Contribution
My Lords, many congratulations to all our maiden speakers today. It is a special pleasure to follow the exceptional maiden speech of my noble friend Lord Smith of Ranmoor. His CV reads like the making of modern British food standards, but his emphasis on obesity means that I cannot now say that all of us who enjoy eating are very grateful to him.
A son of Sheffield and an alum of Leeds University, of which he is obviously extremely proud, my noble friend started his career at Northern Foods. He was appointed to the Food Standards Agency as CEO in 2008, after which he accepted a senior role at Tesco. He is now chair of Cranswick plc and one of the UK’s most experienced people in food retail.
Throughout his work with several Governments across parties, my noble friend has chaired the Trade and Agriculture Commission and has been co-chair of the Food and Drink Sector Council, among other significant posts. He is also a trustee of Natasha’s Foundation, the food allergy charity, which is very important in food safety today. I am sure all noble Lords will welcome my noble friend’s immense experience to our House and look forward to his many contributions to come.
I usually stay away from giving my opinion on health Bills; it is not my area of expertise and the NHS is challenged enough without my tuppence-worth. However, I could not stop myself with the Bill in front of us, because I was struck by its plan to enhance patient safety and the patient’s experience through a new single patient record—long in the making, as my noble friend Lady Jay said.
This record could transform patient care. As long as safeguards exist against cyber attacks and AI going rogue, and as long as transparency is always at the forefront of our mind with the creation of this record, patients will welcome it as much as we do tonight. I welcome my noble friend the Minister’s commitment to this specific part of the Bill in her opening remarks.
I support the Bill and its ambition. Of course, it has its critics. The trade union UNISON is concerned that the 10-year plan, which the Bill will make law, could produce a larger role for private healthcare. The Patients Association, while welcoming the Bill’s stated intention to put patients first and reduce bureaucracy, points out—as many noble Lords have—that
“any period of organisational change risks distracting from immediate patient care”.
I am sure my noble friend the Minister, who has a well-earned reputation for listening, will be aware of such concerns and will address them in her summing up.
As vice-president of RoSPA, the Royal Society for the Prevention of Accidents, along with the noble Baroness, Lady Watkins of Tavistock, and the noble Lord, Lord Jordan, our president, I saw in the proposed single patient record an opportunity for far more accurate and meaningful data than is currently the case: data from across the health service, to be used more effectively for patients’ well-being. As noble Lords will know, RoSPA’s mission is to campaign to prevent serious injury and save lives. However, as it stands, injury prevention is hindered by fragmented, incomplete and inconsistent NHS data. Data is often missing or provides only surface-level detail, which makes comprehensive injury prevention policies extremely difficult. As we know, information on injuries comes from multiple sources and agencies: hospitals, ambulance services, primary care, public health data, and so on. The Bill’s new information-sharing powers create a real opportunity not merely to further modernise digital records—to be fair, the old digital record has not always gone super smoothly—but to provide a stronger and safer evidence base for the prevention of accidents.
I will give noble Lords a couple of current examples. According to the latest NHS data, in 2024, seven people were admitted to hospital as a result of being bitten by a crocodile, two people were admitted for being bitten by a scorpion, and 53 people for being bitten by a rat. Three people were the victims of a volcanic eruption and 22 people were admitted to hospital due to a long stay in a weightless environment—I do not know what that means either. However, when it comes to falls, which are the biggest cause of accidental death and injury in this country, more than a third of admissions are recorded simply as “unspecified”. It cannot be right that we know more about injuries caused by crocodiles than we do about hundreds of thousands of falls, many of them affecting our ever-ageing population. During the passage of the Bill, will my noble friend the Minister meet me, the noble Baroness, Lady Watkins, and perhaps representatives of RoSPA to discuss how the Bill will improve the quality of injury data and, in doing so, enable prevention, save lives and reduce avoidable pressure on our overstretched NHS?