request of my noble friend Lady Browning for a timetable around the delivery of SPR. Finally, I turn to other measures in the Bill related to women’s health. The move towards ICB commissioning may well create opportunities to tailor services more effectively to local needs. However, a key concern is whether women’s health will remain a national priority, rather than access to services varying according to where women live. An amendment to the Bill on implementation of the women’s health strategy was tabled in the other place. Six months have now passed since the publication of the refreshed plan, yet progress on its 117 actions appears limited. An amendment was also considered on ensuring that waiting times for gynaecology and women’s health do not exceed average NHS waiting times. Gynaecology waiting lists have increased for five consecutive months, with more than 585,000 women in England currently waiting for care and less than 60% being seen within the 18-week target, which is well over the average for other NHS treatments. These issues deserve consideration as we scrutinise the Bill. I recognise that our scrutiny ought to remain firmly on the contents of this Bill and we should resist turning it into a vehicle for every worthy cause, but we cannot allow women’s health to be treated as an afterthought in the reform and modernisation of our health service. Whether through maternity safety, digital patient records or the delivery of the women’s health strategy, these issues must remain central to the Bill’s scrutiny and implementation. I look forward to working constructively with this Government as the Bill progresses.

More from Baroness Sugg (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.